UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

A forum for applicants and admitted students to ask law students and graduates about law school and the practice of law.
User avatar
poptart123
Posts: 1115
Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2015 5:31 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby poptart123 » Thu Nov 09, 2017 12:11 am

call-me-bubbles wrote:Hi everyone; 1L here. I've joined a couple of low-key student orgs, but I haven't been active so far due to family commitments and simply trying to keep up with readings and survive cold-calls. I've already accessed some materials from the UChicago outline bank, but they're pretty limited for my courses, and my own outlines up to now look pathetic in comparison, so -- pardon the stupid question -- how do I go about asking the older students if they'd mind sharing their outlines? We just had a whole outlining session with the academic counselors, and they mentioned it repeatedly, so it seems like that's common practice, but I just don't know any 2Ls or 3Ls I feel I could ask . . . but yet it seems like that's what each successive generation of 1Ls is supposed/expected to do?

Signed,

Fucking clueless and worried about winding up at the bottom of my class


I've yet to have anybody tell me I can't use their outline. Quite a few of the student groups have outlines, or if not, there are generally upperclassmen in that group who would be willing to share. The easiest way to ask is to find a connection with that person to get my foot in the door, then bring up school, then classes, then exams, then ask if they have any outlines because it would be really helpful to you as you study and make your own. Nobody is going to tell you no if they have some.

User avatar
archipm
Posts: 484
Joined: Mon Feb 01, 2016 11:05 am

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby archipm » Fri Nov 10, 2017 1:03 pm

Has anyone taken Oil & Gas with Helmholz? I'm on the fence for next term.

User avatar
Leo
Posts: 359
Joined: Thu Nov 14, 2013 5:58 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby Leo » Fri Nov 10, 2017 1:41 pm

archipm wrote:Has anyone taken Oil & Gas with Helmholz? I'm on the fence for next term.

Did you have him for property? If so, I see no reason to subject yourself to his brand of teaching (and grading). He's overrated. Funny? Obviously. Good teacher? Not so much.

User avatar
BlendedUnicorn
Posts: 8112
Joined: Sat Aug 27, 2016 2:40 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby BlendedUnicorn » Fri Nov 10, 2017 2:31 pm

Leo wrote:
archipm wrote:Has anyone taken Oil & Gas with Helmholz? I'm on the fence for next term.

Did you have him for property? If so, I see no reason to subject yourself to his brand of teaching (and grading). He's overrated. Funny? Obviously. Good teacher? Not so much.


Word on the street is that he's completely different in O&G. I never took it so can't say for sure but to the extent I have any regrets about law school that's kind of one of them.

User avatar
archipm
Posts: 484
Joined: Mon Feb 01, 2016 11:05 am

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby archipm » Fri Nov 10, 2017 8:54 pm

BlendedUnicorn wrote:
Leo wrote:
archipm wrote:Has anyone taken Oil & Gas with Helmholz? I'm on the fence for next term.

Did you have him for property? If so, I see no reason to subject yourself to his brand of teaching (and grading). He's overrated. Funny? Obviously. Good teacher? Not so much.


Word on the street is that he's completely different in O&G. I never took it so can't say for sure but to the extent I have any regrets about law school that's kind of one of them.


I did not have him for property and have been somewhat warned away from taking his classes, including by other faculty members. I'd like to take O&G for content reasons but also a) don't want to totally hate my life and b) don't want to tank my GPA. I guess I wondered if the negative parts of his reputation were overblown.

User avatar
Jaqen
Posts: 976
Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2012 6:23 am

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby Jaqen » Fri Nov 10, 2017 10:08 pm

archipm wrote:
BlendedUnicorn wrote:
Leo wrote:
archipm wrote:Has anyone taken Oil & Gas with Helmholz? I'm on the fence for next term.

Did you have him for property? If so, I see no reason to subject yourself to his brand of teaching (and grading). He's overrated. Funny? Obviously. Good teacher? Not so much.


Word on the street is that he's completely different in O&G. I never took it so can't say for sure but to the extent I have any regrets about law school that's kind of one of them.


I did not have him for property and have been somewhat warned away from taking his classes, including by other faculty members. I'd like to take O&G for content reasons but also a) don't want to totally hate my life and b) don't want to tank my GPA. I guess I wondered if the negative parts of his reputation were overblown.


I had O&G with him but not Property, so I can't compare. But the grading and workload was totally normal from what I remember.

User avatar
BlendedUnicorn
Posts: 8112
Joined: Sat Aug 27, 2016 2:40 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby BlendedUnicorn » Sat Nov 11, 2017 2:02 am

Jaqen wrote:
archipm wrote:
BlendedUnicorn wrote:
Leo wrote:
archipm wrote:Has anyone taken Oil & Gas with Helmholz? I'm on the fence for next term.

Did you have him for property? If so, I see no reason to subject yourself to his brand of teaching (and grading). He's overrated. Funny? Obviously. Good teacher? Not so much.


Word on the street is that he's completely different in O&G. I never took it so can't say for sure but to the extent I have any regrets about law school that's kind of one of them.


I did not have him for property and have been somewhat warned away from taking his classes, including by other faculty members. I'd like to take O&G for content reasons but also a) don't want to totally hate my life and b) don't want to tank my GPA. I guess I wondered if the negative parts of his reputation were overblown.


I had O&G with him but not Property, so I can't compare. But the grading and workload was totally normal from what I remember.


FWIW I enjoyed the shit out of hemoltz’s class and got a fine grade. My understanding is that there’s a second layer of curving th registrar does basically because of him.

But mostly who gives a shit. If you’re a 2 or 3 aL grades really don’t matter.

User avatar
landshoes
is that cool?
Posts: 1232
Joined: Mon Jan 09, 2012 2:17 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby landshoes » Sat Nov 11, 2017 10:02 am

call-me-bubbles wrote:Hi everyone; 1L here. I've joined a couple of low-key student orgs, but I haven't been active so far due to family commitments and simply trying to keep up with readings and survive cold-calls. I've already accessed some materials from the UChicago outline bank, but they're pretty limited for my courses, and my own outlines up to now look pathetic in comparison, so -- pardon the stupid question -- how do I go about asking the older students if they'd mind sharing their outlines? We just had a whole outlining session with the academic counselors, and they mentioned it repeatedly, so it seems like that's common practice, but I just don't know any 2Ls or 3Ls I feel I could ask . . . but yet it seems like that's what each successive generation of 1Ls is supposed/expected to do?

Signed,

Fucking clueless and worried about winding up at the bottom of my class


What outlines do you need? I'll hook you up if I can

I never outlined for shit and was NOT at the bottom of my class.

Remember: learn the material. Practice applying it. Everything else is noise.

Also I'm sorry my classmates freaked you out about outlining. It's really just rewriting your notes so you can review them.

User avatar
landshoes
is that cool?
Posts: 1232
Joined: Mon Jan 09, 2012 2:17 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby landshoes » Sat Nov 11, 2017 10:06 am

Also I sometimes refuse to share personal outlines because I think they're misleading, super short, or so disorganized that they won't help. If that happens don't worry. Some people don't outline as much. I sometimes just ctrl+f my notes during a test.

User avatar
beepboopbeep
Posts: 1336
Joined: Thu Oct 18, 2012 7:36 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby beepboopbeep » Sat Nov 11, 2017 11:22 am

landshoes wrote:
call-me-bubbles wrote:Hi everyone; 1L here. I've joined a couple of low-key student orgs, but I haven't been active so far due to family commitments and simply trying to keep up with readings and survive cold-calls. I've already accessed some materials from the UChicago outline bank, but they're pretty limited for my courses, and my own outlines up to now look pathetic in comparison, so -- pardon the stupid question -- how do I go about asking the older students if they'd mind sharing their outlines? We just had a whole outlining session with the academic counselors, and they mentioned it repeatedly, so it seems like that's common practice, but I just don't know any 2Ls or 3Ls I feel I could ask . . . but yet it seems like that's what each successive generation of 1Ls is supposed/expected to do?

Signed,

Fucking clueless and worried about winding up at the bottom of my class


What outlines do you need? I'll hook you up if I can

I never outlined for shit and was NOT at the bottom of my class.

Remember: learn the material. Practice applying it. Everything else is noise.

Also I'm sorry my classmates freaked you out about outlining. It's really just rewriting your notes so you can review them.


^^^
good advice

am graduated person
my experience was that two things mattered way more than outlining:
1- internalizing how shit worked enough to apply it - for me this came more through practice tests than outlining
2- not being a fucking basket case during exams, if you are relaxed and confident you'll do better even if you don't know the material as well

i know it is hard to do 2 if you don't feel like you can do 1, but these things are actually decouple-able and spending some time just relaxing and getting your mindset right, especially the night before/morning of but honestly just throughout because stress can pile up, is going to do a lot more for you in most cases than cramming. if you are furiously outlining right now you definitely don't need to be and can spare a couple nights a week doing fun non-law-school shit.

subpoint to 1: having a study group can be legit too if you aren't ready for practice tests. just answering other peoples' questions about stuff / explaining things that you get that they don't get / asking similar questions to them when the roles are reversed helps get you there where you can take cases/rules/fact patterns and apply them to other fact patterns. ask each other hypos and talk through them and i think preferably be comfortable enough to not just agree with everything people say because they're your friends or w/e

point 3, maybe? is that like, say right now you are panicking because your previous notes are worthless, they spend too much time on unimportant stuff and you can't easily pull out the important stuff now that you have an idea of what that is. notice that and change it going forward. better to have half a class's worth of good notes than a full quarter's of bad notes that are self-consistent. i felt like a lot of people just kinda stuck to what they were doing regardless of whether it worked for them and that was frustrating to observe.

landshoes wrote:Also I sometimes refuse to share personal outlines because I think they're misleading, super short, or so disorganized that they won't help. If that happens don't worry. Some people don't outline as much. I sometimes just ctrl+f my notes during a test.


This happened to me a few times and I just said I didn't outline for whatever class, which was true (seems different than refusing to share?)

User avatar
landshoes
is that cool?
Posts: 1232
Joined: Mon Jan 09, 2012 2:17 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby landshoes » Sat Nov 11, 2017 12:02 pm

beepboopbeep wrote:
landshoes wrote:
call-me-bubbles wrote:Hi everyone; 1L here. I've joined a couple of low-key student orgs, but I haven't been active so far due to family commitments and simply trying to keep up with readings and survive cold-calls. I've already accessed some materials from the UChicago outline bank, but they're pretty limited for my courses, and my own outlines up to now look pathetic in comparison, so -- pardon the stupid question -- how do I go about asking the older students if they'd mind sharing their outlines? We just had a whole outlining session with the academic counselors, and they mentioned it repeatedly, so it seems like that's common practice, but I just don't know any 2Ls or 3Ls I feel I could ask . . . but yet it seems like that's what each successive generation of 1Ls is supposed/expected to do?

Signed,

Fucking clueless and worried about winding up at the bottom of my class


What outlines do you need? I'll hook you up if I can

I never outlined for shit and was NOT at the bottom of my class.

Remember: learn the material. Practice applying it. Everything else is noise.

Also I'm sorry my classmates freaked you out about outlining. It's really just rewriting your notes so you can review them.


^^^
good advice

am graduated person
my experience was that two things mattered way more than outlining:
1- internalizing how shit worked enough to apply it - for me this came more through practice tests than outlining
2- not being a fucking basket case during exams, if you are relaxed and confident you'll do better even if you don't know the material as well

i know it is hard to do 2 if you don't feel like you can do 1, but these things are actually decouple-able and spending some time just relaxing and getting your mindset right, especially the night before/morning of but honestly just throughout because stress can pile up, is going to do a lot more for you in most cases than cramming. if you are furiously outlining right now you definitely don't need to be and can spare a couple nights a week doing fun non-law-school shit.

subpoint to 1: having a study group can be legit too if you aren't ready for practice tests. just answering other peoples' questions about stuff / explaining things that you get that they don't get / asking similar questions to them when the roles are reversed helps get you there where you can take cases/rules/fact patterns and apply them to other fact patterns. ask each other hypos and talk through them and i think preferably be comfortable enough to not just agree with everything people say because they're your friends or w/e

point 3, maybe? is that like, say right now you are panicking because your previous notes are worthless, they spend too much time on unimportant stuff and you can't easily pull out the important stuff now that you have an idea of what that is. notice that and change it going forward. better to have half a class's worth of good notes than a full quarter's of bad notes that are self-consistent. i felt like a lot of people just kinda stuck to what they were doing regardless of whether it worked for them and that was frustrating to observe.

landshoes wrote:Also I sometimes refuse to share personal outlines because I think they're misleading, super short, or so disorganized that they won't help. If that happens don't worry. Some people don't outline as much. I sometimes just ctrl+f my notes during a test.


This happened to me a few times and I just said I didn't outline for whatever class, which was true (seems different than refusing to share?)


That is prob what I will say in the future. I always get them an outline from elsewhere which hopefully indicates that I'm not just being a asshole, but you never know

User avatar
courtneylove
Posts: 134
Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2011 10:24 pm

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby courtneylove » Sat Nov 11, 2017 10:28 pm

archipm wrote:Has anyone taken Oil & Gas with Helmholz? I'm on the fence for next term.


I didn't have him for Property but I took two different classes with him during 2L and 3L, including OIl and Gas. Highly recommended... it's a great class. My grades were fine in both.

User avatar
archipm
Posts: 484
Joined: Mon Feb 01, 2016 11:05 am

Re: UChi Students & Alumni Taking Questions

Postby archipm » Sun Nov 12, 2017 1:43 am

courtneylove wrote:
archipm wrote:Has anyone taken Oil & Gas with Helmholz? I'm on the fence for next term.


I didn't have him for Property but I took two different classes with him during 2L and 3L, including OIl and Gas. Highly recommended... it's a great class. My grades were fine in both.


Thanks! This is helpful to hear.




Return to “Ask a Law Student / Graduate”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests