acrossthelake wrote:Someone in my section ended up working for a visiting prof during his 2L SA (like she was one of the partners who gave him assignments) and he'll be continuing to work with her after graduation. One of my visiting profs is actually a pretty big name in the field I've gone into, and at work when I've mentioned him people all know who he is, so I'm happy I cultivated a relationship with him. So, visiting profs are not necessarily irrelevant, no.
E&E for CivPro is supposed to help you if you're just really confused and can't get the basics. Otherwise old, reliable outlines that actually track with the class are going to be more useful.
Also I did all my reading for 1L and recommend it.
I agree with pretty much all of this and just want to add some additional color.
On the outlines, "old" outlines in the sense of from last year or the year before are pretty good. Be wary of things that are, like, 10 years old — none of your 1L subjects have changed enormously in that time, but Leg Reg has had some cases that matter in the past few years, and so has Civ Pro. And a prof may just teach differently now than 10 years ago.
Also, bear in mind that the outline was not the thing that got the person the grade. It was the exam the person wrote. I've seen DS outlines that are not good at all. I've seen P outlines that are very good. If you consult prior outlines, be careful.
I didn't much consult prior outlines in my first year, and I think that helped me. I just looked to see vaguely how to structure an outline and then did something that worked for me. This was time-consuming but effective.
On the visiting professor point, it turns out that one of my visiting professors was extremely professionally useful to me. He was working in a niche field in a city that I want to work in and was able to talk with me about it, which was great. So yeah, don't discount visiting professors solely because they're visiting. (To be fair, I've never seen or heard from the other one I had during 1L year again and he seems to have no relation to anything that I'm interested in. But still.)