Page 1 of 2

Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 1:46 am
by poo
My friend to accepted to all the schools mentioned in the title and would have to pay sticker at Duke and Georgetown and graduate with a shit ton of debt, or he would go to UF/ FSU for free. He's 100% sure he wants to stay in Florida and is having a hard time trying to decide if the debt is worth it. I really can't find anything on this, so if someone has any feed back I (we) would really appreciate it!

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 1:49 am
by Cupidity
Duke

/thread

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 1:50 am
by pugalicious
Is he good-looking and single? Then he should go to FSU. : )

Sorry I don't have any real help (0L), but if he could go to UF or FSU for free, and he wants to stay in Florida, either of those seem like the obvious choice.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 1:50 am
by poo
Cupidity wrote:Duke

/thread
Will you please explain why?

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 1:53 am
by JollyGreenGiant
This is one of those threads where I have absolutely no idea.

Umm.. what are the career goals? ex. biglaw, clerkship, PI, academia, etc.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 1:55 am
by poo
JollyGreenGiant wrote:This is one of those threads where I have absolutely no idea.

Umm.. what are the career goals? ex. biglaw, clerkship, PI, academia, etc.
He would like biglaw for sure (which is why maybe Duke or Georgetown?), so I guess the question is for a big firm job in Florida, is Duke > UF/ FSU for biglaw to the point where it is worth debt.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 2:02 am
by JollyGreenGiant
Biglaw or bust usually means go to the highest ranked school possible. I, personally, would take a regional school full scholly over anything except T6-10. But, I'm definitely not biglaw or bust and I'm probably a little more debt averse than the average person.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 2:06 am
by DerrickRose
While Biglaw writ large is a much more certain proposition at Duke than Florida (which places more strongly in FL than FSU from everything I hear), Florida Biglaw may not be.

I wouldn't chance the debt. If you're 100% committed to living in Florida, Go Gators.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 2:41 am
by A'nold
See, the problem w/ the advice I'm going to give is that I probably wouldn't take it if it were me, haha.

Seattle is my target market and UW absolutely owns it. If I had received a full-ride there (I know they don't give them but for the sake of the argument.....) and I had been accepted to Duke, I think I'd make the mistake of taking Duke. Maybe not. But I think the responsible answer here would be UF.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 2:44 am
by im_blue
poo wrote:
JollyGreenGiant wrote:This is one of those threads where I have absolutely no idea.

Umm.. what are the career goals? ex. biglaw, clerkship, PI, academia, etc.
He would like biglaw for sure (which is why maybe Duke or Georgetown?), so I guess the question is for a big firm job in Florida, is Duke > UF/ FSU for biglaw to the point where it is worth debt.
Since he wants biglaw, the correct choice is Duke.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 2:46 am
by poo
im_blue wrote:
poo wrote:
JollyGreenGiant wrote:This is one of those threads where I have absolutely no idea.

Umm.. what are the career goals? ex. biglaw, clerkship, PI, academia, etc.
He would like biglaw for sure (which is why maybe Duke or Georgetown?), so I guess the question is for a big firm job in Florida, is Duke > UF/ FSU for biglaw to the point where it is worth debt.
Since he wants biglaw, the correct choice is Duke.

Even for Florida biglaw?

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 3:08 am
by Cupidity
What did I say? DUKE.

All the top firms in the south east recruit from Duke. That includes Florida.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 3:17 am
by A'nold
On a side note, UF is getting crushed employment-wise. Students at the very top had to struggle this past year BIGTIME. Even if you are in the top 5% there biglaw is not a sure thing right now.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 3:17 am
by lshopeful3232
Cupidity wrote:What did I say? DUKE.

All the top firms in the south east recruit from Duke. That includes Florida.

what makes you certain that a top florida firm would recruit from duke over its own UF graduates? Duke only sends 10% of its grads to the South actually and Florida is not among the most popular. i mean, that's of course obvious, but i get the sense that Florida firms wouldn't necessarily go for Duke before UF every time. I think it depends where you are looking in Florida though too as half of Florida is more "southern" and the other part has a more "northern" population that might be more keen on Duke.

i'm not saying the Florida schools are definitely better but they are giving you the chance to be debt free and if you are set on florida, it will work out for you in the end and UF should not be underestimated as it is the top ranked Florida school

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 3:24 am
by bk1
lshopeful3232 wrote:
Cupidity wrote:What did I say? DUKE.

All the top firms in the south east recruit from Duke. That includes Florida.

what makes you certain that a top florida firm would recruit from duke over its own UF graduates? Duke only sends 10% of its grads to the South actually and Florida is not among the most popular. i mean, that's of course obvious, but i get the sense that Florida firms wouldn't necessarily go for Duke before UF every time. I think it depends where you are looking in Florida though too as half of Florida is more "southern" and the other part has a more "northern" population that might be more keen on Duke.

i'm not saying the Florida schools are definitely better but they are giving you the chance to be debt free and if you are set on florida, it will work out for you in the end and UF should not be underestimated as it is the top ranked Florida school
I would only add that part of the Duke stats is self-selection.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 3:27 am
by Cupidity
lshopeful3232 wrote:
Cupidity wrote:What did I say? DUKE.

All the top firms in the south east recruit from Duke. That includes Florida.

what makes you certain that a top florida firm would recruit from duke over its own UF graduates? Duke only sends 10% of its grads to the South actually and Florida is not among the most popular. i mean, that's of course obvious, but i get the sense that Florida firms wouldn't necessarily go for Duke before UF every time. I think it depends where you are looking in Florida though too as half of Florida is more "southern" and the other part has a more "northern" population that might be more keen on Duke.

i'm not saying the Florida schools are definitely better but they are giving you the chance to be debt free and if you are set on florida, it will work out for you in the end and UF should not be underestimated as it is the top ranked Florida school
Are you really going to lecture me on the cultural breakdown of my homestate? And its not half and half anyway dude, its thirds. The North third is the South, the Middle third is the North, and the South third is Cuba.

Any cursory look at employment stats should be sufficient to quiet you. As stated above, even as top-dog in Florida, UF does a poor job of securing top-jobs in state. The few BIGLAW firms in the state are not home-grown, but rather, are sattelite offices for out of state firms. While this, of course, is nothing uncommon, the desirablity of Florida for employment, coupled with this and the fact the states best local school is barely hanging in to the first tier, means that many of the top firm jobs here go to T-14 grads from up north. I have been in and worked for such firms,

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 9:52 am
by FlightoftheEarls
im_blue wrote:
poo wrote:
JollyGreenGiant wrote:This is one of those threads where I have absolutely no idea.

Umm.. what are the career goals? ex. biglaw, clerkship, PI, academia, etc.
He would like biglaw for sure (which is why maybe Duke or Georgetown?), so I guess the question is for a big firm job in Florida, is Duke > UF/ FSU for biglaw to the point where it is worth debt.
Since he wants biglaw, the correct choice is Duke.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 9:59 am
by Aberzombie1892
poo wrote:My friend to accepted to all the schools mentioned in the title and would have to pay sticker at Duke and Georgetown and graduate with a shit ton of debt, or he would go to UF/ FSU for free. He's 100% sure he wants to stay in Florida and is having a hard time trying to decide if the debt is worth it. I really can't find anything on this, so if someone has any feed back I (we) would really appreciate it!
I think your friend needs to be clearer on what he/she means by "big law."

You see, big law cuts off at firms of about 166 lawyers (it changes year to year).

I'm pretty sure that there is not a massive presence of big law firm offices in FL to begin with.

If your friend thinks that he/she would happy working at a firm with more than 50+ lawyers, irregardless of the "big law' distinction made online, then he/she should go to UF (easily).

If your friend has to absolutely/positively work at a "big law" firm, he/she should go to Duke.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 10:02 am
by lshopeful3232
Cupidity wrote:
lshopeful3232 wrote:
Cupidity wrote:What did I say? DUKE.

All the top firms in the south east recruit from Duke. That includes Florida.

what makes you certain that a top florida firm would recruit from duke over its own UF graduates? Duke only sends 10% of its grads to the South actually and Florida is not among the most popular. i mean, that's of course obvious, but i get the sense that Florida firms wouldn't necessarily go for Duke before UF every time. I think it depends where you are looking in Florida though too as half of Florida is more "southern" and the other part has a more "northern" population that might be more keen on Duke.

i'm not saying the Florida schools are definitely better but they are giving you the chance to be debt free and if you are set on florida, it will work out for you in the end and UF should not be underestimated as it is the top ranked Florida school
Are you really going to lecture me on the cultural breakdown of my homestate? And its not half and half anyway dude, its thirds. The North third is the South, the Middle third is the North, and the South third is Cuba.

Any cursory look at employment stats should be sufficient to quiet you. As stated above, even as top-dog in Florida, UF does a poor job of securing top-jobs in state. The few BIGLAW firms in the state are not home-grown, but rather, are sattelite offices for out of state firms. While this, of course, is nothing uncommon, the desirablity of Florida for employment, coupled with this and the fact the states best local school is barely hanging in to the first tier, means that many of the top firm jobs here go to T-14 grads from up north. I have been in and worked for such firms,
Wow, not trying to lecture anyone, chill. I'm not disagreeing with what you are saying, just trying to assure the OP that if they are debt adverse, then UF isn't a bad option is all. I didn't realize the OP only wanted Big law anyway....Hardly trying to analyze the cultural breakdown of Florida, nor do i particularly care.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Mon May 03, 2010 10:21 am
by tilghmab
Cupidity wrote:
lshopeful3232 wrote:
Cupidity wrote:What did I say? DUKE.

All the top firms in the south east recruit from Duke. That includes Florida.

what makes you certain that a top florida firm would recruit from duke over its own UF graduates? Duke only sends 10% of its grads to the South actually and Florida is not among the most popular. i mean, that's of course obvious, but i get the sense that Florida firms wouldn't necessarily go for Duke before UF every time. I think it depends where you are looking in Florida though too as half of Florida is more "southern" and the other part has a more "northern" population that might be more keen on Duke.

i'm not saying the Florida schools are definitely better but they are giving you the chance to be debt free and if you are set on florida, it will work out for you in the end and UF should not be underestimated as it is the top ranked Florida school
Are you really going to lecture me on the cultural breakdown of my homestate? And its not half and half anyway dude, its thirds. The North third is the South, the Middle third is the North, and the South third is Cuba.

Any cursory look at employment stats should be sufficient to quiet you. As stated above, even as top-dog in Florida, UF does a poor job of securing top-jobs in state. The few BIGLAW firms in the state are not home-grown, but rather, are sattelite offices for out of state firms. While this, of course, is nothing uncommon, the desirablity of Florida for employment, coupled with this and the fact the states best local school is barely hanging in to the first tier, means that many of the top firm jobs here go to T-14 grads from up north. I have been in and worked for such firms,
Shameless Orlando trolling.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Tue May 04, 2010 11:00 am
by Jericwithers
Whats wrong with Orlando?

I agree with what was said that there are no real 'biglaw' jobs in Florida. From my research there are no market paying $160k jobs in Florida at all. If the motivation is Florida or bust, then go UF or FSU. If it is biglaw $$$ or bust, then go Duke. I would just be worried paying off the debt load when the best firms in Florida pay at most $145k, and when those jobs are quite scarce.

Check out http://www.nalpdirectory.com for my info and to do some research into OCI at all these schools.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Wed May 05, 2010 12:36 pm
by tilghmab
Jericwithers wrote:Whats wrong with Orlando?

I agree with what was said that there are no real 'biglaw' jobs in Florida. From my research there are no market paying $160k jobs in Florida at all. If the motivation is Florida or bust, then go UF or FSU. If it is biglaw $$$ or bust, then go Duke. I would just be worried paying off the debt load when the best firms in Florida pay at most $145k, and when those jobs are quite scarce.

Check out http://www.nalpdirectory.com for my info and to do some research into OCI at all these schools.
Orlando is fine (except for the drivers) - just sticking up for the Magic City.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Wed May 05, 2010 12:57 pm
by Jericwithers
I would dare to say that the driving problems exists in all parts of Florida.

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Wed May 05, 2010 1:01 pm
by Dr. Strangelove
Cupidity wrote:
lshopeful3232 wrote:
Cupidity wrote:What did I say? DUKE.

All the top firms in the south east recruit from Duke. That includes Florida.

what makes you certain that a top florida firm would recruit from duke over its own UF graduates? Duke only sends 10% of its grads to the South actually and Florida is not among the most popular. i mean, that's of course obvious, but i get the sense that Florida firms wouldn't necessarily go for Duke before UF every time. I think it depends where you are looking in Florida though too as half of Florida is more "southern" and the other part has a more "northern" population that might be more keen on Duke.

i'm not saying the Florida schools are definitely better but they are giving you the chance to be debt free and if you are set on florida, it will work out for you in the end and UF should not be underestimated as it is the top ranked Florida school
Are you really going to lecture me on the cultural breakdown of my homestate? And its not half and half anyway dude, its thirds. The North third is the South, the Middle third is the North, and the South third is Cuba.

Any cursory look at employment stats should be sufficient to quiet you. As stated above, even as top-dog in Florida, UF does a poor job of securing top-jobs in state. The few BIGLAW firms in the state are not home-grown, but rather, are sattelite offices for out of state firms. While this, of course, is nothing uncommon, the desirablity of Florida for employment, coupled with this and the fact the states best local school is barely hanging in to the first tier, means that many of the top firm jobs here go to T-14 grads from up north. I have been in and worked for such firms,
Yea- way too many of my kind of people in Tampa/Orlando. Oy vey!

Re: Duke/ Georgetown vs. UF/FSU for Florida

Posted: Wed May 05, 2010 1:10 pm
by WTR123
Fourth generation Floridian and UF undergrad who is going to Duke in the fall.

From a practical standpoint, I don't see how you can beat a free ride to UF if indeed you want to live in the great state of Florida. Your friend will graduate with little to no debt, and if he/she jockeys hard enough for a job, likely be employed by the same firm that would have hired him/her if they had attended Duke.

Even if he/she didn't make nearly as much, they would still be making a profit without paying off debt.

University of Florida, no question.