This was an applicant who had previously been offered 90k, then got off HLS waitlist, sent Chicago withdrawal email and got a Rubenstein as a reply. Interestingly, I quite similarly also had 90k at Chi, in off HLS waitlist, and sent Chi withdrawal email. I'd have taken a Ruby in a heartbeat, but their response to my email was:curiouscat wrote:Checking in!
I tried to withdraw earlier this week, and they responded by offering me a Ruby. Totally unexpected... but too incredible to pass up. So excited to be joining you all in Chicago this September.
"Dear xxx - Your application has been withdrawn."
Woops. I mean I ended up at HLS and am fine, but just saying this isn't a recommended bargaining tactic, even if it ended up golden for that other applicant.