Best time of day to interview when selecting OCI times? Forum

[Anonymous User]

I would love to hear everyone's thoughts on what they think the best time of day is to interview, and why, when scheduling interviews through the OCI process.

I prefer early morning so that the interviewer is fresh and hasn't gone through the same questions over and over. The hard part with this is creating a lasting impression.

[kurla88]

Not right before lunch.

[jarofsoup]

I have always thought that after lunch is the best time to interview. Like 1 or 2 pm.

[Aston2412]

When are you at your best?

I'm not a morning person. I know this and won't be scheduling interviews before 10 unless I absolutely have to.

[Sup Kid]

For what it's worth, I got a callback from the last firm that I interviewed with at the end of each day of OCI (~4pm). Besides just having lots of practice throughout the day and being relieved that the day was almost over, I found out at my firm this summer that interviewers normally have to make their selections immediately after finishing the interview process (ie. before the following morning). That makes me think that the people who they interviewed later are still in their mind when they are making decisions.

That said, it probably doesn't matter much at all -- have good grades and click with the interviewer, and you'll be fine. Just don't have the one right before lunch...

[dood]

last

[choochoo]

First or last-- they're more likely to remember you (recency/primacy effects)

[Cupidity]

I'd advise against first. If they think you are amazing, they'll question whether it was a genuine impression by the end of the day.

[Jack Smirks]

If you're signing up on a clipboard just erase the other names. I know it sounds like a scandalous method but it has helped me out a few times.

[Anonymous User]

why NOT before the lunch?

[vanwinkle]

why NOT before the lunch?

You want them to be thinking about you, and not about "oh man I need this to wrap up so I can go get lunch".

[Anonymous User]

why NOT before the lunch?

You want them to be thinking about you, and not about "oh man I need this to wrap up so I can go get lunch".

would they go over the morning sessions during relaxed lunch time and think more about the last person?
similarly, would they think more about the last few persons before the end of the day?

if it's suggested to go near the end of the day, why wouldn't interviewers want to rush and wrap up the day?

[NotMyRealName09]

Midafternoon, between 2 and 3 pm, are the WORST. Everyone gets sleepy and cranky. Avoid those spots.

[Anonymous User]

Midafternoon, between 2 and 3 pm, are the WORST. Everyone gets sleepy and cranky. Avoid those spots.

What if I have an interview in this time slot but it is directly following the most socially awkward person in the class? Do the benefits of looking good in comparison to someone who will surely blow his interview outweigh the interviewers crankiness?

[Cupidity]

Midafternoon, between 2 and 3 pm, are the WORST. Everyone gets sleepy and cranky. Avoid those spots.

What if I have an interview in this time slot but it is directly following the most socially awkward person in the class? Do the benefits of looking good in comparison to someone who will surely blow his interview outweigh the interviewers crankiness?

I dare you to pull this off.

[Anonymous User]

Midafternoon, between 2 and 3 pm, are the WORST. Everyone gets sleepy and cranky. Avoid those spots.

What if I have an interview in this time slot but it is directly following the most socially awkward person in the class? Do the benefits of looking good in comparison to someone who will surely blow his interview outweigh the interviewers crankiness?

I dare you to pull this off.

At my school we can see the list of who is interviewing when. My time slot is in the 2-3 range but the person interviewing right before me is terrible. I can't get into specifics but there is literally no way that he will not completely blow his interview in spectacular fashion. I feel like interviewing right after him would be a huge advantage. But it would put me in the 2-3 slot. There are open spots earlier in the day that I could take instead. What do?

[Anonymous User]

I signed up for the spot directly after lunch. I figured they would be refreshed and ready to go again. Right before lunch they will be cranky and thinking about what they want to eat. Also I felt like it was close enough to the end of the day that I'll be remembered. But now I'm nervous I picked bad times b/c of what you posted!

[Anonymous User]

2 CBs, both above my station, both in the morning before 10am at a job fair. I'm the complete opposite of a morning person. Read: it really doesn't matter. This is as bad as the OMG NOTHING BUT RED TIES ridiculousness in the clothing thread (but yeah still don't do them right before lunch). E.g. you're better off spacing them and giving yourself a break to refresh your memory about who's coming up next than trying to pack in 3 in a row because you or TLS has some notion that the sun aligns perfectly with Venus over your interview sight between 1:15 and 1:50 or some nonsense.

[Kilpatrick]

2 CBs, both above my station, both in the morning before 10am at a job fair. I'm the complete opposite of a morning person. Read: it really doesn't matter. This is as bad as the OMG NOTHING BUT RED TIES ridiculousness in the clothing thread (but yeah still don't do them right before lunch). E.g. you're better off spacing them and giving yourself a break to refresh your memory about who's coming up next than trying to pack in 3 in a row because you or TLS has some notion that the sun aligns perfectly with Venus over your interview sight between 1:15 and 1:50 or some nonsense.

I agree with you that it doesn't matter that much. But I think feedback in this thread would be helpful in the same way that I find the suit thread helpful. If someone has two ties they could wear its helpful to know that a conservative red tie is better than a yellow one, even if the amount that it is "better" is negligible. It helps that person make the decision. So if a person has two choices for an interview slot, its helpful to know stuff like what NotMyRealName posted.

[Anonymous User]

2 CBs, both above my station, both in the morning before 10am at a job fair. I'm the complete opposite of a morning person. Read: it really doesn't matter. This is as bad as the OMG NOTHING BUT RED TIES ridiculousness in the clothing thread (but yeah still don't do them right before lunch). E.g. you're better off spacing them and giving yourself a break to refresh your memory about who's coming up next than trying to pack in 3 in a row because you or TLS has some notion that the sun aligns perfectly with Venus over your interview sight between 1:15 and 1:50 or some nonsense.

I agree with you that it doesn't matter that much. But I think feedback in this thread would be helpful in the same way that I find the suit thread helpful. If someone has two ties they could wear its helpful to know that a conservative red tie is better than a yellow one, even if the amount that it is "better" is negligible. It helps that person make the decision. So if a person has two choices for an interview slot, its helpful to know stuff like what NotMyRealName posted.

Maybe. I think there are too many variables for it to matter, personally. Part of the reason I did well was because they were early and I wasn't worn out by long days. Wouldn't have picked the times offhand, because I either am or used to be non-functional in the morning. I just think there's no way to reliably assign percentages to this, and as a result you should do what you're most comfortable with while erring on the side of conservatism.

That said, in those two interviews... blue & silver paisley tie with medium grey 2 button, and solid darkish-silver tie with gunmetal blue three button and lightly striped French cuff shirt replete with some bitching cufflinks. Also one of my young interviewers had some sick links as well. What. Now. Fashionistas.

Problem?.jpg