Page 1 of 1

St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Mon Mar 20, 2017 1:37 pm
by Shark3487
Hello!

I've been accepted to St. Mary's Law in San Antonio and am waiting to hear from Widener Law in Harrisburg. I'm trying to decide where I should go. At this point, I am leaning to St. Mary's, because it'll be easier to find work/internships vs. At Widener. But I am open to hearing other input.

St. Mary's will cost me 20K extra in loans vs. Widener should I get the scholarship promised. I'm interested in criminal law and eventually after several years of work experience I would like to move to Philly.

Where should I go?

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Mon Mar 20, 2017 1:43 pm
by cavalier1138
Assuming that this isn't a troll: neither. Do not go to either school if you want to be a practicing lawyer.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Mon Mar 20, 2017 1:47 pm
by Shark3487
Why ?

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Mon Mar 20, 2017 2:52 pm
by cavalier1138
Because about half of the graduating class from each of these schools does not have a job as a lawyer.

You did look up a bit of information about these places before applying, right?

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2017 2:34 pm
by Rigo
Thank you for letting me know St. Mary's was in San Antonio, because I honestly had no idea.

But hell no. Neither. Just no. If a school is more willing than fucking Widener to admit you, it's a total dumpster fire and a complete waste of 3 years as you'll likely end up without a legal job.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2017 2:37 pm
by Thomas Hagan, ESQ.
https://www.lstreports.com/schools/stmarys/

https://www.lstreports.com/schools/widener-de/

Both gives you a 47% chance of becoming a lawyer, which is less than a coin-flip chance.

Edit: Whoops, I didn't know you were talking about Widener Harrisburg (I didn't even know there were two). Graduating from harrisburg gives you even worse prospects.

https://www.lstreports.com/schools/widener-pa/

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2017 2:40 pm
by Thomas Hagan, ESQ.
Rigo wrote:Thank you for letting me know St. Mary's was in San Antonio, because I honestly had no idea.

But hell no. Neither. Just no. If a school is more willing than fucking Widener to admit you, it's a total dumpster fire and a complete waste of 3 years as you'll likely end up without a legal job.
Lols same.. I also didn't even know Widener was in the Northeast...and I'm from the northeast.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2017 2:43 pm
by mjb447
Don't go, and definitely don't pay money or take out loans to go.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2017 4:39 pm
by Mikey
neither

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 9:12 am
by proteinshake
Don't waste three years of your life.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 9:37 am
by didgeridoo92
Prime example of just how warm and kind TLS posters to those asking for advice

...

You are gonna get a lot of crap from posters (most of whom went to T14 schools) who don't understand your position whatsoever. You wanna live in TX (San Antonio specifically), go to St. Mary's. Understand that if you go to St. Mary's you will not get a big firm job in Texas. If you are happy with small firm in Texas, go there. I don't know enough about Widener to give advice on if, but I assume same deal - optimal outcome is an associate gig at a small firm near the school.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 9:44 am
by cavalier1138
didgeridoo92 wrote:Prime example of just how warm and kind TLS posters to those asking for advice

...

You are gonna get a lot of crap from posters (most of whom went to T14 schools) who don't understand your position whatsoever. You wanna live in TX (San Antonio specifically), go to St. Mary's. Understand that if you go to St. Mary's you will not get a big firm job in Texas. If you are happy with small firm in Texas, go there. I don't know enough about Widener to give advice on if, but I assume same deal - optimal outcome is an associate gig at a small firm near the school.
Prime example of how being "warm and kind" often equates to recommending financial and career suicide with a smile.

Both schools give graduates a 50/50 shot at being a practicing lawyer in any capacity. Texas has plenty of decent law schools that feed their local markets. There's no need to recommend a shit school just because you want people on an anonymous online board to perceive you as cute and cuddly (for who knows what reason).

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 9:47 am
by Rigo
didgeridoo92 wrote:Prime example of just how warm and kind TLS posters to those asking for advice
Nobody has been unkind to the poster.
As for our take on the schools, the truth is best served bluntly with no room for misinterpretation. Unfortunately people close to us in our real life are yes men who know absolutely nothing and it's easy to make bad decisions if all we ever get are affirmations. If I relied on parental advice and anecdotes, I'd 100% be at a TTT and most likely really struggling right now. It would be a huge ego/self-esteem blow too because I would have gone in with completely unrealistic expectations and fallen very, very short of them.
TLS is great because it's really the only source of objective feedback many applicants get.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 9:52 am
by didgeridoo92
cavalier1138 wrote:
didgeridoo92 wrote:Prime example of just how warm and kind TLS posters to those asking for advice

...

You are gonna get a lot of crap from posters (most of whom went to T14 schools) who don't understand your position whatsoever. You wanna live in TX (San Antonio specifically), go to St. Mary's. Understand that if you go to St. Mary's you will not get a big firm job in Texas. If you are happy with small firm in Texas, go there. I don't know enough about Widener to give advice on if, but I assume same deal - optimal outcome is an associate gig at a small firm near the school.
Prime example of how being "warm and kind" often equates to recommending financial and career suicide with a smile.

Both schools give graduates a 50/50 shot at being a practicing lawyer in any capacity. Texas has plenty of decent law schools that feed their local markets. There's no need to recommend a shit school just because you want people on an anonymous online board to perceive you as cute and cuddly (for who knows what reason).
Fair, and agree on there being better schools in Texas to get the job you want. For what it's worth, in Texas, St. Mary's isn't considered a "shit school" by a long shot. I think we both agree that a job in Philly won't happen from any school he/she mentioned

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 10:02 am
by cavalier1138
didgeridoo92 wrote:For what it's worth, in Texas, St. Mary's isn't considered a "shit school" by a long shot.
Are you referring to the law school, or the general university? Because I have a hard time believing that Texans all think that the legal job outcomes from St. Mary's are good.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 10:25 am
by BigZuck
cavalier1138 wrote:
didgeridoo92 wrote:For what it's worth, in Texas, St. Mary's isn't considered a "shit school" by a long shot.
Are you referring to the law school, or the general university? Because I have a hard time believing that Texans all think that the legal job outcomes from St. Mary's are good.
I've never met a St. Mary's grad and I do not think it has a good reputation in TX

I haven't spent a lot of time in San Antonio and it is the only school there so I'm sure there are St. Mary's grads there. But it's pretty solidly in the South Texas/Texas Tech grouping of schools. The type of school specifically named when people say "There are too many law schools in Texas."

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 10:42 am
by mjb447
Rigo wrote:Unfortunately people close to us in our real life are yes men who know absolutely nothing and it's easy to make bad decisions if all we ever get are affirmations. If I relied on parental advice and anecdotes, I'd 100% be at a TTT and most likely really struggling right now. It would be a huge ego/self-esteem blow too because I would have gone in with completely unrealistic expectations and fallen very, very short of them.
TLS is great because it's really the only source of objective feedback many applicants get.
"You're thinking of taking out how much in loans to attend [a top law school]? Can't you just go to [local TTT]? You've always been in the top of your class before!" - too many well-meaning family members

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 8:41 pm
by Johann
Thomas Hagan, ESQ. wrote:https://www.lstreports.com/schools/stmarys/

https://www.lstreports.com/schools/widener-de/

Both gives you a 47% chance of becoming a lawyer, which is less than a coin-flip chance.

Edit: Whoops, I didn't know you were talking about Widener Harrisburg (I didn't even know there were two). Graduating from harrisburg gives you even worse prospects.

https://www.lstreports.com/schools/widener-pa/
id reiterate and emphasize looking at these stats and truly understanding what they mean. if you still decide to go, you should go to whichever school is in the city you want to work in after you graduate. feel free to pm with any questions.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 8:44 pm
by GoLandcrabs
didgeridoo92 wrote:
cavalier1138 wrote:
didgeridoo92 wrote:Prime example of just how warm and kind TLS posters to those asking for advice

...

You are gonna get a lot of crap from posters (most of whom went to T14 schools) who don't understand your position whatsoever. You wanna live in TX (San Antonio specifically), go to St. Mary's. Understand that if you go to St. Mary's you will not get a big firm job in Texas. If you are happy with small firm in Texas, go there. I don't know enough about Widener to give advice on if, but I assume same deal - optimal outcome is an associate gig at a small firm near the school.
Prime example of how being "warm and kind" often equates to recommending financial and career suicide with a smile.

Both schools give graduates a 50/50 shot at being a practicing lawyer in any capacity. Texas has plenty of decent law schools that feed their local markets. There's no need to recommend a shit school just because you want people on an anonymous online board to perceive you as cute and cuddly (for who knows what reason).
Fair, and agree on there being better schools in Texas to get the job you want. For what it's worth, in Texas, St. Mary's isn't considered a "shit school" by a long shot. I think we both agree that a job in Philly won't happen from any school he/she mentioned
If they aren't a shit school why are 53% of lawyers from there not hired.

Re: St. Mary's Law vs. Widener Law

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2017 11:23 pm
by kalvano
St. Mary's is a shit school. Don't go.