Hey guys. I've done a lot of forum searching but can't find quite the answer I'm looking for.
How do you approach a commerce clause question? My professor says that we should only enlist the historic cases (Carter Coal through EC Knight) if they're factually similar to the question, so it seems to me that the way to approach it is to place the regulation/law into one of the three Lopez categories. Once you place it in a category, do you use the rational basis review level? We read the National Federation of Independent Businesses case (healthcare case) which seems to move away from that rational basis review, so would you discuss both a more limited scope of commerce power under that case and the rational basis deferential view?
Commerce clause question approach Forum
(Study Tips, Dealing With Stress, Maintaining a Social Life, Financial Aid, Internships, Bar Exam, Careers in Law . . . )
Return to “Forum for Law School Students”
Jump to
- Law School Admissions
- ↳ Law School Admissions Forum
- ↳ Law School Personal Statements
- ↳ LSAT Prep and Discussion Forum
- ↳ Law School Acceptances, Denials, and Waitlists
- ↳ Law School Visits
- ↳ Choosing a Law School
- ↳ What are my chances?
- ↳ Financial Aid
- ↳ Ask a Law Student / Graduate
- ↳ Transfers
- Law School
- ↳ Forum for Law School Students
- ↳ Ask a Law Student
- ↳ Non-US Law Schools Forum
- ↳ Bar Exam Prep and Discussion Forum
- ↳ Law School Courses
- Law School Class Forums
- ↳ TLS Class of 2025 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2024 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2023 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2022 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2021 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2020 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2019 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2018 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2017 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2016 Forum
- Legal Employment/Careers
- ↳ Legal Employment
- ↳ Judicial Clerkships
- ↳ OCI
- ↳ In-House
- ↳ Small & Midsized Firms
- ↳ 1st Year and 2nd Year Summer
- ↳ Big Law/Private Practice Jobs
- ↳ Public Interest & Government
- ↳ Alternative Careers
- ↳ Lateral Moves
- ↳ Interview Tips
- ↳ Resume Tips
- Underrepresented Lawyers and Students
- ↳ Black Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Hispanic and Latino Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Asian Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ American Indian Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Women Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ LGBTQ+ Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Disabled Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ First Generation Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Veteran Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Single Parent Lawyers and Law Students
- ↳ Underrepresented Law Students
- Legal Practice
- ↳ Forum for Law School Graduates Only
- ↳ Discussion of Practice Areas
- ↳ Legal News/Law Firm Gossip
- ↳ Firm Q&A by Region
- Legal Advice
- ↳ Free Help and Advice from Professionals
- Off-Topic
- ↳ Buy - Exchange - Giveaway - Sell
- ↳ TLS Content Competitions
- ↳ Other forums not on the main forum index page
- ↳ TLS Class of 2015 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2014 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2013 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2012 Forum
- ↳ TLS Class of 2011 Forum
- ↳ TLS wiki forum
- ↳ TLS Web Logs (Blogs)