PLEASE rip my PS apart. Need as much critique as possible.
Posted: Mon Feb 27, 2012 3:58 pm
.
Law School Discussion Forums
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=179156
This whole section is an over-generalization, highly presumptive, and honestly over dramatic. Seriously, you really believe it to be "devastating"I have also been known to be mature beyond my years by elder people. Undoubtedly, this was a result of my challenging childhood. Constantly aware of my family’s financial situation, I would repeatedly have to learn the discipline of not asking my parents for things I desired. Most children, when asking for and being denied something they want, will turn the disappointment they feel into anger. Anger towards the people they feel are responsible for these disgusting feelings which have arisen within them; their parents. This coping mechanism is soothing to children and allows them to maintain a certain naivety and innocent outlook on life for many years. I, however, was not able to hold onto either for long. Not having a “face” to put to these despairing feelings forced me to search further than “my parents don’t want me to be happy and that is why I do not have my new toy” for answers. This profound and chronic experience, while confusing and devastating in my younger years, led me to have a mature outlook on life from an early age.
sound so, superficial to the issue of being less fortunate. The quotations do not help avoid this fact.I have a strong compassion for the less-fortunate due to the fact that, at one point, “less-fortunate” was to be my fortune.
Way to totally trivialize the impact you may have had on these people. Wouldnt it be more powerful to say you recognized how much of an impact assisting someone with a simple task like explaining legalize had on their ability to see justice in their personal lives?This is what led me to internship at a legal aid clinic during college. It was here that I lost my idealistic and naïve notion that becoming a lawyer and fighting in court for a few indigent or oppressed people would do anything substantial.
....... oh my, first the allusion is odd and does not add to anything, nor does it relate well to the theme or content, but then you put a tangent in parenthesis for no reason.The image that always arose in my mind was that of the Ecclesia of Athens (in my mind, however, for whatever reason, I would be fervently addressing the assembly in modern clothes rather than a toga).
The topic is fine considering it is probably the most popular topic to write a PS about. However, the grammatical errors are definitely frequent as well as sentence structure issues.mehereuthere101787 wrote:do you see issues with format only or topic as well?benburns214 wrote:Needs to be completely rewritten or taken to a writing center.
Also, for future reference, any number less than 10 is to be written as the actual word and not just the number. (ex "4 = four")
TITCR. In reference to your question, I wrote about debate, and traveling the world, although this is perhaps less useful as a model.bee wrote:The format is a little meandering and irrational, but the topic also has problems in that it's not very cohesive. I would suggest trying to focus in on something you feel is important, and be very specific, instead of trying to lay out your whole life story. Sorry if I come off a little too critical.mehereuthere101787 wrote:I'm beginning to think my skin is not as tough as I once believed haha. Thanks for your honesty though, it is definitely welcomed.bee wrote:If you want complete honesty, here it is: scrap it and start over. Your tone is much too informal, a lot of the structure makes no sense, the flow of the statement is stilted, it's not very clear what point, exactly, you're trying to make, and there are a lot of awkward turns of phrase e.g. "elder people." I agree with a lot of the points the post above mines makes, and also want to add that I would consider parantheses--or, at least, the way you use them--to be inappropriate for a personal statement.
Good luck with revisions and come back with another version.
do you think I should scrap the format and structure or the topic altogether? if you mean the latter, could you please explain why it doesn't work? thanks!