Page 1 of 1

Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 11:51 am
by jimraynor
I'm primarily interested in PI/Govt in the DC area. I was wondering if this has an impact on school selection within the T14.
I'm in at Georgetown, UVA, and NYU. It seems that ITE UVA and NYU are faring a bit better overall. I just don't have any real way to evaluate how important it is to attend school in the region I wish to work.

Thoughts?

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 11:56 am
by nbaguy
If all at sticker, UVA > NYU > Georgetown.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 11:58 am
by tipler4213
nbaguy wrote:If all at sticker, UVA > NYU > Georgetown.
Why on earth would you put UVA above NYU. PI/Govt is NYUs bread n' butter.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 2:44 pm
by jimraynor
Thanks!

Yeah, I am assuming they are all going to be at/near sticker

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 3:53 pm
by vamedic03
jimraynor wrote:I'm primarily interested in PI/Govt in the DC area. I was wondering if this has an impact on school selection within the T14.
I'm in at Georgetown, UVA, and NYU. It seems that ITE UVA and NYU are faring a bit better overall. I just don't have any real way to evaluate how important it is to attend school in the region I wish to work.

Thoughts?
Are you in-state for UVA?

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Sun Feb 06, 2011 4:02 pm
by Ialdabaoth
What kind of PI/government are you interested in? I would recommend searching for attorney profiles at organizations that interest you because some organizations have particularly strong ties to certain law schools. This type of research proved to be very helpful in giving me an idea of what schools I should target. HTH!

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 8:41 am
by jimraynor
vamedic03 wrote:
jimraynor wrote:I'm primarily interested in PI/Govt in the DC area. I was wondering if this has an impact on school selection within the T14.
I'm in at Georgetown, UVA, and NYU. It seems that ITE UVA and NYU are faring a bit better overall. I just don't have any real way to evaluate how important it is to attend school in the region I wish to work.

Thoughts?
Are you in-state for UVA?
Yup.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 10:43 am
by SupraVln180
NYU is clearly, clearly, clearly the best school. Especially for your interests. I absolutely love UVa, location-wise and QoL-wise. But do not turn down NYU. You might not regret it, since UVa is a great option, but NYU will open up more doors especially in PI/Gov't than UVa.

Georgetown shouldn't be an option, it isn't even really a T-14.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 12:08 pm
by Sentry
I don't know much about GT's and UVA's LRAPs but NYU's LRAP is fantastic.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 12:35 pm
by romothesavior
tipler4213 wrote:
nbaguy wrote:If all at sticker, UVA > NYU > Georgetown.
Why on earth would you put UVA above NYU. PI/Govt is NYUs bread n' butter.
+1

NYU for sure

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 7:53 pm
by showNprove
tipler4213 wrote:PI/Govt is NYUs bread n' butter.
This is true, and NYU's LRAP is also better, but--and I haven't seen NYU's geographical PI/Gov't placement numbers, so correct me if I'm wrong--I'm under the impression that U.Va. does much better in placing students in Gov't positions outside of NYC.

Either way, TCR is definitely not Georgetown. I would find out more about the geographical placement of U.Va./NYU grads in these jobs, then way your desire to do PI vs. your desire to do PI in DC. If NYU is the better option for both, then the decision is easy.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 7:56 pm
by paulinaporizkova
jimraynor wrote:
vamedic03 wrote:
jimraynor wrote:I'm primarily interested in PI/Govt in the DC area. I was wondering if this has an impact on school selection within the T14.
I'm in at Georgetown, UVA, and NYU. It seems that ITE UVA and NYU are faring a bit better overall. I just don't have any real way to evaluate how important it is to attend school in the region I wish to work.

Thoughts?
Are you in-state for UVA?
Yup.
I voted UVA after I read that you were in state. In state tuition plus way lower cost of living = win over NYU. Why did more people vote for GULC than UVA in the poll??? I would take either UVA or NYU if you heart is set on NYC, but never GULC - even if it is in DC (for PI purposes)

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 9:17 pm
by vamedic03
jimraynor wrote:
vamedic03 wrote:
jimraynor wrote:I'm primarily interested in PI/Govt in the DC area. I was wondering if this has an impact on school selection within the T14.
I'm in at Georgetown, UVA, and NYU. It seems that ITE UVA and NYU are faring a bit better overall. I just don't have any real way to evaluate how important it is to attend school in the region I wish to work.

Thoughts?
Are you in-state for UVA?
Yup.
I'd go to UVA if I was in your shoes - in-state tuition = 5K reduction in tuition/year.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 9:26 pm
by nealric
Georgetown shouldn't be an option, it isn't even really a T-14.
And you aren't really even a law student.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 9:32 pm
by nbaguy
tipler4213 wrote:
nbaguy wrote:If all at sticker, UVA > NYU > Georgetown.
Why on earth would you put UVA above NYU. PI/Govt is NYUs bread n' butter.
He wants to be in DC and he is in-state. The CoL + Tuition difference is a lot. However, with IBR and PSLF, depending on current financial situation, maybe the $$ difference is meaningless.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 9:38 pm
by tea_drinker
Ialdabaoth wrote:What kind of PI/government are you interested in? I would recommend searching for attorney profiles at organizations that interest you because some organizations have particularly strong ties to certain law schools. This type of research proved to be very helpful in giving me an idea of what schools I should target. HTH!
Example(s)please?
showNprove wrote: I haven't seen NYU's geographical PI/Gov't placement numbers, so correct me if I'm wrong--I'm under the impression that U.Va. does much better in placing students in Gov't positions outside of NYC.
Show and prove?
paulinaporizkova wrote: Why did more people vote for GULC than UVA in the poll??? I would take either UVA or NYU if you heart is set on NYC, but never GULC - even if it is in DC (for PI purposes)
GULC has a great clinical program. And if you are looking at general PI, you certainly have access to a plethora of opportunities at GULC

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 7:58 am
by Ialdabaoth
Ialdabaoth wrote:What kind of PI/government are you interested in? I would recommend searching for attorney profiles at organizations that interest you because some organizations have particularly strong ties to certain law schools. This type of research proved to be very helpful in giving me an idea of what schools I should target. HTH!
tea_drinker wrote:Example(s)please?


I've compiled attorney profile data with law school and significant experience/honors (e.g. law review and clerkships) for the attorneys at several environmental PI organizations. Most of the results were unsurprising, i.e. the T14 was very well-represented across the board, but some other things were surprising. For instance, although NYU is great for PI in general, they have very few attorneys at the big PI enviro legal organizations (Earthjustice, Sierra Club Environmental Law Program, SELC, etc.). While some of this may be self-selection out of such employment, that wouldn't seem to account for all of the difference because NYU is big on both PI and environmental. There are certainly other schools that are ranked lower and comparably that place very well in comparison to NYU. For instance, Boalt and UVa both have 4-5+ attorneys at Earthjustice compared to NYU. (However, only 52/72 of Earthjustice's attorneys have profiles on their website.) Moreover, there are much lower ranked schools like Vermont and Golden Gate that have several attorneys at organizations like the Sierra Club due to externship programs at those schools that give people a great foot in the door. Last, UVa dominates placement at the Southern Environmental Law Center because of its location in Charlottesville. Again, this is partially self-selection, but I believe it is also due to access and networking opportunities available to UVa students while in law school.

TL;DL Some schools out place their ranking/generally do very well at specific organizations due to local connections and externship/placement programs.

I'll put up all of my data in a new post when I have it better organized.

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 1:32 pm
by jimraynor
Thanks for all the thoughts!

I'll see what I think of the schools once I've been to all the accepted students weekends as well...

Re: Where should I go for PI/govt?

Posted: Tue Feb 08, 2011 1:48 pm
by bk1
UVa's LRAP (the fact that it uses IBR and can royally screw you if you lose employment during the 10 year period) seems pretty meh to me.

The difference between NYU versus UVa in cost is not large enough, in this case, for me to think that UVa is better due to the differences in LRAP.