Page 1 of 1

Michigan - "it is not in our practice to negotiate merit"

Posted: Tue Mar 22, 2011 6:22 pm
by neonx
How true is the above statement?
Can you leverage after being given a Dean's?

Re: Michigan - "it is not in our practice to negotiate merit"

Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2011 2:22 am
by pixytree
neonx wrote:How true is the above statement?
Can you leverage after being given a Dean's?
What do you have to leverage?

Re: Michigan - "it is not in our practice to negotiate merit"

Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2011 2:56 am
by neonx
NYU: RTK finalist, if not then (~$50,000-$75,000)
Penn: $61,500
UVA: $75,000
UCLA: $91,000
Texas: $69,000
USC: Rothman finalist
Waiting on Columbia, Duke & Cornell packages.
Full-rides from WUSTL down (more or less).
(see profile for specific #s).

Michigan gave me $30,000.
Do I have a valid case to leverage?
If so, how do I go about doing it when the letter explicitly states they won't negotiate merit aid . . .

Re: Michigan - "it is not in our practice to negotiate merit"

Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2011 4:48 pm
by pixytree
neonx wrote:NYU: RTK finalist, if not then (~$50,000-$75,000)
Penn: $61,500
UVA: $75,000
UCLA: $91,000
Texas: $69,000
USC: Rothman finalist
Waiting on Columbia, Duke & Cornell packages.
Full-rides from WUSTL down (more or less).
(see profile for specific #s).

Michigan gave me $30,000.
Do I have a valid case to leverage?
If so, how do I go about doing it when the letter explicitly states they won't negotiate merit aid . . .
is it a school you really want or are you jsut trying to see if they'll give you more money? You definitely have leverage to negotiate. Just call them up or email them and let them that you want to attend (and why) but considering the COA at Michigan and the offers you've gotten from other schools, you would not be able to attend given the current scholarship offer. And ask if they'd be willing to reconsider your scholarship offer or offer other grants. There are a ton of posts on negotiating, do a search. They don't officially negotiate, but all schools will reconsider if it's a candidate they really want and that wants them.

I would advise against just chasing money offers at every school and try to narrow your list to schools you really want to attend.

Re: Michigan - "it is not in our practice to negotiate merit"

Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2011 4:54 pm
by glewz
holy crap how in the...... with a 166-168 and 3.8X

Re: Michigan - "it is not in our practice to negotiate merit"

Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2011 5:02 pm
by neonx
pixytree wrote:
neonx wrote:NYU: RTK finalist, if not then (~$50,000-$75,000)
Penn: $61,500
UVA: $75,000
UCLA: $91,000
Texas: $69,000
USC: Rothman finalist
Waiting on Columbia, Duke & Cornell packages.
Full-rides from WUSTL down (more or less).
(see profile for specific #s).

Michigan gave me $30,000.
Do I have a valid case to leverage?
If so, how do I go about doing it when the letter explicitly states they won't negotiate merit aid . . .
is it a school you really want or are you jsut trying to see if they'll give you more money? You definitely have leverage to negotiate. Just call them up or email them and let them that you want to attend (and why) but considering the COA at Michigan and the offers you've gotten from other schools, you would not be able to attend given the current scholarship offer. And ask if they'd be willing to reconsider your scholarship offer or offer other grants. There are a ton of posts on negotiating, do a search. They don't officially negotiate, but all schools will reconsider if it's a candidate they really want and that wants them.

I would advise against just chasing money offers at every school and try to narrow your list to schools you really want to attend.
Thank you for this incredibly sound advice. I very much appreciate it

I am very interested in Michigan (if I weren't, I wouldn't've applied), but their $ would have to top Virginia's $75,000 for me to even seriously consider them at this point in time. I will pursue this and tell you how it goes!

Re: Michigan - "it is not in our practice to negotiate merit"

Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2011 11:46 pm
by pixytree
good luck!

Re: Michigan - "it is not in our practice to negotiate merit"

Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2011 9:37 am
by SupraVln180
neonx wrote:
pixytree wrote:
neonx wrote:NYU: RTK finalist, if not then (~$50,000-$75,000)
Penn: $61,500
UVA: $75,000
UCLA: $91,000
Texas: $69,000
USC: Rothman finalist
Waiting on Columbia, Duke & Cornell packages.
Full-rides from WUSTL down (more or less).
(see profile for specific #s).

Michigan gave me $30,000.
Do I have a valid case to leverage?
If so, how do I go about doing it when the letter explicitly states they won't negotiate merit aid . . .
is it a school you really want or are you jsut trying to see if they'll give you more money? You definitely have leverage to negotiate. Just call them up or email them and let them that you want to attend (and why) but considering the COA at Michigan and the offers you've gotten from other schools, you would not be able to attend given the current scholarship offer. And ask if they'd be willing to reconsider your scholarship offer or offer other grants. There are a ton of posts on negotiating, do a search. They don't officially negotiate, but all schools will reconsider if it's a candidate they really want and that wants them.

I would advise against just chasing money offers at every school and try to narrow your list to schools you really want to attend.
Thank you for this incredibly sound advice. I very much appreciate it

I am very interested in Michigan (if I weren't, I wouldn't've applied), but their $ would have to top Virginia's $75,000 for me to even seriously consider them at this point in time. I will pursue this and tell you how it goes!
How did you pull off that cycle? Are you Mark Zuckerburg or something? Don't get me wrong, you have great numbers, but not THATT great. Congrats on a beast cycle, and Michigan should match UVa. E-mail first, then call if e-mail isn't going well (or fast enough).