Another question
Posted: Sat Jan 05, 2013 2:15 am
...
Law School Discussion Forums
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/
https://www.top-law-schools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=201377
wow, tell me how you really feel... 163 3.5EvilClinton wrote:Post your stats or GTFO.
+1EvilClinton wrote:Post your stats or GTFO.
scroll upSuralin wrote:+1EvilClinton wrote:Post your stats or GTFO.
Thanks for your reply, Dog. I'm not totally sure what I would do if I attended Hastings or Davis. But with USF, McGeorge, or Santa Clara, I would definitely see myself working with/for my uncle. I feel like I would have a lot more options with Davis and Hastings.Dog wrote:If you're guaranteed a job with your uncle I think it makes sense to follow the $$$. Your uncle would be better suited to give you advice than myself. But if both paths lead to the same end destination (working for your uncle) and one has $140k extra of debt, yeah...
I'm right there with you in terms of a financial decision. I just don't think I could bring myself to pay sticker when I have that full ride offer, and possibly more than just one when all is said and done.LeninLunchbox wrote:Hastings or Davis will absolutely open way more doors for you than McGeorge. In another insane break with TLS-think I'm going to say it's possible your experience there might be enough better that you get a better idea of what you want to do along with your better shot. The problem is that that better shot is only 50/50 at a real lawyer job and in terms of getting a job that services serious debt more like 1/5. So to my financial eye it's simply insane to take out six-figure debt for that shot especially when you can get your most likely outcome for free. I'd consider those schools with a scholarship big enough you could reasonably service your debt at graduation with the job with your uncle.
As for leveraging the McGeorge offer, once your in at a school and they start sending you all the stuff about how you should really attend, email the admissions people saying you'd love to but that you've got a full ride from McGeorge and you can't really turn that down for sticker. How hard you want to push it is up to you. I'm not a expert at this but at similarly ranked schools with your stats I'd ask if they would match McGeorge's offer. With the T1's I'd ask them how much they'd be willing to give you. If you get some new $$$ offers you can meta-leverage that! Even if you'd truly crap out you should still use your acceptance at the better schools to get McGeorge to remove their stipulations. I'm sure more posters can give more advice on this, but it's not an exact science. You'll only get stuff if you try for it.
I think you're right! Thanks!thelawyler wrote:There are other ways to discover that than to pay 160k. Go with the full ride + uncle option.
Hey Champagne, I meant to note that it was not a "full ride" because only the first year and the summer program are guaranteed. I wouldn't say that I'm not worried about the stipulations because I am a little apprehensive about them, but at the same time, its the best offer I have. I'm holding out a little hope that the stipulations might be negotiable depending on what other schools have to say, but at the same time I believe I have a good chance at keeping the scholarship for all three years. I'm not naive or arrogant about it, I just think that if worse came to worse and the stipulations stuck that I would do what I had to do to keep the scholarship. The information I have on scholarships at McGeorge is that around 45% keep them and 55% lose them, theres no data about who was a full ride, half ride, quarter ride, etc.. I'm aware that the top schools don't use stipulations for the most part, but the top schools aren't the ones offering me the full ride lol.ChampagnePapi wrote:OP is this an actual full ride or is there a stipulation? McGeorge usually has a top third requirement. If there's no stipulations then I would go to McGeorge. Sacramento is a nice area to buy a house in too.
If you really want to explore fields other than your uncles law firm without spending a fortune, you'll have to retake again.
I know the retaking advice sucks, but I retook and renegotiated huge scholarships. Retaking and raising your score even a few point is THE BEST way to get money, as it both makes you a more attractive candidate and it shows to the school that you are serious in your threat to not matriculate. It's worth your time and money to do it. Even if you have only a 50% chance of upping your score 2-3 points with 50 extra hours of work/study, it is worth it. Think of it this way: if somebody offered you a 50% shot at $60,000 for 50 hours of work, would you take it? Of course you would, because that work has an Expected Value of $600 per hour. That's a fucking good hourly wage just for studying. And that's why you should retake. It's really a no brainer, especially because doing worse will not hurt you.bayareahopeful wrote:Hey Champagne, I meant to note that it was not a "full ride" because only the first year and the summer program are guaranteed. I wouldn't say that I'm not worried about the stipulations because I am a little apprehensive about them, but at the same time, its the best offer I have. I'm holding out a little hope that the stipulations might be negotiable depending on what other schools have to say, but at the same time I believe I have a good chance at keeping the scholarship for all three years. I'm not naive or arrogant about it, I just think that if worse came to worse and the stipulations stuck that I would do what I had to do to keep the scholarship. The information I have on scholarships at McGeorge is that around 45% keep them and 55% lose them, theres no data about who was a full ride, half ride, quarter ride, etc.. I'm aware that the top schools don't use stipulations for the most part, but the top schools aren't the ones offering me the full ride lol.ChampagnePapi wrote:OP is this an actual full ride or is there a stipulation? McGeorge usually has a top third requirement. If there's no stipulations then I would go to McGeorge. Sacramento is a nice area to buy a house in too.
If you really want to explore fields other than your uncles law firm without spending a fortune, you'll have to retake again.
Regarding the retake, I think you're right, retaking just isn't an option for me at this time in my career/family life. Thanks again for your reply, Champagne.
thelawyler wrote:
I know the retaking advice sucks, but I retook and renegotiated huge scholarships. Retaking and raising your score even a few point is THE BEST way to get money, as it both makes you a more attractive candidate and it shows to the school that you are serious in your threat to not matriculate. It's worth your time and money to do it. Even if you have only a 50% chance of upping your score 2-3 points with 50 extra hours of work/study, it is worth it. Think of it this way: if somebody offered you a 50% shot at $60,000 for 50 hours of work, would you take it? Of course you would, because that work has an Expected Value of $600 per hour. That's a fucking good hourly wage just for studying. And that's why you should retake. It's really a no brainer, especially because doing worse will not hurt you.
Annnnnd if there are stips on that scholarship, I wouldn't take it. Negotiate hard with them to make it go away.
I got offered that same deal at McGeorge and I think the key factor here is that the scholarship is clearly for the first year only. I think you need more information regarding stipulations and what kind of merit-based aid you would be getting for your second and third years. Maybe see if you could talk with admissions, explaining to them you are seriously considering it, but you want to know what would be coming your way 2l and 3l. Because if the stip is top-third and you're at median lets say, and they don't renew any sort of scholarship for the second and third years, then you just gave up the better opportunities at Davis/Hastings for 50k. For someone with a guaranteed job lined up, 50k extra is not that a huge sum long-term to warrant not going for greater opportunities, IMO.bayareahopeful wrote: To anyone reading this post I think we're just getting a little sidetracked with retaking, comparing stipulations, etc... I don't want to offend anyone but I'm really just looking for any information that I may have missed while talking to people who aren't in the law school application process, and people who are, so I came here for some advice from people who are familiar with the subject. It's going to be really hard for me to turn down a full ride from McGeorge, or the other two schools as well, even if I get a little money from Hastings or Davis. Again, thanks for all your responses and I look forward to hearing more opinions if they come.
You don't have a full ride to McGeorge. Also, sticker at Hastings/Davis will put you closer to 240K in debt than 140K unless you have substantial family assistance. Finally, you can re-take the LSAT in June (or February) with the intention of negotiating more scholarship money but still attending this fall.bayareahopeful wrote:It's going to be really hard for me to turn down a full ride from McGeorge, or the other two schools as well, even if I get a little money from Hastings or Davis. Again, thanks for all your responses and I look forward to hearing more opinions if they come.
Hey Splitter, thanks for the advice.Tiago Splitter wrote: You don't have a full ride to McGeorge. Also, sticker at Hastings/Davis will put you closer to 240K in debt than 140K unless you have substantial family assistance. Finally, you can re-take the LSAT in June (or February) with the intention of negotiating more scholarship money but still attending this fall.
You're right the scholarship is only guaranteed for the first year. From my understanding what McGeorge does for 2L's and 3L's is gives out substantial aid if you're in the top 10% or so of your class. But that wouldn't really apply to me because of the stipulations being in the top 1/3 of the class to keep the scholarship. So if I miss out on my scholarship renewing, I'd definitely miss out on any of the other scholarships available to 2L's and 3L's.superpippo wrote: I got offered that same deal at McGeorge and I think the key factor here is that the scholarship is clearly for the first year only. I think you need more information regarding stipulations and what kind of merit-based aid you would be getting for your second and third years. Maybe see if you could talk with admissions, explaining to them you are seriously considering it, but you want to know what would be coming your way 2l and 3l. Because if the stip is top-third and you're at median lets say, and they don't renew any sort of scholarship for the second and third years, then you just gave up the better opportunities at Davis/Hastings for 50k. For someone with a guaranteed job lined up, 50k extra is not that a huge sum long-term to warrant not going for greater opportunities, IMO.
I'd guess I'd look at this way. You have a job lined-up to mitigate debt-related issues if you never were to find a dream job at Hastings/Davis. Because the chances of finding such a job at Hastings/Davis would be higher than at McGeorge, and you have backup employment to hedge against any failure, the debt/opportunity ratio might be worth it in your case because the consequences of "failure" would be fairly low compared to the average 0L.
Well I'm planning on attending Hastings, however I have slightly above median stats so I'm hoping to get some $ (hopefully). I may have a potential job after college due to UG networking at a smaller firm, but regardless of that, for me, the McGeorge scholarship was nowhere near enticing enough for me to forgo the opportunities I would receive at Hastings (not saying they are amazing right now, just better than at McGeorge). If I were you, and you still wanted to go to school on scholarship, I would really try to negotiate with Santa Clara/USF (I think SC would give you better opportunities at least in Silicon Valley) and use the this scholarship offer to get a 3-year scholarship offer at one of these schools. You should have above 75% stats at both universities so I would just apply and wait for the financial aid offers; then maybe re-negotiate to see if you can get a better deal.bayareahopeful wrote: You're right the scholarship is only guaranteed for the first year. From my understanding what McGeorge does for 2L's and 3L's is gives out substantial aid if you're in the top 10% or so of your class. But that wouldn't really apply to me because of the stipulations being in the top 1/3 of the class to keep the scholarship. So if I miss out on my scholarship renewing, I'd definitely miss out on any of the other scholarships available to 2L's and 3L's.
That makes sense what you're saying about having a back up plan if I didn't land a "dream job". Definitely something to think about!
Since we've been in similar situations, what did you end up doing in choosing a law school? Thanks for the reply!