Page 1 of 1

8th (and hopefully better) draft. More critique, please!

Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 12:47 am
by restless
.

Re: 8th (and hopefully better) draft. More critique, please!

Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 4:58 am
by mikstew
You write well.

this is a minor detail but: I love your use of words, quite poetic, so in keeping with your style, why not swap alter (line 2) with something a bit more descriptive (blur, distort). In fact you can get rid of lines, too, if you'd like. "Undulating heat waves blur my vision"

Although I do not always practice what I preach, in your last line, go out with a bang: swap HOPE with WILL

cheers

Re: 8th (and hopefully better) draft. More critique, please!

Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 5:35 am
by 1evilo.aihpos
mikstew wrote:You write well.

this is a minor detail but: I love your use of words, quite poetic, so in keeping with your style, why not swap alter (line 2) with something a bit more descriptive (blur, distort). In fact you can get rid of lines, too, if you'd like. "Undulating heat waves blur my vision"

Although I do not always practice what I preach, in your last line, go out with a bang: swap HOPE with WILL
cheers

i liked it also

Re: 8th (and hopefully better) draft. More critique, please!

Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 11:55 am
by KHM101010
i thought this was great. you write so well.

although we have very different stories, i feel like it comes from a very similar place. I also dealt with losing someone i trusted and eventually finding peace of mind when i studied abroad--coming back stronger than ever. i'm actually having a hard time with my statement, and after reading yours, see how much tweaking mine needs. i hope you don't mind-- i'd like to use yours as inspiration!

would love it if you critiqued mine actually if you had the time--i'm so impressed! good luck!

Re: 8th (and hopefully better) draft. More critique, please!

Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 12:20 pm
by LSATclincher
This is better than the previous, but there are some issues:

- Eliminate the one word sentence in para 1.
- Eliminate queer language: undulating, motley, re-interested, familial
- Edit the final 2 sentences. Keep it general. Avoid "your program" and "your school." Use a phrase like "legal profession" or "path towards a career in law" or "journey towards a legal career"
- Overall, you have a nice story. I'd still recommend toning the language down, and making it less literary and more professional. You can do this and still create a wonderful story. It just takes many hours of editing, and help from many people.