H/Y/S vs. NYU w/scholly Forum

[ChriLa425]

Hey guys,

Completely theoretical post at this point, seeing as I´ve not heard back from H/Y/S and won´t hear back for the B&B scholly till April, but if you were offered a full scholarship at NYU versus admission at H/Y/S which would you choose?

[BlueDiamond]

worry about it when it happens

[ChriLa425]

not worried just curious

[FuManChusco]

HYS all day

[charliebrownwn]

i would take Y or S, but only if it didnt conflict with my astronaut training and if natalie portman said it was OK if we waited a couple more years before we bought the yacht and sailed around the world together.

[FuManChusco]

i would take Y or S, but only if it didnt conflict with my astronaut training and if natalie portman said it was OK if we waited a couple more years before we bought the yacht and sailed around the world together.

Lulz. Why is OP asking this with a 3.7/174?

[christinalsat]

I'm actually deciding between H/Y (still waiting on Stanford) and NYU -- potentially with a scholarship as I was selected as a finalist for one of their full scholarship programs (we'll see). Any advice?

NYU was always my top choice until I made it into H/Y. I still gravitate towards NYC (particularly over New Haven).

[ChriLa425]

i would take Y or S, but only if it didnt conflict with my astronaut training and if natalie portman said it was OK if we waited a couple more years before we bought the yacht and sailed around the world together.

oh good point, I also forgot to include the Natalie effect. Is she yours exclusively or would you be willing to share on weekends?

[ChriLa425]

I'm actually deciding between H/Y (still waiting on Stanford) and NYU -- potentially with a scholarship as I was selected as a finalist for one of their full scholarship programs (we'll see). Any advice?

NYU was always my top choice until I made it into H/Y. I still gravitate towards NYC (particularly over New Haven).

ooh congrats on all your great options! My question is theoretical but yours isn´t, well done!

[westbayguy]

There is much discussion on this issue- poke around TLS and you should find it.

For a recent discussion see Asha's discussion at

http://blogs.law.yale.edu/blogs/admissions/default.aspx

Are you up for a Furman or RTK? Doyou want to be an academic or do PI? How important is the scholly to you?

[sarahh]

I'm actually deciding between H/Y (still waiting on Stanford) and NYU -- potentially with a scholarship as I was selected as a finalist for one of their full scholarship programs (we'll see). Any advice?

NYU was always my top choice until I made it into H/Y. I still gravitate towards NYC (particularly over New Haven).

ooh congrats on all your great options! My question is theoretical but yours isn´t, well done!

Okay, I had to look it up, since I only know about RTK. Is it Bickel & Brewer? Personally, I would go with that. In addition to the scholarship, it seems that you get additional training and mentoring. And they only require you to do two years of public-interest work after graduating (and give you a fellowship if you cannot find something!).

[ahduth]

FWIW, one of the people I've been talking to about this school selection process took Stanford with minimal money over a full ride plus stipend at NYU. He's a fifth year at Skadden now, so I guess he started school in 2002? He's also black and killed it in engineering in undergrad, so take it with the grain of salt that entails.

He said he probably should have gone with NYU. Based on his thinking, whatever marginal benefit he might have gotten with Stanford on his resume was offset by the large amount of money he left on the table. Surprisingly he said that he'd feel even more strongly about that if he were applying this year. They interview students at both Stanford and NYU, and take people from both places. Saying "no thanks" to over a hundred thousand dollars for some nebulous benefit during the interview process doesn't hold water in his book, at least if you're going for work at a firm like his. He did say that clerkships could be a different story, however.

[jonfen]

.

[ChriLa425]

I'm actually deciding between H/Y (still waiting on Stanford) and NYU -- potentially with a scholarship as I was selected as a finalist for one of their full scholarship programs (we'll see). Any advice?

NYU was always my top choice until I made it into H/Y. I still gravitate towards NYC (particularly over New Haven).

ooh congrats on all your great options! My question is theoretical but yours isn´t, well done!

Okay, I had to look it up, since I only know about RTK. Is it Bickel & Brewer? Personally, I would go with that. In addition to the scholarship, it seems that you get additional training and mentoring. And they only require you to do two years of public-interest work after graduating (and give you a fellowship if you cannot find something!).

Yeah its Bickel and Brewer, and they do give you hands-on experience in that program unlike in some of the other scholarships. There´s such a split in opinion over the tangible effect of $$ versus the intangible benefit of H/Y/S

[Frankie55]

Hi guys,

Do you know if Harvard ever increases their grant offer if you try to negotiate with them? I received $90,000 from Chicago and Duke and am considering filling out NYU's scholarship application if Harvard considers these kinds of situations.

FYI, I will probably qualify for the highest amount of grant aid (which I read is a measly $13,000/year?) and definitely need all the aid I can get.

Thank you!

Which NYU app are you talking about? I was under the impression the named scholarships are in the finalist stage now. Did you receive a Dean's invite? ('cause to my knowledge, no one else on TLS has yet).

As to your question, I'm not sure, but Harvard's official position is that their formula is based entirely on need.

[jonfen]

Haha, no nothing special like that. I just got an email from the NYU FinAid dept talking about filling out some sort of application. I had only skimmed it before, but on second reading, it's just the Need Access Form that I would need to fill out for NYU.

Thanks for the response.