Top Law Schools

For most things as important as this PS, I'd get help from an expert. However, TLS users have suggested that simply posting to TLS is more helpful than using an admissions consultant (and free). But it seems maybe TLS is more helpful for critiquing a rough draft than for brainstorming a topic. Any thoughts?

giuseppes12 wrote:For most things as important as this PS, I'd get help from an expert. However, TLS users have suggested that simply posting to TLS is more helpful than using an admissions consultant (and free). But it seems maybe TLS is more helpful for critiquing a rough draft than for brainstorming a topic. Any thoughts?

If you can't come up with ANYthing on your own...

TLS:
+ Lots of great advice, good sense of what admissions look for
+ Variety of opinions
+ Full of overachievers who probably had decent PS's themselves
- People here may not be as "nice" as you'd like. Even if feedback is what you need to hear, if you're at all sensitive to criticism, probably not a good idea.
- Bunch of different (& probably conflicting) opinions at once, rather than someone guiding you steadily thru the process (the fact that you posted this Q makes me guess that's what you need)

Admissions Consultant:
+ Personalized attention often yields better results
+ Doesn't troll
- Not free (granted, PS is important)
- Sounds like a scam artist. What are their qualifications?? (rhetorical Q)

it completely depends on how skilled a writer you are..if you are at least decent at writing..just use tls...if you suck however, nobody on tls is gonna be moivated enough to give you the help you need, so you should prob get professional help.

Bottom line, good writer, tls is fine, bad writer, get help

Do you have a pre-law advisor? Mine had worked in admissions offices before and helped me a lot with mine. I didn't post my PS on TLS and I didn't pay anyone to read it and I did fine.