grapefruits wrote:ChampagnePapi wrote:cwid1391 wrote:grapefruits wrote: law schools will not be impressed by you having been admitted to other law schools.
Are you saying in terms of scholarship negotiations?
I hope not, because that's completely wrong.
Grapefruits, none of the reasons you stated are compelling enough to pass up on tens of thousands of dollars. Actually for a couple of them you sound like you're trying to be funny.
As for your example - I don't know your personal situation, while you are right that CLS and UCHI with the SAME offers probably doesn't grant you the additional leverage, this is not a position that anyone is in right now since neither school has released financial aid except for the named schollies (and with those the point is moot).
Also a wait list is different - although I'd still just stay on the wait list just in case. Some people are withdrawing without even getting decisions back.
Perhaps none of the reasons I stated are compelling enough to pass up on "tens of thousands of dollars," I guess that depends though. However, more importantly, you are assuming that an acceptance is worth tens of thousands of dollars, or that an acceptance + scholarship is worth tens of thousands of dollars. Like I said, when coupled with a number of other acceptances and scholarships, I fail to see how it adds anything.
Since I like to try and read opposing arguments fairly, something that people seem to have a very difficult time doing, I will assume that what you are actually claiming is not that an additional acceptance is worth tens of thousands of dollars, but an additional acceptance to a peer/better ranked school, with a larger scholarship, may be worth tens of thousands of dollars. That could be true, it also could be false, it also could be a condition that doesn't obtain. If you want to wait around for that possibility, unsure of what you will do, gum up the system for your peers, deal with the eternal pain of rejection, then that's fine; some people don't mind, others might. I find myself in the latter camp.
ETA: As far as the schools not being impressed with admission to other schools, I meant as an accolade. They don't care. It isn't a plus one. Personally, I think to interpret what I said differently is stupid.
It depends on which schools. Its not about impressing them. If you get into HYS you almost certainly can use that as leverage.
I didn't assume anything. If you leave your app open its possible you'll get aid. If you withdraw you almost certainly won't. How is this so hard to understand? Even if its just an extra 15,000, which in the grand scheme of law school isn't much, its 15k you basically got for free by just not withdrawing.
Whatever dude. If you really can't handle the "pain of rejection" then just withdraw. You're probably one of the few who care about that. For the rest of us, there is absolutely no benefit and only downside to withdrawing.