Page 1 of 4

Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 4:39 pm
by Xixak
Would I be considered a URM?

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 4:53 pm
by Ded Precedent
Flame.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 5:06 pm
by bosmer88
OP, assuming you are talking about American law schools, I think you would be considered international, thus you wouldn't get as big of a bump, if any at all.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 5:39 pm
by Xixak
bosmer88 wrote:OP, assuming you are talking about American law schools, I think you would be considered international, thus you wouldn't get as big of a bump, if any at all.
Yeah I am talking about American schools. So they would just treat me like any other applicant eh?

Btw to the first poster... I'm not flaming just asking an honest question.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 5:46 pm
by bosmer88
Xixak wrote:
bosmer88 wrote:OP, assuming you are talking about American law schools, I think you would be considered international, thus you wouldn't get as big of a bump, if any at all.
Yeah I am talking about American schools. So they would just treat me like any other applicant eh?

Btw to the first poster... I'm not flaming just asking an honest question.
I can't say for sure you wouldn't get any boost. I do believe though that if you got any type of boost, it wouldn't be as substantial if you were a us citizen/resident/etc.

Are you or your parents recent immigrants? If so, you could use the background/experiences in a DS.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 5:50 pm
by JamMasterJ
not African American bro

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 5:54 pm
by Xixak
bosmer88 wrote:
Xixak wrote:
bosmer88 wrote:OP, assuming you are talking about American law schools, I think you would be considered international, thus you wouldn't get as big of a bump, if any at all.
Yeah I am talking about American schools. So they would just treat me like any other applicant eh?

Btw to the first poster... I'm not flaming just asking an honest question.
I can't say for sure you wouldn't get any boost. I do believe though that if you got any type of boost, it wouldn't be as substantial if you were a us citizen/resident/etc.

Are you or your parents recent immigrants? If so, you could use the background/experiences in a DS.
No we've been here for quite some time. I guess they don't care that I'm black if I'm from another country eh?

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 6:03 pm
by bosmer88
Xixak wrote:
bosmer88 wrote:
Xixak wrote:
bosmer88 wrote:OP, assuming you are talking about American law schools, I think you would be considered international, thus you wouldn't get as big of a bump, if any at all.
Yeah I am talking about American schools. So they would just treat me like any other applicant eh?

Btw to the first poster... I'm not flaming just asking an honest question.
I can't say for sure you wouldn't get any boost. I do believe though that if you got any type of boost, it wouldn't be as substantial if you were a us citizen/resident/etc.

Are you or your parents recent immigrants? If so, you could use the background/experiences in a DS.
No we've been here for quite some time. I guess they don't care that I'm black if I'm from another country eh?
The URM bump as used by US law schools is supposed to benefit US citizens and residents. I'd get that if you came to the US, you'd likely be indiscernible from any other black person living in the US, but that is the way it works.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 6:12 pm
by Xixak
Guess no URM boost. So with my projected 3.65 GPA im screwed out of the T-6 unless i get a 180 LSAT.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 6:32 pm
by JamMasterJ
Xixak wrote:Guess no URM boost. So with my projected 3.65 GPA im screwed out of the T-6 unless i get a 180 LSAT.
172-3

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 6:36 pm
by bosmer88
I actually think you have a decent GPA. My best advice is to score as high as you can on the LSAT (170+ is ideal). It is pretty hard to gauge where you fall without a LSAT score. You might want to check out lsn and look at international applicants to get a sense of their scores and where they ended up. Additionally, everything else in your application needs to be *stellar*. Make sure you have glowing LORS (possibly school specific if you can), a well-written PS and DS with no errors, and make sure you follow all the directions outlined in a school's application.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 8:38 pm
by jas1503
Ignore some of these comments.

Truthfully, you don't even have to be black to claim black-URM status.

Being from Canada doesn't make any difference at all.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 8:49 pm
by ManoftheHour
jas1503 wrote:Ignore some of these comments.

Truthfully, you don't even have to be black to claim black-URM status.

Being from Canada doesn't make any difference at all.
But affirmative action was created to right the wrongs of the past to create a more even playing field for those who were wronged in this country. That is why African/Native AMERICANS get the boost and international students don't.

Many minorities start off at a disadvantage because the state of their ancestors was not ideal.

This does not apply to international students.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 9:06 pm
by jas1503
ManoftheHour wrote:
jas1503 wrote:Ignore some of these comments.

Truthfully, you don't even have to be black to claim black-URM status.

Being from Canada doesn't make any difference at all.
But affirmative action was created to right the wrongs of the past to create a more even playing field for those who were wronged in this country. That is why African/Native AMERICANS get the boost and international students don't.

Many minorities start off at a disadvantage because the state of their ancestors was not ideal.

This does not apply to international students.
I'm assuming that "being wronged" in this country means that you're talking about slavery and segregation for African Americans; and for the very, very few Native Americans left, the wrong you're talking about has to do with the wars lost that resulted in much of their land being taken.

Can you explain to me what the Mexican, Cuban, PR boost is for? Is it the Encomienda? By your logic, why isn't Spain giving out this boost instead?

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 9:11 pm
by JamMasterJ
Let's not AA debate and just note that a) policy exists b) it doesn't apply to non-Americans.

I have a friend who was born in Mexico, but is now married to an American - got the URM boost. It is what it is - a proxy

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 9:23 pm
by Xixak
Really sucks to not get the URM boost. Reminds me of my undergrad admissions where I had a 4.0 2260 but got rejected from every top 20 US School I applied to :/

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 15, 2013 9:28 pm
by ManoftheHour
jas1503 wrote:
ManoftheHour wrote:
jas1503 wrote:Ignore some of these comments.

Truthfully, you don't even have to be black to claim black-URM status.

Being from Canada doesn't make any difference at all.
But affirmative action was created to right the wrongs of the past to create a more even playing field for those who were wronged in this country. That is why African/Native AMERICANS get the boost and international students don't.

Many minorities start off at a disadvantage because the state of their ancestors was not ideal.

This does not apply to international students.
I'm assuming that "being wronged" in this country means that you're talking about slavery and segregation for African Americans; and for the very, very few Native Americans left, the wrong you're talking about has to do with the wars lost that resulted in much of their land being taken.

Can you explain to me what the Mexican, Cuban, PR boost is for? Is it the Encomienda? By your logic, why isn't Spain giving out this boost instead?
I'm not saying that's my logic. I'm not even saying I believe in or don't believe in AA. This is all irrelevant to OP. Not trying to incite any AA debates around here. I'm saying that that is probably THE logic that the schools are going by. I don't know if Spain is giving this boost instead. They might, they might not. But we're not talking about Spanish schools so I'm not sure what you're trying to get out of that question.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 29, 2013 2:35 pm
by Xixak
:( Really wish I got this boost.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 29, 2013 3:38 pm
by twenty
Xixak wrote::( Really wish I got this boost.
Xixak wrote:Guess no URM boost.
Xixak wrote:Really sucks to not get the URM boost.
maybe if you wish really hard!

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 29, 2013 4:44 pm
by soj
What's everyone talking about? Black international students do get the AA bump.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 29, 2013 4:46 pm
by John_rizzy_rawls
soj wrote:What's everyone talking about? Black international students do get the AA bump.
This thread is what's wrong with the on-topics lately. Everyone thinks they're a hilarious troll and it impedes on giving decent advice to people legitimately asking for it.

Yes OP, you are considered a URM. It's the reason the box asks if you are Black/African-American, because those two can be different things and in your case you're the former.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 29, 2013 4:50 pm
by John_rizzy_rawls
Note of advice to people ITT: don't immediately call out flame (it's not funny or productive), and don't give advice if you don't actually know the answer. Also, debating AA in the on-topics is not okay, there's a thread for that. Thanks.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 29, 2013 5:05 pm
by soj
bosmer88 wrote:The URM bump as used by US law schools is supposed to benefit US citizens and residents. I'd get that if you came to the US, you'd likely be indiscernible from any other black person living in the US, but that is the way it works.
ManoftheHour wrote:But affirmative action was created to right the wrongs of the past to create a more even playing field for those who were wronged in this country. That is why African/Native AMERICANS get the boost and international students don't.

Many minorities start off at a disadvantage because the state of their ancestors was not ideal.

This does not apply to international students.
Call me cynical, but there's nothing law schools care less about than redressing past racial wrongs. They care about statistical or visible diversity. Black Canadians do get the URM bump. I don't know about Canadian First Nations because they so rarely apply to US law schools, but I would guess they get the bump, too.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 29, 2013 5:35 pm
by twenty
Maybe I'm completely wrong on this, but it seems like URMs get "the boost" if they go to US undergrads. There are "URMs" from international undergrads on LSN that sure as hell didn't get any kind of substantial boost, or else wrote naughty words in their PS.

Re: Black Canadian?

Posted: Wed May 29, 2013 5:48 pm
by indo
ManoftheHour wrote:
jas1503 wrote:Ignore some of these comments.

Truthfully, you don't even have to be black to claim black-URM status.

Being from Canada doesn't make any difference at all.
But affirmative action was created to right the wrongs of the past to create a more even playing field for those who were wronged in this country. That is why African/Native AMERICANS get the boost and international students don't.

Many minorities start off at a disadvantage because the state of their ancestors was not ideal.

This does not apply to international students.
So how long this and future generation has to pay for the sins of their forefather ?
How about Chinese were mistreated / wrong in USA too when they built the railroads ?
How come the chineses do not the boost ?