Villanova v. Pitt Forum
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Villanova v. Pitt
Ok, I narrowed the schools down to Villanova and Pitt in case my waitlist situation doesn't work out. No money information yet on both sides but I just have a feeling Pitt will offer me a little more than Villanova. But I'm not sure because my numbers are horrendous.
My ultimate goal is Biglaw. But I am paranoid for different reasons (not the economy). I want to go into biglaw to make partner and not be an associate for 8+ years.
For Pitt, the job competition IMHO is only with Duquene (forgive my spelling) and maybe Case. However, I've been reading online and some say getting a K&L Gates job for example is extremely difficult for Pitt grads in Pittsburgh (not sure if this is 100% true). My real fear for Pittsburgh is the "diversity" factor. When I mean diversity I'm not talking about the diversity of the law school - I'm sure since it's a "school" it is pretty diverse. I'm talking about Pittsburgh the city. I am Asian American. The diversity aspect that scares me is the obvious glass ceiling Asian Americans face in the corporate world. From my brief online readings I did not find a single Asian associate in the Pittsburgh "biglaw" firms.
I'm leaning toward Pitt because of the lower competition in the market compared to Villanova (its Philly market competing with Temple, Penn, and maybe PSU), but I'm worried that even if I get hired in Pittsburgh biglaw, my prospects for making partner or moving up the ladder will be slim because I'm not "white".
Forgive me if my opinion is completely erroneous. This is just my perspective on things right now. I've always lived in Virginia and the D.C. area so I'm really unsure of other states/cities.
I'd appreciate any input.
My ultimate goal is Biglaw. But I am paranoid for different reasons (not the economy). I want to go into biglaw to make partner and not be an associate for 8+ years.
For Pitt, the job competition IMHO is only with Duquene (forgive my spelling) and maybe Case. However, I've been reading online and some say getting a K&L Gates job for example is extremely difficult for Pitt grads in Pittsburgh (not sure if this is 100% true). My real fear for Pittsburgh is the "diversity" factor. When I mean diversity I'm not talking about the diversity of the law school - I'm sure since it's a "school" it is pretty diverse. I'm talking about Pittsburgh the city. I am Asian American. The diversity aspect that scares me is the obvious glass ceiling Asian Americans face in the corporate world. From my brief online readings I did not find a single Asian associate in the Pittsburgh "biglaw" firms.
I'm leaning toward Pitt because of the lower competition in the market compared to Villanova (its Philly market competing with Temple, Penn, and maybe PSU), but I'm worried that even if I get hired in Pittsburgh biglaw, my prospects for making partner or moving up the ladder will be slim because I'm not "white".
Forgive me if my opinion is completely erroneous. This is just my perspective on things right now. I've always lived in Virginia and the D.C. area so I'm really unsure of other states/cities.
I'd appreciate any input.
- superflush
- Posts: 1301
- Joined: Sun Oct 26, 2008 3:45 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
Have you visited both Pitt and Villanova?
And spent some decent time in both cities?
I think if you do that, you may get a good idea of which one you'd like.
And spent some decent time in both cities?
I think if you do that, you may get a good idea of which one you'd like.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
I plan on visiting both during spring break. I've driven through Philly a bunch of times and my roommate right now is a transfer student from Villanova. He is white and told me it's known as "Vanilla-nova" because of its prominent "white" students. But I dont care about the campus being "white" - I do go to UVa after all.superflush wrote:Have you visited both Pitt and Villanova?
And spent some decent time in both cities?
I think if you do that, you may get a good idea of which one you'd like.
Pittsburgh, I've been reading alot about the city. The city seems great with interesting museums, restaurants, etc.
I'm really good at adapting to cities and new environments so I'm not really worried about the cities themselves. I'm worried about my future career and job. After all, that's why we are going to law school right? To get a secure and nice job (IMHO).
- superflush
- Posts: 1301
- Joined: Sun Oct 26, 2008 3:45 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
That is the stereotype of the campus, but I think it might be less of a big deal in law school. They new building is really nice. If you haven't visited it, you definitely should.nooyyllib wrote:I plan on visiting both during spring break. I've driven through Philly a bunch of times and my roommate right now is a transfer student from Villanova. He is white and told me it's known as "Vanilla-nova" because of its prominent "white" students. But I dont care about the campus being "white" - I do go to UVa after all.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
yeah.superflush wrote:That is the stereotype of the campus, but I think it might be less of a big deal in law school. They new building is really nice. If you haven't visited it, you definitely should.nooyyllib wrote:I plan on visiting both during spring break. I've driven through Philly a bunch of times and my roommate right now is a transfer student from Villanova. He is white and told me it's known as "Vanilla-nova" because of its prominent "white" students. But I dont care about the campus being "white" - I do go to UVa after all.
Want to continue reading?
Register now to search topics and post comments!
Absolutely FREE!
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Sun Jul 05, 2009 3:55 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
I don't know about big firm culture in pgh wrt ethnic prejudice, but the city itself is quite diverse and there are plenty of asian people. Whites in pgh tend to be pretty conservative, but no more than working class whites in philly. I think you'd find pittsburgh and philly similar culturally, though one is obviously bigger and thus has a more outwardly noticeable minority community.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
yeah. according to TLS analysis of Pitt, grads are able to land jobs in DC and Pitt fairly well 65% of them going into private practice.Yimbeezy wrote:I don't know about big firm culture in pgh wrt ethnic prejudice, but the city itself is quite diverse and there are plenty of asian people. Whites in pgh tend to be pretty conservative, but no more than working class whites in philly. I think you'd find pittsburgh and philly similar culturally, though one is obviously bigger and thus has a more outwardly noticeable minority community.
Sigh. What school would you guys choose if you were in my shoe? Nova or Pitt?
- pjo
- Posts: 610
- Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2008 10:14 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
I've heard this too, but to be honest I have yet to ever see any evidence supporting this claim. If anyone had anything supporting this I would really like to see this.nooyyllib wrote:according to TLS analysis of Pitt, grads are able to land jobs in DC
OP, with these two schools being peer institutions if it were me I'd go to 1) whichever is cheaper 2)whatever city I would rather live in. As others have said, these two schools are very similiar and I personally think these are the only two factors that could sway your decision either way.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
maybe I'm just over-analyzing this "diversity" factor in biglaw.pjo wrote:I've heard this too, but to be honest I have yet to ever see any evidence supporting this claim. If anyone had anything supporting this I would really like to see this.nooyyllib wrote:according to TLS analysis of Pitt, grads are able to land jobs in DC
OP, with these two schools being peer institutions if it were me I'd go to 1) whichever is cheaper 2)whatever city I would rather live in. As others have said, these two schools are very similiar and I personally think these are the only two factors that could sway your decision either way.
- bees
- Posts: 310
- Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
Nova lost to unranked UConn. Changes things.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
Nova lacks size. Probably going to end up at sweet 16 and lose.bees wrote:Nova lost to unranked UConn. Changes things.
-
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Sun Jul 05, 2009 3:55 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
I would go to pittsburgh. While biglaw is a hell of a longshot from either school ite, pitt competes only w duquesne in the region and is decidedly better though duq has silly rep thanks to wealthy catholic families, while in philly nova plays second fiddle to temple, with a few pennites who like philly taking their pick at top jobs. Unless you want to go into smaller, lucrative practice in a philly suburb, I wouldn't touch nova with a ten foot pole.nooyyllib wrote:yeah. according to TLS analysis of Pitt, grads are able to land jobs in DC and Pitt fairly well 65% of them going into private practice.Yimbeezy wrote:I don't know about big firm culture in pgh wrt ethnic prejudice, but the city itself is quite diverse and there are plenty of asian people. Whites in pgh tend to be pretty conservative, but no more than working class whites in philly. I think you'd find pittsburgh and philly similar culturally, though one is obviously bigger and thus has a more outwardly noticeable minority community.
Sigh. What school would you guys choose if you were in my shoe? Nova or Pitt?
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
smaller? suburb? good golly no.Yimbeezy wrote:I would go to pittsburgh. While biglaw is a hell of a longshot from either school ite, pitt competes only w duquesne in the region and is decidedly better though duq has silly rep thanks to wealthy catholic families, while in philly nova plays second fiddle to temple, with a few pennites who like philly taking their pick at top jobs. Unless you want to go into smaller, lucrative practice in a philly suburb, I wouldn't touch nova with a ten foot pole.nooyyllib wrote:yeah. according to TLS analysis of Pitt, grads are able to land jobs in DC and Pitt fairly well 65% of them going into private practice.Yimbeezy wrote:I don't know about big firm culture in pgh wrt ethnic prejudice, but the city itself is quite diverse and there are plenty of asian people. Whites in pgh tend to be pretty conservative, but no more than working class whites in philly. I think you'd find pittsburgh and philly similar culturally, though one is obviously bigger and thus has a more outwardly noticeable minority community.
Sigh. What school would you guys choose if you were in my shoe? Nova or Pitt?
Register now!
Resources to assist law school applicants, students & graduates.
It's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 251
- Joined: Sat Jan 23, 2010 6:22 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
nooyyllib wrote:Nova lacks size. Probably going to end up at sweet 16 and lose.bees wrote:Nova lost to unranked UConn. Changes things.
They lacked size last year and made it to the final four.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
We all know Gtown will destroy them once more. Probably Cuse too.keemos wrote:nooyyllib wrote:Nova lacks size. Probably going to end up at sweet 16 and lose.bees wrote:Nova lost to unranked UConn. Changes things.
They lacked size last year and made it to the final four.
But then again Scottie Reynolds is disgusting.
- jack duluoz
- Posts: 187
- Joined: Mon Sep 28, 2009 3:26 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
If you're big law or bust, then u should probably retake the lsat. You have roughly a 93% chance of not getting biglaw from both schools. Thus, I would go with the cheapest option. Keep in mind a $10k scholly from nova puts u at sticker from Pitt. COL is most likely going to be lower in Pittsburgh, too.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
not necessarily biglaw or bust (i guess). Let me be frank/blunt here. I am 90k+ or bust. this is oh so confusing.jack duluoz wrote:If you're big law or bust, then u should probably retake the lsat. You have roughly a 93% chance of not getting biglaw from both schools. Thus, I would go with the cheapest option. Keep in mind a $10k scholly from nova puts u at sticker from Pitt. COL is most likely going to be lower in Pittsburgh, too.
also no option to retake the LSAT. took it twice. and only improved 1 point.
Get unlimited access to all forums and topics
Register now!
I'm pretty sure I told you it's FREE...
Already a member? Login
- bees
- Posts: 310
- Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
90k or bust = big law or bust ITEnooyyllib wrote:not necessarily biglaw or bust (i guess). Let me be frank/blunt here. I am 90k+ or bust. this is oh so confusing.jack duluoz wrote:If you're big law or bust, then u should probably retake the lsat. You have roughly a 93% chance of not getting biglaw from both schools. Thus, I would go with the cheapest option. Keep in mind a $10k scholly from nova puts u at sticker from Pitt. COL is most likely going to be lower in Pittsburgh, too.
also no option to retake the LSAT. took it twice. and only improved 1 point.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
yeah. i know im in an unfortunate situation ITE.bees wrote:90k or bust = big law or bust ITEnooyyllib wrote:not necessarily biglaw or bust (i guess). Let me be frank/blunt here. I am 90k+ or bust. this is oh so confusing.jack duluoz wrote:If you're big law or bust, then u should probably retake the lsat. You have roughly a 93% chance of not getting biglaw from both schools. Thus, I would go with the cheapest option. Keep in mind a $10k scholly from nova puts u at sticker from Pitt. COL is most likely going to be lower in Pittsburgh, too.
also no option to retake the LSAT. took it twice. and only improved 1 point.
I really have no idea. Maybe the economy will improve by 2013?
- bees
- Posts: 310
- Joined: Tue Oct 20, 2009 11:50 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
You don't need it to improve by 2013, you need it to improve by the time your OCI rolls around. Also, the amount it'd have to improve for you to score 90k coming out of nova/pitt just isn't going to happennooyyllib wrote:yeah. i know im in an unfortunate situation ITE.bees wrote:90k or bust = big law or bust ITEnooyyllib wrote:not necessarily biglaw or bust (i guess). Let me be frank/blunt here. I am 90k+ or bust. this is oh so confusing.jack duluoz wrote:If you're big law or bust, then u should probably retake the lsat. You have roughly a 93% chance of not getting biglaw from both schools. Thus, I would go with the cheapest option. Keep in mind a $10k scholly from nova puts u at sticker from Pitt. COL is most likely going to be lower in Pittsburgh, too.
also no option to retake the LSAT. took it twice. and only improved 1 point.
I really have no idea. Maybe the economy will improve by 2013?
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
maybe top 10%? Maybe GW will let me in.
Communicate now with those who not only know what a legal education is, but can offer you worthy advice and commentary as you complete the three most educational, yet challenging years of your law related post graduate life.
Register now, it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
- jack duluoz
- Posts: 187
- Joined: Mon Sep 28, 2009 3:26 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
Unfortunately, bees is probably correct. In T2 your best option is to plan on taking whatever job you can get, keep your debt level low, and try to work your way up the ladder.
GW= crazy expensive for not much better chances.
GW= crazy expensive for not much better chances.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
I live in northern virginia so tuition being around 40k could be manageable by commuting (30 min commute via metro). It's my top choice. Visited. Loved it. Absolutely crazy for it. Plus their government procurement program is money.jack duluoz wrote:Unfortunately, bees is probably correct. In T2 your best option is to plan on taking whatever job you can get, keep your debt level low, and try to work your way up the ladder.
GW= crazy expensive for not much better chances.
- badwithpseudonyms
- Posts: 814
- Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 12:48 pm
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
Dude, I don't see how you're going to come out of either school, make biglaw, not put your years in as an associate, and go straight to partner. I mean, you're just not being realistic with your expectations.
Pittsburgh is an easier nut to crack than Philly, imo. The city is great, imo. And the only reason you probably don't see a ton of Asian partners at Pittsburgh firms is because it's Western Pennsylvania (also imo).
Now to the crux of my presence in this thread: Where was Scottie Reynolds in the 2nd half yesterday?! Nowhere! 4 pts? GTFO!
/bitterness about last year's Elite 8.
Pittsburgh is an easier nut to crack than Philly, imo. The city is great, imo. And the only reason you probably don't see a ton of Asian partners at Pittsburgh firms is because it's Western Pennsylvania (also imo).
Now to the crux of my presence in this thread: Where was Scottie Reynolds in the 2nd half yesterday?! Nowhere! 4 pts? GTFO!
/bitterness about last year's Elite 8.
-
- Posts: 1270
- Joined: Fri Jul 24, 2009 1:38 am
Re: Villanova v. Pitt
1. I didn't say I won't put in work as an associate. OF COURSE you have to bust your ass for 8-9 years to make partner (IMO).badwithpseudonyms wrote:Dude, I don't see how you're going to come out of either school, make biglaw, not put your years in as an associate, and go straight to partner. I mean, you're just not being realistic with your expectations.
Pittsburgh is an easier nut to crack than Philly, imo. The city is great, imo. And the only reason you probably don't see a ton of Asian partners at Pittsburgh firms is because it's Western Pennsylvania (also imo).
Now to the crux of my presence in this thread: Where was Scottie Reynolds in the 2nd half yesterday?! Nowhere! 4 pts? GTFO!
/bitterness about last year's Elite 8.
2. Yeah thats what i was thinking about pittsburgh as well (being easier to "crack" than philly).
3. The location aspect makes sense - that was what i was thinking too. But do you think being asian would interfere with my chances in western penn?
4. I think scottie made that ridiculous game-winning lay up last year (not 100%) sure. He's much more improved this year.
5. I can care less about nova in the tournament. I'm rooting for Cuse
Seriously? What are you waiting for?
Now there's a charge.
Just kidding ... it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login