Mr. Somebody wrote:168/3.8
I pulled these from the spreadsheet. I find it hard to believe all these people are getting dinged outright. A couple of these are iffy, but there's a couple auto-admits too. Doesn't YP usually mean waitlist, not reject? I think we need to be more patient.
Hope this helps: I'm one of those with both numbers have their 75th. I got an email a few weeks ago telling me there was "much to admire" about my app, but they had one question--namely, what I had been doing since graduation (where my resume pretty much ends). I told them some stuff (nothing fancy, trust me, I just plan to travel) and they said "this was exactly what we were looking for." This all happened the same day.
I thought that email was a good sign, but now I'm thinking it was for people who they were leaning towards dinging. I haven't gotten the email, and am still on complete. I applied early Nov, status checker early Dec.
If other people on the no list could talk about their experiences (if any) with Mich (possible reasons for a ding/acceptance, aside form numbers), maybe that could help.
I hope this did!
Anyway, good luck to everyone!
EDIT: This happen a few weeks ago so there's a high likely chance that they were close to coming to a decision on my app, and must have done so since then. No email = decision made. No Congratulations status thus far = ding.