Page 1 of 1
Second draft PS - give it a read?
Posted: Tue Dec 07, 2010 10:50 pm
by vissidarte27
Nothin' to see here.
Re: Second draft PS - give it a read?
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2010 1:35 pm
by vissidarte27
Bump?
Re: Second draft PS - give it a read?
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2010 3:20 pm
by aesis
From a quick look, I would say:
- Cut the intro about "why law." It's distracting and not very well executed anyway.
- Cut out everything related to LSAT -- it's irrelevant and detracts from a clear message.
- This reads like a newspaper article. Why? They want to read a PS, with thematic, cohesive paragraphs. Breaking them should be for rhetorical effect, which you do only once: "I hated myself."
- Your motif of music being a liberating mechanism for your sexuality is not as clear as it could be. The topic shift seems abrupt, and the incentive/motivation/impetus -- no matter how true it may be -- seems artificial. Just my opinion though.
- the chronology is distorted because you talk about dating men in college then revert to your musical revelation at 17
Good things:
- personal struggle with homophobia and societal pressure (but I hated the "societal and legal world" phrase)
- the musical details are great, speaks to how well-versed you are in music
- "it gets better" theme motif
- conclusion is good
Solutions:
Each paragraph should establish a point, leading to your decision since this is the main point of your PS (I struggled, I overcame , how I overcame, I want to help others like me overcome). Weave the music into the LGBTQ narrative elegantly and logically.
In many ways, you have the opportunity to write something bigger than a why I want to go to law school. With material as rich as this I would opt to remove law school from the PS entirely and instead refocus the statement a bit to depict your sexual maturation exclusively and reflect on its importance and implications for other LGBTQ individuals. Just my opinion. The Why Law fits fine anyhow.
Good luck!
Re: Second draft PS - give it a read?
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2010 3:24 pm
by CanadianWolf
Well written & convincing.
Re: Second draft PS - give it a read?
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2010 6:08 pm
by quetzal_bird
I agree with aesis's advice. I will say, however, I was still engrossed. It's not perfect yet, but the story is beautiful