Anonymous User wrote:wow. The T10 people are really dying for 'prestige'.....
I think the dilution occurs in state clerkships.
I know a lot of you do not think much of state courts. Many people with good/great grades I know are clerking in Massachusetts/RI/New York ... though.
Not sure what you're referring to with respect to "dilution." State court clerkships aren't valued by big law or the federal government as far as I know, so there's nothing to dilute. I've heard that state clerkships are very valuable for district
attorney jobs for that particular county, but DAs don't really care about grades or prestige anyway so there's no dilution to be had. You neither get a bonus for a state court clerkship (unless it is the highest appellate court of a state, usually called the state supreme court), nor federal seniority for a government position.
My firm, and most firms I'm aware of, does not give bonus to even magistrate clerkships. Very prestige-obsessed, and that's a sad thing, because magistrate clerkships are probably ten times more relevant to big law than federal appellate stints.
A second-year associate at my firm clerked for a state court of appeals judge. He came out of that experience a phenomenal writer - better than any of the firm's appellate clerks. Was he bonus'd? No. Why not? That's the shitty side of this profession. He has superior writing ability, knows exactly how the sausage of law is "made," and has the exact same skill sets coming out of his clerkship as the federal circuit clerks, but is $50k poorer.