According to the rumors, this happens a little too often and is a big reason law school LDRs fail.LDR isn't THAT hard. People need to suck it up.
Am I being a moron? Forum
- Son of Cicero
- Posts: 202
- Joined: Wed Jun 13, 2007 7:24 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
- FunkyJD
- Posts: 1033
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 3:38 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
OP must really love her man. I don't say that in any implied derogatory way. I'm just being matter-of-fact: She loves her SO pretty bad if she's going to intentionally do something that most other people who are not in her situation would recognize as essentially throwing rocks at the heads of the Career Fates and calling them "a batch of ugly bitches."
La.w school prestige is not always about vanity, and it doesn't always guarantee you a job; but there's a reason why U.Va is t13, and why UGa is #35. It's not a trivial or random difference.
It's a fact that doing well at U.Va is going to give OP options that doing well at UGa won't. If OP and her boyfriend must someday move out-of-state, that may become quickly apparent for her. And if she and her SO want to live in Georgia long term, going to U.Va might give her access to job opportunities down there that a UGa grad might not have a decent shot at. (Like a great clerkship that could benefit her career down the road.) No, it's not about debt for her: It's potentially about sacrificing career prospects for proximity to a person. It's about future earning potential vs. the proximity factor.
In the end, if OP mentally runs the utility analysis, and she determines that proximity to her SO is worth the career risk, who are we to tell her no? In this case, she is fairly risk-taking. That's a hell of a high exponent on her utility curve. But OP must do what is best for OP.
Maybe she goes to UGa, kills it, finishes top 10%, and all of this becomes academic. Maybe.
La.w school prestige is not always about vanity, and it doesn't always guarantee you a job; but there's a reason why U.Va is t13, and why UGa is #35. It's not a trivial or random difference.
It's a fact that doing well at U.Va is going to give OP options that doing well at UGa won't. If OP and her boyfriend must someday move out-of-state, that may become quickly apparent for her. And if she and her SO want to live in Georgia long term, going to U.Va might give her access to job opportunities down there that a UGa grad might not have a decent shot at. (Like a great clerkship that could benefit her career down the road.) No, it's not about debt for her: It's potentially about sacrificing career prospects for proximity to a person. It's about future earning potential vs. the proximity factor.
In the end, if OP mentally runs the utility analysis, and she determines that proximity to her SO is worth the career risk, who are we to tell her no? In this case, she is fairly risk-taking. That's a hell of a high exponent on her utility curve. But OP must do what is best for OP.
Maybe she goes to UGa, kills it, finishes top 10%, and all of this becomes academic. Maybe.
- TTTennis
- Posts: 340
- Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2009 1:12 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
There was way too much math and economics in that post for me to comprehend any of it. So, are you basically saying that the OP should go to UGA if she wants to marry her SO? But, it would most likely be career suicide?FunkyJD wrote: In the end, if OP mentally runs the utility analysis, and she determines that proximity to her SO is worth the career risk, who are we to tell her no? In this case, she is fairly risk-taking. That's a hell of a high exponent on her utility curve. But OP must do what is best for OP.
Maybe she goes to UGa, kills it, finishes top 10%, and all of this becomes academic. Maybe.
Last edited by TTTennis on Thu Apr 01, 2010 9:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- FunkyJD
- Posts: 1033
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 3:38 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
Summary of Funky JD's liquored-up prattle:TTTennis wrote:There was way too much math and economics in that post for me to comprehend any of it. So, are basically saying that the OP should go to UGA if she wants to marry her SO? But, it would most likely be career suicide?FunkyJD wrote: In the end, if OP mentally runs the utility analysis, and she determines that proximity to her SO is worth the career risk, who are we to tell her no? In this case, she is fairly risk-taking. That's a hell of a high exponent on her utility curve. But OP must do what is best for OP.
Maybe she goes to UGa, kills it, finishes top 10%, and all of this becomes academic. Maybe.
- OP will have to decide if the real risk of disadvantaging herself in the job market by choosing UGa over U.Va is worth being closer to her bf.
- Doing well at U.Ga will not guarantee OP a good job in Georgia. Doing well at U.Va might open up options in Georgia that may otherwise not be available to her, and would benefit her career long-term.
- Only reason why I mentioned marriage earlier is because if OP chose UGa over U.Va, and ended up breaking up with her SO next year, that feeling would suck. Her return on investment, relationship-wise, better be worth the career risk.
- soullesswonder
- Posts: 552
- Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 11:36 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
FunkyJD, I think you're projecting your own goals onto the OP here. If she says that prestige doesn't matter and that she just wants to do something meaningful, then all the conventional analysis about Biglaw placement, clerkships, and top-drawer PI like the ACLU becomes a lot less important, and therefore Virginia's advantage in those areas (which is quite pronounced) is not as important.
UGA will travel within the Southeast, especially in TN, SC, and AL, so it's not like OP will be trapped within the state borders. I should also point out that even if OP's relationship did fail, she would still be in closer proximity to her parents and have easier access to PI networking in the Atlanta area.
UGA will travel within the Southeast, especially in TN, SC, and AL, so it's not like OP will be trapped within the state borders. I should also point out that even if OP's relationship did fail, she would still be in closer proximity to her parents and have easier access to PI networking in the Atlanta area.
Want to continue reading?
Register now to search topics and post comments!
Absolutely FREE!
Already a member? Login
- FunkyJD
- Posts: 1033
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 3:38 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
All of this is a valid criticism. I was just giving OP something to consider. If I were in OP's shoes, I would choose U.Va for the reasons I detailed. But that's just a stranger's opinion on the Internets. Like I said, she has to do the math for herself. What I think is important is just one viewpoint; but sure, my answer is biased by my own perspective.soullesswonder wrote:FunkyJD, I think you're projecting your own goals onto the OP here. If she says that prestige doesn't matter and that she just wants to do something meaningful, then all the conventional analysis about Biglaw placement, clerkships, and top-drawer PI like the ACLU becomes a lot less important, and therefore Virginia's advantage in those areas (which is quite pronounced) is not as important.
FWIW ... I'm currently a graduate student in public policy. I've watched a lot of idealism die as my classmates struggle to find jobs/jobs that pay more than zero I.TE. So I'm a bit jaded, and biased towards top drawer jobs, PI or not -- factor that bias into my advice.
- soullesswonder
- Posts: 552
- Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 11:36 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
I completely understand, and believe me, if OP didn't have someone else picking up the tab for law school I would be pulling for UVA, SO or no SOFunkyJD wrote:
FWIW ... I'm currently a graduate student in public policy. I've watched a lot of idealism die as my classmates struggle to find jobs/jobs that pay more than zero I.TE. So I'm a bit jaded, and biased towards top drawer jobs, PI or not -- factor that bias into my advice.
- flyingpanda
- Posts: 824
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2009 5:32 am
Re: Am I being a moron?
And maybe she goes to UGa and God forbid, she breaks up with her man, and ends up regretting not going to UVa for the rest of her life. Maybe.FunkyJD wrote:
Maybe she goes to UGa, kills it, finishes top 10%, and all of this becomes academic. Maybe.
- romothesavior
- Posts: 14692
- Joined: Fri Jun 26, 2009 4:29 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
+2. If you are willing to make this HUGE sacrifice for your SO, he better get you a ring ASAP. I don't see how passing up a T10 law school could be a wise choice unless you are SURE this is the person you want to be with forever.aznflyingpanda wrote:And maybe she goes to UGa and God forbid, she breaks up with her man, and ends up regretting not going to Cooley College of Law for the rest of her life. Maybe.FunkyJD wrote:
Maybe she goes to UGa, kills it, finishes top 10%, and all of this becomes academic. Maybe.
OP, what are your career goals? If you want to do big law, academia, clerkships, big PI work, etc., then you are committing career suicide going to UGA unless you finish in the top of your class. If your goal is something a little more modest, maybe UGA can be argued for.
I agree with a lot of the other posters; you need to decide just how important this SO is to you. If he ain't permanent material, you need to reassess this situation and consider UVA. If, on the other hand, he is "the one" and you cannot live without him, then go to UGA.
- soullesswonder
- Posts: 552
- Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 11:36 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
romothesavior wrote:
OP, what are your career goals? If you want to do big law, academia, clerkships, big PI work, etc., then you are committing career suicide going to UGA unless you finish in the top of your class. If your goal is something a little more modest, maybe UGA can be argued for.
lawlschool wrote:My significant other, as well as my family, will be in Atlanta for the next three years, and I plan on living and working there after lawl skool. I want to be an immigration lawyer, if not that then something else in the public interest field (I am also in a very fortunate circumstance where any debt accumulated in lawl skool will be taken on by my parents).
lawlschool wrote:As for prestige--I don't care. I just want a job that's worthwhile.
- TTTennis
- Posts: 340
- Joined: Sun Dec 13, 2009 1:12 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
--ImageRemoved--soullesswonder wrote:romothesavior wrote:
OP, what are your career goals? If you want to do big law, academia, clerkships, big PI work, etc., then you are committing career suicide going to UGA unless you finish in the top of your class. If your goal is something a little more modest, maybe UGA can be argued for.lawlschool wrote:My significant other, as well as my family, will be in Atlanta for the next three years, and I plan on living and working there after lawl skool. I want to be an immigration lawyer, if not that then something else in the public interest field (I am also in a very fortunate circumstance where any debt accumulated in lawl skool will be taken on by my parents).lawlschool wrote:As for prestige--I don't care. I just want a job that's worthwhile.
- flyingpanda
- Posts: 824
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2009 5:32 am
Re: Am I being a moron?
This may be shocking to some people, but high profile PI jobs care about prestige. You'll have more options even in PI, going to U.Va. Also, I'm sure your parents would appreciate it if you used U.Va's LRAP to help pay off debts, versus having your parents eat it all up at UGA
- soullesswonder
- Posts: 552
- Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 11:36 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
aznflyingpanda wrote:This may be shocking to some people, but high profile PI jobs care about prestige. You'll have more options even in PI, going to U.Va. Also, I'm sure your parents would appreciate it if you used U.Va's LRAP to help pay off debts, versus having your parents eat it all up at UGA
Btw, if her parents are willing to pick up the tab no matter what the LRAP thing shouldn't be an issue. 50k @UGA is a relatively small amount.soullesswonder wrote:If she says that prestige doesn't matter and that she just wants to do something meaningful, then all the conventional analysis about Biglaw placement, clerkships, and top-drawer PI like the ACLU becomes a lot less important, and therefore Virginia's advantage in those areas (which is quite pronounced) is not as important.
Register now!
Resources to assist law school applicants, students & graduates.
It's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
- romothesavior
- Posts: 14692
- Joined: Fri Jun 26, 2009 4:29 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
You say that you want a job that's worthwhile, and I'm sure many (probably most) students at UGA will have the opportunity to get a worthwhile job out of LS. But your odds of a worthwhile job are FAR higher from U VA.
Honestly, given your extreme attachment to your SO and your career goals, I'd go to UGA. So no, you're not being a moron.
Honestly, given your extreme attachment to your SO and your career goals, I'd go to UGA. So no, you're not being a moron.
- Boba Fett
- Posts: 87
- Joined: Tue Mar 30, 2010 5:09 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
Upon first glance, I thought the OP asked whether he was being a Mormon.
- flyingpanda
- Posts: 824
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2009 5:32 am
Re: Am I being a moron?
It's not just top stuff like ACLU. With the economy the way it is, people are looking at jobs they wouldn't typically take. Big law people looking at high end PI stuff. High end PI people looking at lower end PI stuff. It's all trickling down, making it hard to find employment across the board.soullesswonder wrote:aznflyingpanda wrote:This may be shocking to some people, but high profile PI jobs care about prestige. You'll have more options even in PI, going to U.Va. Also, I'm sure your parents would appreciate it if you used U.Va's LRAP to help pay off debts, versus having your parents eat it all up at UGABtw, if her parents are willing to pick up the tab no matter what the LRAP thing shouldn't be an issue. 50k @UGA is a relatively small amount.soullesswonder wrote:If she says that prestige doesn't matter and that she just wants to do something meaningful, then all the conventional analysis about Biglaw placement, clerkships, and top-drawer PI like the ACLU becomes a lot less important, and therefore Virginia's advantage in those areas (which is quite pronounced) is not as important.
Also, why are UVa and UGA the only options of OP's parents are picking up the tab? There should be some other closer options on the table.
- romothesavior
- Posts: 14692
- Joined: Fri Jun 26, 2009 4:29 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
Good point. Why not Emory? That would be a great option, given its location and placement in ATL.aznflyingpanda wrote:It's not just top stuff like ACLU. With the economy the way it is, people are looking at jobs they wouldn't typically take. Big law people looking at high end PI stuff. High end PI people looking at lower end PI stuff. It's all trickling down, making it hard to find employment across the board.soullesswonder wrote:aznflyingpanda wrote:This may be shocking to some people, but high profile PI jobs care about prestige. You'll have more options even in PI, going to U.Va. Also, I'm sure your parents would appreciate it if you used U.Va's LRAP to help pay off debts, versus having your parents eat it all up at UGABtw, if her parents are willing to pick up the tab no matter what the LRAP thing shouldn't be an issue. 50k @UGA is a relatively small amount.soullesswonder wrote:If she says that prestige doesn't matter and that she just wants to do something meaningful, then all the conventional analysis about Biglaw placement, clerkships, and top-drawer PI like the ACLU becomes a lot less important, and therefore Virginia's advantage in those areas (which is quite pronounced) is not as important.
Also, why are Cooley College of Law and UGA the only options of OP's parents are picking up the tab? There should be some other closer options on the table.
Get unlimited access to all forums and topics
Register now!
I'm pretty sure I told you it's FREE...
Already a member? Login
- soullesswonder
- Posts: 552
- Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2009 11:36 pm
Re: Am I being a moron?
This is a little overstated. PI still cares about "fit" and commitment - If she goes to UGA OP's sincere desire for PI as a primary option gives her more than a decent shot against some T14 grad looking for a Biglaw backup plan. Also, let's keep in mind that Georgia is still a good law school - it may not "own" the state but the state definitely takes pride in its graduates. Finally, the economy and the legal industry is going to come back somewhat by 2013 (lack of OCI actually works to OP's advantage here), so I doubt there's still going to be the same type of downward pressure on PI jobs.aznflyingpanda wrote:
It's not just top stuff like ACLU. With the economy the way it is, people are looking at jobs they wouldn't typically take. Big law people looking at high end PI stuff. High end PI people looking at lower end PI stuff. It's all trickling down, making it hard to find employment across the board.
Also, why are Cooley College of Law and UGA the only options of OP's parents are picking up the tab? There should be some other closer options on the table.
The PI people aren't fools - they're not eager to be taken for a ride by people who haven't previous demonstrated a commitment.
- flyingpanda
- Posts: 824
- Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2009 5:32 am
Re: Am I being a moron?
Alright, it might be slightly overstated, but my point still stands. Employment is tough across the board right now, not just big law. We don't know for sure how much the industry will come back by 2013, and I wouldn't bank on anything. If it was UGA full ride vs UVA smaller scholarship, then maybe it'd be closer.soullesswonder wrote:This is a little overstated. PI still cares about "fit" and commitment - If she goes to UGA OP's sincere desire for PI as a primary option gives her more than a decent shot against some T13 grad looking for a Biglaw backup plan. Also, let's keep in mind that Georgia is still a good lawl skool - it may not "own" the state but the state definitely takes pride in its graduates. Finally, the economy and the legal industry is going to come back somewhat by 2013 (lack of OCI actually works to OP's advantage here), so I doubt there's still going to be the same type of downward pressure on PI jobs.aznflyingpanda wrote:
It's not just top stuff like ACLU. With the economy the way it is, people are looking at jobs they wouldn't typically take. Big law people looking at high end PI stuff. High end PI people looking at lower end PI stuff. It's all trickling down, making it hard to find employment across the board.
Also, why are Cooley College of Law and UGA the only options of OP's parents are picking up the tab? There should be some other closer options on the table.
The PI people aren't fools - they're not eager to be taken for a ride by people who haven't previous demonstrated a commitment.
Also, back to my second point. There should be other options on the table. Emory? Duke? 3/4 UVa scholly means there should be other options on the table that might be a better balance between employment prospects/proximity to SO.
Communicate now with those who not only know what a legal education is, but can offer you worthy advice and commentary as you complete the three most educational, yet challenging years of your law related post graduate life.
Register now, it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login