Page 1 of 1

Thank you!

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 11:56 am
by Anonymous User
Thank you!

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 7:50 pm
by Anonymous User
Bump! I'd love any help!

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 7:55 pm
by blueberrycrumble
IMO, the whole first paragraph is either entirely unnecessary or could be reduced to one sentence. Is this your version of "Why law" from the Duke prompt? You are going to need to discuss something more specific than this.

Would take out "While professional obligations prohibit me from visiting until after my application is submitted"; You didn't visit but there's no reason to specifically mention that fact.

The entire second paragraph says almost nothing, except the "LEAD" thing? Not sure what this is, but you're going to need to connect with it in a more personal way than "fits my academic experiences and strengths" and the fact that your undergrad has a "rigorous" program.

"Over one hundred Fortune 500 companies are headquartered in the South" - wouldn't say this either.

Writing is good, but it's mostly about nothing...

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 8:05 pm
by Anonymous User
blueberrycrumble wrote:IMO, the whole first paragraph is either entirely unnecessary or could be reduced to one sentence. Is this your version of "Why law" from the Duke prompt? You are going to need to discuss something more specific than this.
I definitely need help with this. I don't have any experience with the legal system, so what's the best way to write something specific? It seems like a trap question unless it's fine to discuss my reasoning in more abstract terms. I want a career path that is challenging, requires a blend of intellectual and interpersonal skills, and serves/impacts others. Why law? Because it matches those goals and, moreover, involves a field that I believe is undergirds and advances our society.

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 8:15 pm
by blueberrycrumble
Anonymous User wrote:
blueberrycrumble wrote:IMO, the whole first paragraph is either entirely unnecessary or could be reduced to one sentence. Is this your version of "Why law" from the Duke prompt? You are going to need to discuss something more specific than this.
I definitely need help with this. I don't have any experience with the legal system, so what's the best way to write something specific? It seems like a trap question unless it's fine to discuss my reasoning in more abstract terms. I want a career path that is challenging, requires a blend of intellectual and interpersonal skills, and serves/impacts others. Why law? Because it matches those goals and, moreover, involves a field that I believe is undergirds and advances our society.
That's not a very good reason... you may find that your actual job may not be all that intellectual, interpersonal nor will you necessarily serve others.

For example, I wrote about a specific internship experience I had where I did work that used skills that would apply to law school, and where the subject matter (while not law) is related to law.

Anyway, do you have any experiences that led you to law school? Could be something you actively did or some event that has impacted you. Or is there any specific area of law that you want to pursue? Why? Ex: someone might have environment related work or volunteer experience and therefore wants to pursue environmental law

Regardless, the Why Duke should mostly be about Duke; I just included one paragraph about Why Law.

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 9:13 pm
by EarthdogFred
Are your numbers at or above Duke's medians? If so, some iteration of this should be fine. Otherwise, we need something more provocative.

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 9:18 pm
by Anonymous User
EarthdogFred wrote:Are your numbers at or above Duke's medians? If so, some iteration of this should be fine. Otherwise, we need something more provocative.
Comfortably above both 75ths.

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 9:23 pm
by blueberrycrumble
EarthdogFred wrote:Are your numbers at or above Duke's medians? If so, some iteration of this should be fine. Otherwise, we need something more provocative.
I actually disagree with this since OP is above both 75ths; we've seen a bit of YP going on already with priority reserves, so I think writing at least a semi-compelling Why Duke is important if you actually want to go.

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Mon Nov 10, 2014 9:24 pm
by Anonymous User
blueberrycrumble wrote:
EarthdogFred wrote:Are your numbers at or above Duke's medians? If so, some iteration of this should be fine. Otherwise, we need something more provocative.
I actually disagree with this since OP is above both 75ths; we've seen a bit of YP going on already with priority reserves, so I think writing at least a semi-compelling Why Duke is important if you actually want to go.
I didn't receive a PT invite, if that indicates anything.

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2014 12:04 pm
by Anonymous User
Is this a better version?

Re: "Why" Duke Law (Optional Essay #1)

Posted: Tue Nov 11, 2014 5:32 pm
by Anonymous User
Bump :D

Help is appreciated so much!!!