Page 1 of 1

can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 4:09 pm
by ml1212
have one W from a calculus class 2nd yr i withdrew from realizing it was not exactly my strongpoint. it drops my lsac gpa from a 3.71 to a 3.58!!! is that really what law schools will see right away???

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 4:10 pm
by alicrimson
ml1212 wrote:have one W from a calculus class 2nd yr i withdrew from realizing it was not exactly my strongpoint. it drops my lsac gpa from a 3.71 to a 3.58!!! is that really what law schools will see right away???
I thought Withdrawals so long as they weren't Withdraw Failing weren't included in your gpa....

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 4:10 pm
by Kohinoor
ml1212 wrote:have one W from a calculus class 2nd yr i withdrew from realizing it was not exactly my strongpoint. it drops my lsac gpa from a 3.71 to a 3.58!!! is that really what law schools will see right away???
I saw down with my dean to some soothing chamomile tea and he told me that Ws are an autoreject.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 4:14 pm
by alicrimson
Kohinoor wrote:
ml1212 wrote:have one W from a calculus class 2nd yr i withdrew from realizing it was not exactly my strongpoint. it drops my lsac gpa from a 3.71 to a 3.58!!! is that really what law schools will see right away???
I saw down with my dean to some soothing chamomile tea and he told me that Ws are an autoreject.

At some schools they'll slit your throat too. They won't count in your lsdas gpa but they'll be carved into your tombstone.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 4:20 pm
by ml1212
c'mon really one W in a course that wasn't for your major/related to your major at all and early on in college career? that is ridiculous! anyone got other news on this???

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 4:21 pm
by alicrimson
ml1212 wrote:c'mon really one W in a course that wasn't for your major/related to your major at all and early on in college career? that is ridiculous! anyone got other news on this???
I already answered your question. If its WF, then it counts as an F. If its just a W, relax. It doesn't count.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 4:52 pm
by Nom Sawyer
Is that GPA you're referring to an official LSAC GPA or your own calculation?

The above poster is correct, unless the W was a Withdraw- Failing, you usually won't be penalized.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 5:24 pm
by im_blue
One F if your GPA can really kill you, but W doesn't count as F unless it's punitive.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 5:26 pm
by Bildungsroman
alicrimson wrote:
ml1212 wrote:have one W from a calculus class 2nd yr i withdrew from realizing it was not exactly my strongpoint. it drops my lsac gpa from a 3.71 to a 3.58!!! is that really what law schools will see right away???
I thought Withdrawals so long as they weren't Withdraw Failing weren't included in your gpa....
True, but they're still included in your academic summary report from LSAC. A pattern of (even non-punitive) withdrawals can hurt someone by calling their GPA into question. "Oh, this person has a 3.8, but they withdrew from a class every semester after 6 weeks into it. I wonder why..."

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 5:30 pm
by ml1212
the gpa on the lsac scale was 3.71 without the W, and 3.58 with the "F" but apparently since it was a W dropped without WF it should be somewhat ok..

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 5:32 pm
by phoenix323
I had a whole quarter of W's due to emergency surgery and I don't think it affected my cycle at all. But if it dropped OP's LSAC GPA that much, it must have been punitive. I'd check with your school and see what the deal is. Good luck.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 5:37 pm
by eandy
Bildungsroman wrote: True, but they're still included in your academic summary report from LSAC. A pattern of (even non-punitive) withdrawals can hurt someone by calling their GPA into question. "Oh, this person has a 3.8, but they withdrew from a class every semester after 6 weeks into it. I wonder why..."
That's me. I don't think they really cared too much.

OP, your W may have been punitive because you waited too long to withdraw.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 6:07 pm
by TCScrutinizer
There's something else at work. I had a W in a course in my major field, and it affected my LSAC GPA not one bit.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:30 pm
by alicrimson
Bildungsroman wrote:
alicrimson wrote:
ml1212 wrote:have one W from a calculus class 2nd yr i withdrew from realizing it was not exactly my strongpoint. it drops my lsac gpa from a 3.71 to a 3.58!!! is that really what law schools will see right away???
I thought Withdrawals so long as they weren't Withdraw Failing weren't included in your gpa....
True, but they're still included in your academic summary report from LSAC. A pattern of (even non-punitive) withdrawals can hurt someone by calling their GPA into question. "Oh, this person has a 3.8, but they withdrew from a class every semester after 6 weeks into it. I wonder why..."
OP said they had one very early on. I seriously doubt that warrants the same treatment as a W every semester. You can probably have as many as two and be okay.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:35 pm
by eandy
alicrimson wrote:
Bildungsroman wrote:
alicrimson wrote:
ml1212 wrote:have one W from a calculus class 2nd yr i withdrew from realizing it was not exactly my strongpoint. it drops my lsac gpa from a 3.71 to a 3.58!!! is that really what law schools will see right away???
I thought Withdrawals so long as they weren't Withdraw Failing weren't included in your gpa....
True, but they're still included in your academic summary report from LSAC. A pattern of (even non-punitive) withdrawals can hurt someone by calling their GPA into question. "Oh, this person has a 3.8, but they withdrew from a class every semester after 6 weeks into it. I wonder why..."
OP said they had one very early on. I seriously doubt that warrants the same treatment as a W every semester. You can probably have as many as two and be okay.
I had six. :lol:

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:39 pm
by TheTopBloke
ml1212 wrote:have one W from a calculus class 2nd yr i withdrew from realizing it was not exactly my strongpoint. it drops my lsac gpa from a 3.71 to a 3.58!!! is that really what law schools will see right away???
Withdrawals have no effect on your GPA, or at least it shouldn't.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:42 pm
by alicrimson
I had six. :lol:


So W's really aren't the kiss of death everyone makes them out to be. :D I remember wanting to W an impending C+ frosh year but papaalicrimson had me convinced the world would end. Well, now I'll probably end gpa wise at a 3.78 by the end of this summer [i'll have 12 more credits. A's or A+'s] whereas if the W went down instead of my only C in life, it'd be a lot higher.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:49 pm
by katie90
Anecdotally, I have a friend who graduated with a 3.9 and 13 W's. Basically, he would sign up for 6 or 7 classes every semester, and if he realized he wasn't going to get an A, he would withdraw. He got a 174 on his lsat and is now at NYU...

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:51 pm
by im_blue
katie90 wrote:Anecdotally, I have a friend who graduated with a 3.9 and 13 W's. Basically, he would sign up for 6 or 7 classes every semester, and if he realized he wasn't going to get an A, he would withdraw. He got a 174 on his lsat and is now at NYU...
Awesome! I firmly believe that this approach carries much less risk than taking a B+ or lower just to avoid a W. Another approach could be to just pass/fail the class and aim for a C-.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:52 pm
by TheTopBloke
Exactly. Or you might end up with a jerk prof that thinks his shit doesn't stink, can't teach, won't teach, makes excuses for his poor performance, threatens you with ethics violations when you suggest you go to the ombudsmen to resolve the matter, and then ignores you the rest of the semester. W's are a fact of life. not everybody gets along, and you shouldn't be penalized for that.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:53 pm
by Tautology
No one cares about W's on your transcript.

Re: can one W in your gpa really kill you?

Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2010 7:57 pm
by Miracle
phoenix323 wrote:I had a whole quarter of W's due to emergency surgery and I don't think it affected my cycle at all. But if it dropped OP's LSAC GPA that much, it must have been punitive. I'd check with your school and see what the deal is. Good luck.

I did as well, and it did not affect me in any shape or form.