Possibly racist professor - What to do? Forum
Forum rules
Anonymous Posting
Anonymous posting is only appropriate when you are sharing sensitive information about bar exam prep. You may anonymously respond on topic to these threads. Unacceptable uses include: harassing another user, joking around, testing the feature, or other things that are more appropriate in the lounge.
Failure to follow these rules will get you outed, warned, or banned."
Anonymous Posting
Anonymous posting is only appropriate when you are sharing sensitive information about bar exam prep. You may anonymously respond on topic to these threads. Unacceptable uses include: harassing another user, joking around, testing the feature, or other things that are more appropriate in the lounge.
Failure to follow these rules will get you outed, warned, or banned."
-
- Posts: 292
- Joined: Thu Mar 11, 2010 3:39 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
It annoys me to no end that racial-profiling whites are the entire reason behind "the talk" that black parents have to have with their children, yet then white people scream that the blacks are the ones being racist. It's so freaking convenient. And then that gives them the excuse to write racist garbage and hide behind the label of sarcasm. It preys on the racist, ignorant, and/or weak-minded who can't see through the bullshit.
- PARTY
- Posts: 420
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2012 5:54 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
welcome to the real world.berkeleykel06 wrote:It preys on the racist, ignorant, and/or weak-minded who can't see through the bullshit.
- Ludo!
- Posts: 4730
- Joined: Wed Nov 09, 2011 1:22 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
I know you think it's really clever to keep telling me to read the article even after I keep telling you that I have. I assure you, I have read it. I understand that you are trying hard to find a way to construe it as not racist. It's like how people say "Hey I'm not racist but... how come I can't start a White Pride Club" or "I'm not racist but... why can't we have white history month?"ben4847 wrote: read the article.
This is "I'm not racist but... if black people can tell their kids not to buy a water gun because they might get shot by police, then I should be able to tell my kid that black people are less intelligent than them!"
He can say he meant it as satire, and you can read it that way if you want, but it's not. It is racist garbage.
- MachineLemon
- Posts: 375
- Joined: Thu Oct 20, 2011 9:47 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
-
Last edited by MachineLemon on Thu Apr 12, 2012 3:07 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- kapital98
- Posts: 1188
- Joined: Sun Jan 09, 2011 9:58 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Ben, you misread Ludovico's reply. He said it was Derbyshire's response to "The Talk." He then explains what "The Talk" is for context.ben4847 wrote:no, the satire response is what if a white parent would tell their kid to be wary of a society which is occasionally fearful of and hostile towards them.Ludovico Technique wrote:
His article was written as a 'response' to articles about "The Talk" that black parents have to have with their kids. Stuff like - how to deal with police when they're stopped for no reason, "Don’t walk around with stuff in your pockets. People will think you stole something.", telling their kids that "they're dealing with a society that is fearful and hostile toward them, simply because of the color of their skin". A talk about "what it means to be a black teenager in a country with a history of regarding young black men as a threat."
And Derbyshire's "satirical" response is that black people are stupid and shouldn't be helped? That's not satire
read the article.
He read the article. It's racist. Section 10 is what grabbed headlines. However, almost the rest of the article is just as bad.
- kapital98
- Posts: 1188
- Joined: Sun Jan 09, 2011 9:58 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Ludovico Technique wrote:I know you think it's really clever to keep telling me to read the article even after I keep telling you that I have. I assure you, I have read it. I understand that you are trying hard to find a way to construe it as not racist. It's like how people say "Hey I'm not racist but... how come I can't start a White Pride Club" or "I'm not racist but... why can't we have white history month?"ben4847 wrote: read the article.
It is racist garbage.
- MTal
- Posts: 852
- Joined: Tue Dec 11, 2007 6:47 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Personally, I would sign up for the first Pro-PLO anti-Zionist class that would become available.
- ben4847
- Posts: 788
- Joined: Mon Nov 07, 2011 11:38 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Sorry, I didn't realize I was talking to the same person.Ludovico Technique wrote:I know you think it's really clever to keep telling me to read the article even after I keep telling you that I have. I assure you, I have read it. I understand that you are trying hard to find a way to construe it as not racist. It's like how people say "Hey I'm not racist but... how come I can't start a White Pride Club" or "I'm not racist but... why can't we have white history month?"ben4847 wrote: read the article.
This is "I'm not racist but... if black people can tell their kids not to buy a water gun because they might get shot by police, then I should be able to tell my kid that black people are less intelligent than them!"
He can say he meant it as satire, and you can read it that way if you want, but it's not. It is racist garbage.
I think I made my point. I think I see your point. I'm not convinced it was racist, and I'm not convinced that it wasn't.
Regarding the "White History Month". You are correct that most people who would say that are doing so because they indeed are racist. But do you think it is inherently racist to have a month celebrating the contributions to civil society made by Caucasians? I don't. I think it is important to distinguish between what is inherently racist, and what is the sort of statement that makes racists smile.
My argument on this thread will make racists smile. (And then can go to h---.) But I don't think I am racist.
"The Talk" is an article that will make racists smile. But I am not convinced that it is inherently racist. I would not have written it, and I don't think he should have. But it is possible he is just a fool, and not every fool is a racist.
-
- Posts: 3019
- Joined: Mon May 09, 2011 11:34 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
I totally understand the bind that your position inherently puts you in. I often find myself in similar situations, arguing a position that is, in itself, not racist or offensive, but is too often used as a subterfuge but those who actually are racist or hateful. Thus, the argument itself becomes "tainted" as being nothing more than a facade. As you said, its difficult for one to make the "White History Month" point without the suspicion arising that its just a backhanded way of conveying one's racism.ben4847 wrote:Sorry, I didn't realize I was talking to the same person.Ludovico Technique wrote:I know you think it's really clever to keep telling me to read the article even after I keep telling you that I have. I assure you, I have read it. I understand that you are trying hard to find a way to construe it as not racist. It's like how people say "Hey I'm not racist but... how come I can't start a White Pride Club" or "I'm not racist but... why can't we have white history month?"ben4847 wrote: read the article.
This is "I'm not racist but... if black people can tell their kids not to buy a water gun because they might get shot by police, then I should be able to tell my kid that black people are less intelligent than them!"
He can say he meant it as satire, and you can read it that way if you want, but it's not. It is racist garbage.
I think I made my point. I think I see your point. I'm not convinced it was racist, and I'm not convinced that it wasn't.
Regarding the "White History Month". You are correct that most people who would say that are doing so because they indeed are racist. But do you think it is inherently racist to have a month celebrating the contributions to civil society made by Caucasians? I don't. I think it is important to distinguish between what is inherently racist, and what is the sort of statement that makes racists smile.
My argument on this thread will make racists smile. (And then can go to h---.) But I don't think I am racist.
"The Talk" is an article that will make racists smile. But I am not convinced that it is inherently racist. I would not have written it, and I don't think he should have. But it is possible he is just a fool, and not every fool is a racist.
- 1800calturk
- Posts: 127
- Joined: Thu Feb 18, 2010 5:32 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
I agree with the people who say talk to others. You never know, a lot of professors don't let their personal beliefs bleed into the curriculum. Then again a lot do. Don't sit there and take offensive remarks all semester long that will drive you crazy, but then again, it may be valuable to be able to add in a new perspective.
I actually had the opposite problem at my school. One of our professors is also black and I didn't agree with his, somewhat radical in my view, characterization of certain cases. It made me kind of uncomfortable, but that's what learning is about and it was fine that I disagreed.
I actually had the opposite problem at my school. One of our professors is also black and I didn't agree with his, somewhat radical in my view, characterization of certain cases. It made me kind of uncomfortable, but that's what learning is about and it was fine that I disagreed.
-
- Posts: 120
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2012 1:43 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Breh, no need for white history month. It's called history.Ludovico Technique wrote:I know you think it's really clever to keep telling me to read the article even after I keep telling you that I have. I assure you, I have read it. I understand that you are trying hard to find a way to construe it as not racist. It's like how people say "Hey I'm not racist but... how come I can't start a White Pride Club" or "I'm not racist but... why can't we have white history month?"ben4847 wrote: read the article.
-
- Posts: 3019
- Joined: Mon May 09, 2011 11:34 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Dude, I know. Its more of a rhetorical point than an actual proposal.Napt wrote:Breh, no need for white history month. It's called history.Ludovico Technique wrote:I know you think it's really clever to keep telling me to read the article even after I keep telling you that I have. I assure you, I have read it. I understand that you are trying hard to find a way to construe it as not racist. It's like how people say "Hey I'm not racist but... how come I can't start a White Pride Club" or "I'm not racist but... why can't we have white history month?"ben4847 wrote: read the article.
-
- Posts: 120
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2012 1:43 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Yea breh, I agree. Do you think it's okay for blacks to have the NAACP but whites can't have something like the NAAWP because of political correctness? Y or y not?kaiser wrote:Dude, I know. Its more of a rhetorical point than an actual proposal.Napt wrote:Breh, no need for white history month. It's called history.Ludovico Technique wrote:I know you think it's really clever to keep telling me to read the article even after I keep telling you that I have. I assure you, I have read it. I understand that you are trying hard to find a way to construe it as not racist. It's like how people say "Hey I'm not racist but... how come I can't start a White Pride Club" or "I'm not racist but... why can't we have white history month?"ben4847 wrote: read the article.
-
- Posts: 3019
- Joined: Mon May 09, 2011 11:34 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Its not that whites can't have such a group. I just think there isn't really a need for it. A minority needs groups to look out for it and ensure it isn't being trampled by the majority. The majority doesn't have that same fear. Its not really a matter of political correction as much as it is a matter of just being unnecessary.Napt wrote: Yea breh, I agree. Do you think it's okay for blacks to have the NAACP but whites can't have something like the NAAWP because of political correctness? Y or y not?
-
- Posts: 120
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2012 1:43 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
What abt whites who come from poor socioeconomic backgrounds similar to blacks, like hicks? They go to equally poor schools in maybe single-parent households but they don't get the benefits of AA. Why not make AA based on SES rather than race?kaiser wrote:Its not that whites can't have such a group. I just think there isn't really a need for it. A minority needs groups to look out for it and ensure it isn't being trampled by the majority. The majority doesn't have that same fear. Its not really a matter of political correction as much as it is a matter of just being unnecessary.Napt wrote: Yea breh, I agree. Do you think it's okay for blacks to have the NAACP but whites can't have something like the NAAWP because of political correctness? Y or y not?
- PARTY
- Posts: 420
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2012 5:54 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
i absolutely LOVE how easy it is for threads to turn into AA debates.
like we haven't heard this before.Napt wrote:What abt whites who come from poor socioeconomic backgrounds similar to blacks, like hicks? They go to equally poor schools in maybe single-parent households but they don't get the benefits of AA. Why not make AA based on SES rather than race?
-
- Posts: 3019
- Joined: Mon May 09, 2011 11:34 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Uh, theres certainly an argument to be made to that effect, but I don't think this thread is the appropriate place to have such a discussion. We aren't actually debating these issues themselves, as much as we were merely acknowledging that it is certainly possible for one to make out logical arguments for positions that may sometimes come off as sounding racist (due to the fact that these arguments are often used as subterfuges for racist people to get their hateful views across).Napt wrote:What abt whites who come from poor socioeconomic backgrounds similar to blacks, like hicks? They go to equally poor schools in maybe single-parent households but they don't get the benefits of AA. Why not make AA based on SES rather than race?kaiser wrote:Its not that whites can't have such a group. I just think there isn't really a need for it. A minority needs groups to look out for it and ensure it isn't being trampled by the majority. The majority doesn't have that same fear. Its not really a matter of political correction as much as it is a matter of just being unnecessary.Napt wrote: Yea breh, I agree. Do you think it's okay for blacks to have the NAACP but whites can't have something like the NAAWP because of political correctness? Y or y not?
Last edited by kaiser on Thu Apr 12, 2012 5:31 pm, edited 2 times in total.
- Ludo!
- Posts: 4730
- Joined: Wed Nov 09, 2011 1:22 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Nope. Don't even start this. There's already a thread for that if you want to talk about thatNapt wrote:What abt whites who come from poor socioeconomic backgrounds similar to blacks, like hicks? They go to equally poor schools in maybe single-parent households but they don't get the benefits of AA. Why not make AA based on SES rather than race?kaiser wrote:Its not that whites can't have such a group. I just think there isn't really a need for it. A minority needs groups to look out for it and ensure it isn't being trampled by the majority. The majority doesn't have that same fear. Its not really a matter of political correction as much as it is a matter of just being unnecessary.Napt wrote: Yea breh, I agree. Do you think it's okay for blacks to have the NAACP but whites can't have something like the NAAWP because of political correctness? Y or y not?
-
- Posts: 120
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2012 1:43 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Okay. But why can't a disadvantaged minority like white hicks have a white hick pride group but blacks can? U see what I'm saying, breh?kaiser wrote:Uh, theres certainly an argument to be made to that effect, but I don't think this thread is the appropriate place to have such a discussion.Napt wrote:What abt whites who come from poor socioeconomic backgrounds similar to blacks, like hicks? They go to equally poor schools in maybe single-parent households but they don't get the benefits of AA. Why not make AA based on SES rather than race?kaiser wrote:Its not that whites can't have such a group. I just think there isn't really a need for it. A minority needs groups to look out for it and ensure it isn't being trampled by the majority. The majority doesn't have that same fear. Its not really a matter of political correction as much as it is a matter of just being unnecessary.Napt wrote: Yea breh, I agree. Do you think it's okay for blacks to have the NAACP but whites can't have something like the NAAWP because of political correctness? Y or y not?
- Ludo!
- Posts: 4730
- Joined: Wed Nov 09, 2011 1:22 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Seriously. shut upNapt wrote: Okay. But why can't a disadvantaged minority like white hicks have a white hick pride group but blacks can? U see what I'm saying, breh?
-
- Posts: 120
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2012 1:43 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Plz explain.Ludovico Technique wrote:Seriously. shut upNapt wrote: Okay. But why can't a disadvantaged minority like white hicks have a white hick pride group but blacks can? U see what I'm saying, breh?
- PARTY
- Posts: 420
- Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2012 5:54 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
obvious troll is obvious.Napt wrote:Plz explain.Ludovico Technique wrote:Seriously. shut upNapt wrote: Okay. But why can't a disadvantaged minority like white hicks have a white hick pride group but blacks can? U see what I'm saying, breh?
-
- Posts: 20063
- Joined: Sun Mar 14, 2010 7:06 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
The AA debate is over.
-
- Posts: 3019
- Joined: Mon May 09, 2011 11:34 pm
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Sorry I humored the troll. Hopefully we can get this discussion back on track.
- 1800calturk
- Posts: 127
- Joined: Thu Feb 18, 2010 5:32 am
Re: Possibly racist professor - What to do?
Uh, theres certainly an argument to be made to that effect, but I don't think this thread is the appropriate place to have such a discussion.[/quote]Napt wrote: What abt whites who come from poor socioeconomic backgrounds similar to blacks, like hicks? They go to equally poor schools in maybe single-parent households but they don't get the benefits of AA. Why not make AA based on SES rather than race?
Okay. But why can't a disadvantaged minority like white hicks have a white hick pride group but blacks can? U see what I'm saying, breh?[/quote]
If you're not a minority, you just can't understand. I mean that sounds cliche, but a white person has historically been judged by their personal traits, whereas blacks (and other minorities) are looked at for their race, and it's a barrier to entry. Now this is clearing up significantly, but I mean just think about it-- whites usually hang with whites and blacks usually hang with blacks. It's just cause you like what's familiar to you, you know? Even if no one is racist, if there's a firm and the partners are choosing the next partner, if every partner is white, then that next partner's going to be white. An equally qualified black guy is probably going to get passed over, only because his culture is unfamiliar. So you spend a period balancing that out, and once the in-group is diverse enough, then you can stop with all the groups and programs. In a lot of places, we're there, and there's a backlash because it's never a fair system in a world of scarce resources. I honestly feel bad for other minorities sometimes because the discussion is always black and white, but one thing at a time. But I guess the point is, the mainstream default "group" is already white.