Congrats on the new girth, bro.rad lulz wrote:Yeah dude lots more employers would come to campus AND your penis would get bigger.dangerdan wrote:Berkeley should clearly be 6th
USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit Forum
- Tom Joad
- Posts: 4526
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2008 5:56 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
-
- Posts: 54
- Joined: Sat May 21, 2011 1:33 am
- cahwc12
- Posts: 942
- Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2012 4:49 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
I think this is something that will be fixed with time. From what I've read, the c/o 2012 will be similar in granularity to the c/o 2011 data, but there is hope that the c/o 2013 data will be a marked improvement.pedestrian wrote:There is a big difference though between a school-funded teaching fellowship or post-grad PI funding and hiring your students to answer phones and stuff envelopes for minimum wage for a year.
Both are responses to the bad economy, but fellowships often do provide a bridge to better employment opportunities, whereas temp work is a blatant attempt to game the rankings.
I wish we could see exactly what these jobs are and what happens to the students who get them.
Until then, while I agree it's bullshit and these schools should have asterisks next to their names, I think that you really have no choice but to count them. The truth will come out soon. That schools like American, Pepperdine, Brooklyn saw precipitous drops in the rankings this year suggest that USNWR is at least trying.
And because we all know how masturbatory the ranking system is, as the school's ranking drops, so all the other factors that rank it will drop accordingly. Employment data is really one of the only semi-independent variables, and it, too, partially depends on the rankings.
- pedestrian
- Posts: 461
- Joined: Sat Jun 18, 2011 9:38 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Perhaps not, but just poking around the website a little I found 15 post-grads for 2012-13 who had various school-funded public interest and research fellowships and there were several other fellowships that did not list current recipients. 10% of the class is ~20 so it isn't a stretch to think that every school-funded job is either a real job at the school or a fellowship.Desert Fox wrote:10% of Yale's grads aren't working on teaching fellowship.
The public interest fellowships fund students while they work for 1-2 years at outside nonprofits. Whether that leads to a job offer or not, it is legitimate work experience on their resumes. The research and teaching fellowships allow students to publish, which is essential to an academic career. Several fellowships (which I didn't count) are only for students who are a few years out, so it also isn't like - "whelp, USNWR only cares about the first year, so sayonara!"
Many of these fellowships predate the recession and are valuable even in a booming economy. Even granting that fellowships have increased in response to the recession, that only makes sense, doesn't it? Wouldn't anyone prefer to go to a school that responds to a poor hiring market in academia and government budget cuts by providing additional support to students who are interested in those careers?
If GW and other schools are really paying graduates minimum wage to sit in the basement, that is a very different situation. However, I don't think that evaluating schools is as simple as subtracting school-funded jobs from the listed employment %.
- Elston Gunn
- Posts: 3820
- Joined: Mon Jul 18, 2011 4:09 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
The school-funded jobs at Yale are definitely all "real," though, for instance, I'm sure the people who are getting paid by Yale to work at HUD, etc. could have gotten paid by, you know, HUD before the recession. My guess would be that the jump in school funded jobs is almost entirely because of the huge drop in PI hiring rather than the relatively smaller drop in firm hiring, since there are so many people here who are completely against working at a firm.pedestrian wrote:Perhaps not, but just poking around the website a little I found 15 post-grads for 2012-13 who had various school-funded public interest and research fellowships and there were several other fellowships that did not list current recipients. 10% of the class is ~20 so it isn't a stretch to think that every school-funded job is either a real job at the school or a fellowship.Desert Fox wrote:10% of Yale's grads aren't working on teaching fellowship.
The public interest fellowships fund students while they work for 1-2 years at outside nonprofits. Whether that leads to a job offer or not, it is legitimate work experience on their resumes. The research and teaching fellowships allow students to publish, which is essential to an academic career. Several fellowships (which I didn't count) are only for students who are a few years out, so it also isn't like - "whelp, USNWR only cares about the first year, so sayonara!"
Many of these fellowships predate the recession and are valuable even in a booming economy. Even granting that fellowships have increased in response to the recession, that only makes sense, doesn't it? Wouldn't anyone prefer to go to a school that responds to a poor hiring market in academia and government budget cuts by providing additional support to students who are interested in those careers?
If GW and other schools are really paying graduates minimum wage to sit in the basement, that is a very different situation. However, I don't think that evaluating schools is as simple as subtracting school-funded jobs from the listed employment %.
Want to continue reading?
Register now to search topics and post comments!
Absolutely FREE!
Already a member? Login
- JamMasterJ
- Posts: 6649
- Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2011 7:17 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
they need to figure out how to distill school-funded into what people are doing AFTER school funded years. I know our's end up getting jerbs for the most part, and with LRAP, even if a bunch of those are shitty PI, it still makes the degree pretty cheap.
-
- Posts: 18203
- Joined: Wed Oct 14, 2009 10:47 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Stop making excuses for Yale's employment BS. People working in internships aren't employed even if their school gives them a stipend.
- pedestrian
- Posts: 461
- Joined: Sat Jun 18, 2011 9:38 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
By your logic, Article III clerks, visiting assistant professors, and PI attorneys living on federal grant money aren't employed. Fellowships are an increasingly important component of certain career paths, and not just in legal fields - they are sprouting up in science, medicine and the humanities as well.Desert Fox wrote:Stop making excuses for Yale's employment BS. People working in internships aren't employed even if their school gives them a stipend.
Honestly, I don't care what fits your definition of employment. The real question is whether going to a particular school will result in a desired career outcome. Some school-funded positions will and some will not. You can't take a school's employment numbers at face value, but obtuse paranoia isn't helpful either.
-
- Posts: 9807
- Joined: Sun Feb 19, 2012 10:53 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
lol aIII clerks draw a federal salary d00d
-
- Posts: 1869
- Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2013 6:49 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
School funded from Yale or NYU, or even JD Advantage work from GULC that's politically minded, that has different results than admissions work or working for cheap at some agency to fluff up data. I agree. But I am a strong advocate for pessimism.pedestrian wrote:Some school-funded positions will and some will not. You can't take a school's employment numbers at face value, but obtuse paranoia isn't helpful either.Desert Fox wrote:Stop making excuses for Yale's employment BS. People working in internships aren't employed even if their school gives them a stipend.
-
- Posts: 9807
- Joined: Sun Feb 19, 2012 10:53 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Also you read that shit in TFL about VAPs? Shit is bordering on scam territory
-
- Posts: 18203
- Joined: Wed Oct 14, 2009 10:47 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Federal grant money? You mean the Feds give an orgo a million dollars and that orgo pays you 50K? That's called employment dooder. Fellowships that are paid by the orgo that is getting the work is employment. If you take a fellowship at MIT for physics they are paying you. It's a job. If your school pays you 30K to do an unpaid internship, that's not a job.pedestrian wrote:By your logic, Article III clerks, visiting assistant professors, and PI attorneys living on federal grant money aren't employed. Fellowships are an increasingly important component of certain career paths, and not just in legal fields - they are sprouting up in science, medicine and the humanities as well.Desert Fox wrote:Stop making excuses for Yale's employment BS. People working in internships aren't employed even if their school gives them a stipend.
Honestly, I don't care what fits your definition of employment. The real question is whether going to a particular school will result in a desired career outcome. Some school-funded positions will and some will not. You can't take a school's employment numbers at face value, but obtuse paranoia isn't helpful either.
I realize that schools often have real fellowships that are competitive and desirable. But not enough for 10% of the class.
These are "fellowships" you get because you can't find a real job.
- pedestrian
- Posts: 461
- Joined: Sat Jun 18, 2011 9:38 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Yes, I know, my point is that it is temporary and relatively low-paying and most people do it for the reward of the experience and because it has the possibility of leading to improved career opportunities.rad lulz wrote:lol aIII clerks draw a federal salary d00d
The same is true of PI/research fellowships.
Register now!
Resources to assist law school applicants, students & graduates.
It's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 18203
- Joined: Wed Oct 14, 2009 10:47 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Do you want to make some more irrelevant points?pedestrian wrote:Yes, I know, my point is that it is temporary and relatively low-paying and most people do it for the reward of the experience and because it has the possibility of leading to improved career opportunities.rad lulz wrote:lol aIII clerks draw a federal salary d00d
The same is true of PI/research fellowships.
- A. Nony Mouse
- Posts: 29293
- Joined: Tue Sep 25, 2012 11:51 am
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Well, given that someone was talking about how the unemployed grads at their school were proctoring exams, I think the school-funded jobs have a high potential to fail those criteria.pedestrian wrote:Yes, I know, my point is that it is temporary and relatively low-paying and most people do it for the reward of the experience and because it has the possibility of leading to improved career opportunities.rad lulz wrote:lol aIII clerks draw a federal salary d00d
The same is true of PI/research fellowships.
- Elston Gunn
- Posts: 3820
- Joined: Mon Jul 18, 2011 4:09 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
I think the fact that many YLS grads can't get decent PI organizations to pay them--which I think is basically the entirety of what Yale's jump in school funded jobs shows--should really scare PI focused people away from law school. PI is a shit show.
-
- Posts: 3436
- Joined: Sun Oct 26, 2008 2:39 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Good point, this is exactly right.Elston Gunn wrote:I think the fact that many YLS grads can't get decent PI organizations to pay them--which I think is basically the entirety of what Yale's jump in school funded jobs shows--should really scare PI focused people away from law school. PI is a shit show.
Get unlimited access to all forums and topics
Register now!
I'm pretty sure I told you it's FREE...
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 18203
- Joined: Wed Oct 14, 2009 10:47 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
I wonder why PI is so shitty ITE. Was it always this shitty? Just a huge supply of people looking for it? Got hooked on free employment after the Great Deferment of 2009?
- pedestrian
- Posts: 461
- Joined: Sat Jun 18, 2011 9:38 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Nonprofits and philanthropies were hit particularly hard by the stock market crash, because a lot of endowments were gutted and donations dried up. Stimulus funding helped at first, but that was offset by deep cuts at the state and local level. Now that the federal government has turned to austerity as well, it is hard times indeed.Desert Fox wrote:I wonder why PI is so shitty ITE. Was it always this shitty? Just a huge supply of people looking for it? Got hooked on free employment after the Great Deferment of 2009?
I know of several nonprofits that had to reduce staff by ~50% and hiring freezes are pretty common. Maybe things will turn around now that the markets have recovered, but only time will tell.
-
- Posts: 3436
- Joined: Sun Oct 26, 2008 2:39 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Yeah, also publicly funded orgs (government, non-profits relying on government funding) tend to experience the effects of recessions well after the private sector does, and recover well after, as well. Government was doing fine for the year or so after Lehman et al, but when the cutbacks do hit they also stick around longer.pedestrian wrote:Nonprofits and philanthropies were hit particularly hard by the stock market crash, because a lot of endowments were gutted and donations dried up. Stimulus funding helped at first, but that was offset by deep cuts at the state and local level. Now that the federal government has turned to austerity as well, it is hard times indeed.Desert Fox wrote:I wonder why PI is so shitty ITE. Was it always this shitty? Just a huge supply of people looking for it? Got hooked on free employment after the Great Deferment of 2009?
I know of several nonprofits that had to reduce staff by ~50% and hiring freezes are pretty common. Maybe things will turn around now that the markets have recovered, but only time will tell.
- cahwc12
- Posts: 942
- Joined: Mon Jul 02, 2012 4:49 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
You seem to know a lot more about this than I do (which is admittedly not much). I have always been under the impression that these school-funded positions at HYS have always been genuine, and are just a bit more plentiful due to biglaw contraction. I have similarly believed that the CCN, UVA, GULC/GW school-funded positions have largely been employment gaming. I don't disbelieve you, but could you explain why you exactly you think these HYS positions are largely also BS? (Also, if I'm misunderstanding your argument, please explain.)Desert Fox wrote:Stop making excuses for Yale's employment BS. People working in internships aren't employed even if their school gives them a stipend.
Thanks.
Communicate now with those who not only know what a legal education is, but can offer you worthy advice and commentary as you complete the three most educational, yet challenging years of your law related post graduate life.
Register now, it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 18203
- Joined: Wed Oct 14, 2009 10:47 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
They have genuine ones. Most t14 have genuine fellowships. But they are for 1-2% of the class. But they all suspiciously exploded in size when student employment dropped. They are nonjobs created to pretend their graduates all have jobs. It's basically unemployment insurance.cahwc12 wrote:You seem to know a lot more about this than I do (which is admittedly not much). I have always been under the impression that these school-funded positions at HYS have always been genuine, and are just a bit more plentiful due to biglaw contraction. I have similarly believed that the CCN, UVA, GULC/GW school-funded positions have largely been employment gaming. I don't disbelieve you, but could you explain why you exactly you think these HYS positions are largely also BS? (Also, if I'm misunderstanding your argument, please explain.)Desert Fox wrote:Stop making excuses for Yale's employment BS. People working in internships aren't employed even if their school gives them a stipend.
Thanks.
Why do you believe that when yale creates " more plentiful due to biglaw contraction" that is not juking the employment stats. But when "CCN, UVA, GULC/GW" does it, it is "employment gaming." You seem to believe that because it's Yale, it can't be wrong.
Stop riding Yale's nuts.
- BearState
- Posts: 240
- Joined: Thu Apr 19, 2012 1:37 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
I think DF and pedestrian are both right to point out how common this is becoming in law and other professions. I think its part of the broader effort to kill entry level employment in general. Many college grads wind up riding from unpaid internship to unpaid internship until they find something that pays sustainably or move in with parents. Some of this has got to do with the recession, but employers have got to be happy they can now demand years of 'fellowships' and 'internships' before they actually hire someone.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/06/busin ... liver.html
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/06/busin ... liver.html
- sinfiery
- Posts: 3310
- Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2011 2:55 am
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
I wish someone would explain the difference in NLJS250 data from its peak versus today at HYS.
Edit: nvm, just H. Damn, I wanted to help in the Yale bashing.
http://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/v ... 1&t=150004
Edit: nvm, just H. Damn, I wanted to help in the Yale bashing.
http://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/v ... 1&t=150004
-
- Posts: 18203
- Joined: Wed Oct 14, 2009 10:47 pm
Re: USNEWS Employment Ranking Data = Bullshit
Fellowships in other professions aren't usually limited to graduates from that university. And they definitely aren't just given to each student who just can't find a job. And fellowships are paid/funded.BearState wrote:I think DF and pedestrian are both right to point out how common this is becoming in law and other professions. I think its part of the broader effort to kill entry level employment in general. Many college grads wind up riding from unpaid internship to unpaid internship until they find something that pays sustainably or move in with parents. Some of this has got to do with the recession, but employers have got to be happy they can now demand years of 'fellowships' and 'internships' before they actually hire someone.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/06/busin ... liver.html
Someone working for HUD in an INTERNSHIP who yale donates 10 dollars an hour to, isn't employed.
Seriously? What are you waiting for?
Now there's a charge.
Just kidding ... it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login