Page 1 of 1

Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Tue Apr 11, 2017 4:36 pm
by LawDataz
Hey everyone,

What are your thoughts on Columbia (sticker) versus UPenn (50k+ scholly; 15k+/year)? I am interested in NYC Big Law and particularly hard (as opposed to soft) IP work. I am also interested in that work having international potential. No clue what I am going to do, so any insight would be appreciated.

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Tue Apr 11, 2017 6:59 pm
by proteinshake
those are your only T13 options?

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Tue Apr 11, 2017 7:44 pm
by RSN
Obviously if those are your only two options go to Penn without question. Do you have money anywhere else?

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 10:50 am
by LawDataz
proteinshake wrote:those are your only T13 options?
No, but those are the only two I'm interested in. I got in at Duke, Michigan, Virginia (all w/ some money) as well as Northwestern. Waitlisted at Chicago and radio silence from NYU.

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 10:50 am
by LawDataz
RSN wrote:Obviously if those are your only two options go to Penn without question. Do you have money anywhere else?
I have money at Duke, Michigan and Virginia, but I'm pretty committed to living and working in the northeast.

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 10:53 am
by proteinshake
LawDataz wrote:
RSN wrote:Obviously if those are your only two options go to Penn without question. Do you have money anywhere else?
I have money at Duke, Michigan and Virginia, but I'm pretty committed to living and working in the northeast.
all of these schools can get you back to the Northeast easily. how much money did you get from the other schools?

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 10:59 am
by LawDataz
proteinshake wrote:
LawDataz wrote:
RSN wrote:Obviously if those are your only two options go to Penn without question. Do you have money anywhere else?
I have money at Duke, Michigan and Virginia, but I'm pretty committed to living and working in the northeast.
all of these schools can get you back to the Northeast easily. how much money did you get from the other schools?
80k + 20k for LLM; 90k; 60k (respectively)

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 11:32 am
by Dr. Nefario
Based on those additional offers, Duke might be the best bet. But it ifs Penn v Columbia, go Penn. Even on biglaw salary Columbia at sticker is indefensible.

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 11:39 am
by proteinshake
Dr. Nefario wrote:Based on those additional offers, Duke might be the best bet. But it ifs Penn v Columbia, go Penn. Even on biglaw salary Columbia at sticker is indefensible.
yeah it'd be a huge mistake to take Columbia. I'd go Duke here.

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 11:42 am
by UVA2B
Why the $20k for an LLM? Duke is the best offer on the table, but I'm confused why you're being given a discount to get an LLM. Can you get that as just $100k for your JD and forego the LLM?

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 11:46 am
by proteinshake
UVA2B wrote:Why the $20k for an LLM? Duke is the best offer on the table, but I'm confused why you're being given a discount to get an LLM. Can you get that as just $100k for your JD and forego the LLM?
nah Duke gives extra money for the LLM since the LLM increases your COA.

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 11:50 am
by UVA2B
proteinshake wrote:
UVA2B wrote:Why the $20k for an LLM? Duke is the best offer on the table, but I'm confused why you're being given a discount to get an LLM. Can you get that as just $100k for your JD and forego the LLM?
nah Duke gives extra money for the LLM since the LLM increases your COA.
Is this within the three years, or does it require a fourth year with attendant COA? If so, Michigan pulls into the lead because that LLM will be zero value added following graduation (beyond miring yourself in legal academia for an additional year taking regular law school classes that won't help when you start working, even if it's ancillary applicable to the practice group you'll eventually end up in with a possible exception of tax).

ETA: mistook UVA and Michigan offers, fixed

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 11:56 am
by proteinshake
UVA2B wrote:
proteinshake wrote:
UVA2B wrote:Why the $20k for an LLM? Duke is the best offer on the table, but I'm confused why you're being given a discount to get an LLM. Can you get that as just $100k for your JD and forego the LLM?
nah Duke gives extra money for the LLM since the LLM increases your COA.
Is this within the three years, or does it require a fourth year with attendant COA? If so, Michigan pulls into the lead because that LLM will be zero value added following graduation (beyond miring yourself in legal academia for an additional year taking regular law school classes that won't help when you start working, even if it's ancillary applicable to the practice group you'll eventually end up in with a possible exception of tax).

ETA: mistook UVA and Michigan offers, fixed
three years (no extra time needed)

Re: Columbia vs UPenn

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 11:57 am
by UVA2B
proteinshake wrote:
UVA2B wrote:
proteinshake wrote:
UVA2B wrote:Why the $20k for an LLM? Duke is the best offer on the table, but I'm confused why you're being given a discount to get an LLM. Can you get that as just $100k for your JD and forego the LLM?
nah Duke gives extra money for the LLM since the LLM increases your COA.
Is this within the three years, or does it require a fourth year with attendant COA? If so, Michigan pulls into the lead because that LLM will be zero value added following graduation (beyond miring yourself in legal academia for an additional year taking regular law school classes that won't help when you start working, even if it's ancillary applicable to the practice group you'll eventually end up in with a possible exception of tax).

ETA: mistook UVA and Michigan offers, fixed
three years (no extra time needed)
Ok, then Duke