Page 1 of 2

Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 9:57 pm
by first_world_problems
Hi Everyone*,

So this has been addressed a few times, but I feel my case may be slightly different. On top of that, I have more questions about the whole ordeal of choosing between Harvard and Yale.

I aspire to be a legal academic! Before you say go to Yale, let me say this: aspiring is one thing; executing is another. Because I have not started law school nor do I know much about it, I have a feeling I might change my mind--I might in fact want to go corporate and be partner aka models and bottles! Alright, but in all seriousness, the following track is what I am thinking: law school and maybe an LLM at Cambridge (3-4 years) --> clerkship CoA and/or SCOTUS (1-4 years)** --> law firm ie Wachtell (2-4 years) --> academia. Since this is an idealized version, I am sure things can change. Maybe I won't get a clerkship, maybe I won't get into a law firm, maybe....

OK, so there were some TLS and above-the-law articles about Harvard v. Yale. Here are some points: I don't care about the MBA, and I don't care about the international presence. Here is what I care about: chilling out, little competition, fawk grades (I'm past that, and I know neither grades, but Yale has that great 1st semester brilliance and no set curve), fawk location (cambridge is better but whatever), doing research on topics I like, best clerkship placement opportunities, best firm placement opportunities, etc. By the way, if anyone can direct me to statistics on clerkship placements from either Harvard or Yale, I'd really appreciate it.

And here is the caveat: I have some strong connections at Harvard because of some research. I'm a pretty sociable gal, so I don't think I'll have trouble making connections at Yale. In fact, I am willing to keep my connections at Harvard by traveling by train (~2 hours) to continue working with some Harvard faculty, so I guess what I am asking is, "Is it not possible to maintain my relationships at Harvard as a JD student at Yale?" Oh, and son-of-a-gun does Harvard have some great interdisciplinary research and multiple centers...so much so that my interests (as they stand today) are only catered to by Harvard.

Strategically, my gut feeling tells me that Yale is the best option. I think I just really wants numbers (and advice!) at this point. What is the placement for clerkships at Yale v. Harvard? Will Wachtell want a Yalie more than a Harvard grad? How much more will Yale benefit me? Can't I somehow bridge the two bastards and eat most of the pie?

Oh and just for all the people who might post the "First World Problem" memes: I am grateful for this opportunity to choose between two awesome schools, and it pains me to make such difficult decisions.

So just to recap: I aspire to do academia, I have connections at Harvard, I want the best for me long-term, I need strategy, and I am grateful for my first world problems, and I thank all for respondin'.

*This message has been sponsored by first_world_problems, and she is officially dizz-er-unk! Also, I apologize for any spelling/grammatical errors--I blame it on the lick-hor!

**Can someone tell me exactly what the strategy would be to put myself in the best position for a clerkship. I know grades, I know writing sample, but what else? If there are good blogs about it, especially telling one what they need to do to prepare, then please share!

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 10:00 pm
by chup
Yale.




Also, you're annoying.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 10:00 pm
by ph14
first_world_problems wrote:Hi Everyone*,

So this has been addressed a few times, but I feel my case may be slightly different. On top of that, I have more questions about the whole ordeal of choosing between Harvard and Yale.

I aspire to be a legal academic! Before you say go to Yale, let me say this: aspiring is one thing; executing is another. Because I have not started law school nor do I know much about it, I have a feeling I might change my mind--I might in fact want to go corporate and be partner aka models and bottles! Alright, but in all seriousness, the following track is what I am thinking: law school and maybe an LLM at Cambridge (3-4 years) --> clerkship CoA and/or SCOTUS (1-4 years)** --> law firm ie Wachtell (2-4 years) --> academia. Since this is an idealized version, I am sure things can change. Maybe I won't get a clerkship, maybe I won't get into a law firm, maybe....

OK, so there were some TLS and above-the-law articles about Harvard v. Yale. Here are some points: I don't care about the MBA, and I don't care about the international presence. Here is what I care about: chilling out, little competition, fawk grades (I'm past that, and I know neither grades, but Yale has that great 1st semester brilliance and no set curve), fawk location (cambridge is better but whatever), doing research on topics I like, best clerkship placement opportunities, best firm placement opportunities, etc. By the way, if anyone can direct me to statistics on clerkship placements from either Harvard or Yale, I'd really appreciate it.

And here is the caveat: I have some strong connections at Harvard because of some research. I'm a pretty sociable gal, so I don't think I'll have trouble making connections at Yale. In fact, I am willing to keep my connections at Harvard by traveling by train (~2 hours) to continue working with some Harvard faculty, so I guess what I am asking is, "Is it not possible to maintain my relationships at Harvard as a JD student at Yale?" Oh, and son-of-a-gun does Harvard have some great interdisciplinary research and multiple centers...so much so that my interests (as they stand today) are only catered to by Harvard.

Strategically, my gut feeling tells me that Yale is the best option. I think I just really wants numbers (and advice!) at this point. What is the placement for clerkships at Yale v. Harvard? Will Wachtell want a Yalie more than a Harvard grad? How much more will Yale benefit me? Can't I somehow bridge the two bastards and eat most of the pie?

Oh and just for all the people who might post the "First World Problem" memes: I am grateful for this opportunity to choose between two awesome schools, and it pains me to make such difficult decisions.

So just to recap: I aspire to do academia, I have connections at Harvard, I want the best for me long-term, I need strategy, and I am grateful for my first world problems, and I thank all for respondin'.

*This message has been sponsored by first_world_problems, and she is officially dizz-er-unk! Also, I apologize for any spelling/grammatical errors--I blame it on the lick-hor!

**Can someone tell me exactly what the strategy would be to put myself in the best position for a clerkship. I know grades, I know writing sample, but what else? If there are good blogs about it, especially telling one what they need to do to prepare, then please share!
Definitely Yale. For everything you have mentioned, Yale is unequivocally the better option. Academia = Yale, you can make new connections at Yale and i'm sure you can still maintain your connections at Harvard via email/occasional visits.

To put yourself in the best position for a clerkship get good grades and build relationships with professors.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 10:09 pm
by DaftAndDirect
I don't think my LSAT score or my GPA are high enough to comment.

But definitely Yale. You seem like a gadabout.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 10:20 pm
by splitbrain
first_world_problems wrote:What is the placement for clerkships at Yale v. Harvard?
Awesome LSAT/GPA but can't use Google? Now that's a #firstworldproblem:

http://www.law.harvard.edu/current/care ... index.html
Harvard last 3 years: 20.71%, 20.11%, 18.47%

http://www.law.yale.edu/studentlife/cdo ... tstats.htm
Yale last 3 years: 36.3%, 30.6%, 35.1%

Also:
"In recent years we have seen an increasing number of graduates choose to work for one or two years before clerking. For example, while 36.3% of the Class of 2010 clerked in their first job after law school, to date 46% of the Class has served as a judicial clerk at some point since graduating."
first_world_problems wrote:**Can someone tell me exactly what the strategy would be to put myself in the best position for a clerkship. I know grades, I know writing sample, but what else? If there are good blogs about it, especially telling one what they need to do to prepare, then please share!
Go to Yale.
first_world_problems wrote:*This message has been sponsored by first_world_problems, and she is officially dizz-er-unk! Also, I apologize for any spelling/grammatical errors--I blame it on the lick-hor!
....go to Yale.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 10:29 pm
by CanadianWolf
But just think how delicious it would be to tell everybody that you turned down Yale.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 11:06 pm
by 1776
Wow.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 11:08 pm
by bk1
aschup wrote:Yale.




Also, you're annoying.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 11:15 pm
by RodneyBoonfield
If you're hot, you should go to Harvard and pose as Elle Woods. Don't break character. Ever.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 11:18 pm
by Richie Tenenbaum
bk187 wrote:
aschup wrote:Yale.




Also, you're annoying.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Wed Mar 21, 2012 11:23 pm
by checkster
Yale. Enjoy being the boss of these bitter TLS folk.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Thu Mar 22, 2012 4:50 am
by organic muskrat
Yale - for the additional reason of networking. I'd rather have strong contacts at two top law schools than "only" one.

Oh yeah: as you know, publish or perish. Shoot for >1/year in law school and do >2/year after that.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 4:31 pm
by wolfmalfoy
------.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 4:41 pm
by Tom Joad
Richie Tenenbaum wrote:
bk187 wrote:
aschup wrote:Yale.




Also, you're annoying.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 4:47 pm
by nkp007
first_world_problems wrote:Hi Everyone*,

So this has been addressed a few times, but I feel my case may be slightly different. On top of that, I have more questions about the whole ordeal of choosing between Harvard and Yale.

I aspire to be a legal academic! Before you say go to Yale, let me say this: aspiring is one thing; executing is another. Because I have not started law school nor do I know much about it, I have a feeling I might change my mind--I might in fact want to go corporate and be partner aka models and bottles! Alright, but in all seriousness, the following track is what I am thinking: law school and maybe an LLM at Cambridge (3-4 years) --> clerkship CoA and/or SCOTUS (1-4 years)** --> law firm ie Wachtell (2-4 years) --> academia. Since this is an idealized version, I am sure things can change. Maybe I won't get a clerkship, maybe I won't get into a law firm, maybe....

OK, so there were some TLS and above-the-law articles about Harvard v. Yale. Here are some points: I don't care about the MBA, and I don't care about the international presence. Here is what I care about: chilling out, little competition, fawk grades (I'm past that, and I know neither grades, but Yale has that great 1st semester brilliance and no set curve), fawk location (cambridge is better but whatever), doing research on topics I like, best clerkship placement opportunities, best firm placement opportunities, etc. By the way, if anyone can direct me to statistics on clerkship placements from either Harvard or Yale, I'd really appreciate it.

And here is the caveat: I have some strong connections at Harvard because of some research. I'm a pretty sociable gal, so I don't think I'll have trouble making connections at Yale. In fact, I am willing to keep my connections at Harvard by traveling by train (~2 hours) to continue working with some Harvard faculty, so I guess what I am asking is, "Is it not possible to maintain my relationships at Harvard as a JD student at Yale?" Oh, and son-of-a-gun does Harvard have some great interdisciplinary research and multiple centers...so much so that my interests (as they stand today) are only catered to by Harvard.

Strategically, my gut feeling tells me that Yale is the best option. I think I just really wants numbers (and advice!) at this point. What is the placement for clerkships at Yale v. Harvard? Will Wachtell want a Yalie more than a Harvard grad? How much more will Yale benefit me? Can't I somehow bridge the two bastards and eat most of the pie?

Oh and just for all the people who might post the "First World Problem" memes: I am grateful for this opportunity to choose between two awesome schools, and it pains me to make such difficult decisions.

So just to recap: I aspire to do academia, I have connections at Harvard, I want the best for me long-term, I need strategy, and I am grateful for my first world problems, and I thank all for respondin'.

*This message has been sponsored by first_world_problems, and she is officially dizz-er-unk! Also, I apologize for any spelling/grammatical errors--I blame it on the lick-hor!

**Can someone tell me exactly what the strategy would be to put myself in the best position for a clerkship. I know grades, I know writing sample, but what else? If there are good blogs about it, especially telling one what they need to do to prepare, then please share!
Depends...how pregnant are you?

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 4:48 pm
by rad lulz
.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 4:56 pm
by chiwachiwa
organic muskrat wrote:Yale - for the additional reason of networking. I'd rather have strong contacts at two top law schools than "only" one.

Oh yeah: as you know, publish or perish. Shoot for >1/year in law school and do >2/year after that.
What? No. Few tenure-track professors publish 3+ articles per year. As long as you have a Yale JD, 3 solid pubs, and a COA clerkship, you should be alright on the meat market depending on your niche. But enjoy the impending law school tuition bubble burst! You may actually have to teach *gasp* 3 or 4 classes per semester.

Oh, and:
Tom Joad wrote:
Richie Tenenbaum wrote:
bk187 wrote:
aschup wrote:Yale.




Also, you're annoying.
What an obnoxious post.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 6:07 pm
by mrtoren
Tom Joad wrote:
Richie Tenenbaum wrote:
bk187 wrote:
aschup wrote:Yale.




Also, you're annoying.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 7:00 pm
by Ti Malice
Perhaps it's rash of me to make any strong character judgments based on just a solitary message board post, but I find myself strongly hoping you'll choose Harvard.
checkster wrote:Yale. Enjoy being the boss of these bitter TLS folk.
I don't think bitterness has much to do with anything in this thread.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 9:54 pm
by first_world_problems
Ti Malice wrote:Perhaps it's rash of me to make any strong character judgments based on just a solitary message board post, but I find myself strongly hoping you'll choose Harvard.
checkster wrote:Yale. Enjoy being the boss of these bitter TLS folk.
I don't think bitterness has much to do with anything in this thread.
Zomg! ROFL-copters! Aren't you the most generous poster! Perhaps I can say the same about you--perhaps you should have taken the Butler at Columbia! Based off of your reply, I find Your character--perhaps!--to be more befitting of a particular subset of NYCers. (And Ti malice stop acting like Yale is full of love--it is a law school like any other and has its gunners and jerks. Better yet save your perfunctory gobbledegook for yourself.)

Regardless of your yahoo comment (and of those who find me "annoying"), I do want to give my thanks for the votes thus far and for the replies that address my questions.

PS--I am not pregnant, but am looking for donors with perfect LSAT scores!

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 9:55 pm
by slsorhls
law school and maybe an LLM at Cambridge (3-4 years) --> clerkship CoA and/or SCOTUS (1-4 years)** --> law firm ie Wachtell (2-4 years) --> academia.
Um, no one else sees this as obvious trolling?

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 10:00 pm
by first_world_problems
slsorhls wrote:
law school and maybe an LLM at Cambridge (3-4 years) --> clerkship CoA and/or SCOTUS (1-4 years)** --> law firm ie Wachtell (2-4 years) --> academia.
Um, no one else sees this as obvious trolling?
Trolling in what way? I said that it is an *ideal* route.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 10:03 pm
by 071816
Fenwick doesn't do OCI at Yale. Therefore, Harvard will provide you with superior career opportunities.

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 10:04 pm
by first_world_problems
chimp wrote:Fenwick doesn't do OCI at Yale. Therefore, Harvard will provide you with superior career opportunities.

Hahaha! Yes I read this! The truth about Yale stings!

Re: Harvard v. Yale (First World Problems)

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 11:25 pm
by chiwachiwa
Stop...just, stop.