Redacted Forum

[Curry]

.

[whymeohgodno]

NYU would be a better use of ED.

[Curry]

so its not that strong of a soft?

[nematoad]

If you're a one-time test taker i vote NYU as well. They average your LSAT(s).

[Curry]

.

[whymeohgodno]

so its not that strong of a soft?

Not really. Strong soft=Curing cancer, olympic medal, medal of honor, president's son, your daddy donated a library wing...

[LockBox]

I have a similar background although I used to play the clarinet. I want to write about my experience with music too. I'd love to take a look at your PS or bounce ideas around with you if you have any. Good luck.

[rundoxierun]

Not a strong soft at all I would think.. My gf is a music major so I know a bunch of music types. The worst percussionist in her performance program (so bad, teachers have recommended she leave the program) has played in Carnegie Hall. Nice thing to maybe fit in your PS as a unique experience but I doubt its a super soft.

[nematoad]

I think it's an pretty interesting soft--more intriguing than the average law student's and something adcoms might find interesting to read about--but i don't think itll be your meal ticket in anywhere. your lsat score on the other hand...

[Curry]

.

[nematoad]

Yup. One time test taker.

What if I get my GPA up to Columbia's 25th percentile? I'm applying next cycle. LSAT is 173.

Any response to this? Is it worth ED to Columbia then? Or should I keep the ED to NYU?

I assume you prefer Columbia and in that case I'd say ED there regardless of whether you make it over their 25th. Is it the prudent thing to do? Probably not. Your chances at NYU are definitely better. Aaaaand Ive probably failed in helping you.

[Curry]

Yup. One time test taker.

What if I get my GPA up to Columbia's 25th percentile? I'm applying next cycle. LSAT is 173.

Any response to this? Is it worth ED to Columbia then? Or should I keep the ED to NYU?

I assume you prefer Columbia and in that case I'd say ED there regardless of whether you make it over their 25th. Is it the prudent thing to do? Probably not. Your chances at NYU are definitely better. Aaaaand Ive probably failed in helping you.

Haha only slightly

I'm just deathly afraid of being shut out of CCN and I don't have much of a yearning to go to chicago. Columbia and NYU are almost equal for me. I might maybe just a tad prefer Columbia but I don't want to apply there if it risks getting shut out.

[nematoad]

Yup. One time test taker.

What if I get my GPA up to Columbia's 25th percentile? I'm applying next cycle. LSAT is 173.

Any response to this? Is it worth ED to Columbia then? Or should I keep the ED to NYU?

I assume you prefer Columbia and in that case I'd say ED there regardless of whether you make it over their 25th. Is it the prudent thing to do? Probably not. Your chances at NYU are definitely better. Aaaaand Ive probably failed in helping you.

Haha only slightly

I'm just deathly afraid of being shut out of CCN and I don't have much of a yearning to go to chicago. Columbia and NYU are almost equal for me. I might maybe just a tad prefer Columbia but I don't want to apply there if it risks getting shut out.

if they're almost equal then i say you gotta go with where you have the best shot.. Greenwich Village is very pretty in the winter.

[Curry]

This process is terrible. Its 9 months before when I start applying and I'm still worrying about it.... that and I need to find a job for this summer.

[albanach]

if they're almost equal then i say you gotta go with where you have the best shot.. Greenwich Village is very pretty in the winter.

If you're happy with both schools, why not apply ED to them both?

[Curry]

Because you can only apply ED to one school? By the time the first school's decision comes out, it will be too late to apply to the other one.

[trudat15]

if they're almost equal then i say you gotta go with where you have the best shot.. Greenwich Village is very pretty in the winter.

If you're happy with both schools, why not apply ED to them both?

Hope you're joking.

OP - you have 10 months to decide where to ED. Plenty of time. Just get your GPA up this year and see where you are when final numbers are at and after you visit both (if you can).

[nematoad]

This process is terrible. Its 9 months before when I start applying and I'm still worrying about it.... that and I need to find a job for this summer.

it's better than the waiting process. status checkers have become a part of my daily routine .

[Curry]

This process is terrible. Its 9 months before when I start applying and I'm still worrying about it.... that and I need to find a job for this summer.

it's better than the waiting process. status checkers have become a part of my daily routine .

Where are you applying? I'm sure you got in; you seem bright.

[nematoad]

If only seeming bright added 4 more points to my LSAT. wah wah. I applied from Berkeley to Fordham and about 12 schools in between. Got into to Fordham so far and so that's nice... I'm just hoping it gets nicer

[albanach]

Hope you're joking.

I wasn't really - I see that they both hold off on decisions until December which is unfortunate for the OP. I was thinking along the lines of some other T14 schools that give a decision inside a timescale that would allow you to ED at more than one school.

[birdlaw117]

I'm not sure that it is a great soft. However, I think it might be a great thing to either write your whole PS about, or just a portion of it. It is a very intriguing, unique, and prestigious honor. You should try to use this to your advantage in some way.

[Curry]

I'm not sure that it is a great soft. However, I think it might be a great thing to either write your whole PS about, or just a portion of it. It is a very intriguing, unique, and prestigious honor. You should try to use this to your advantage in some way.

Thats what I figured. I'm trying to figure out how to write about it, seeing as it happened quite a while back. I think I'm going to open with the performance. Talk about an injury that happened after it and how I've struggled to get back to playing form and tie that into law - how detail oriented music is and how learning each and every detail parallels at least to some extent the attention to detail that law requires.

[vanwinkle]

I suspect this would be a fairly strong soft for you, but the problem with softs are that they really only act as tiebreakers; they have to already like you based on your numbers enough that a "soft" would help them pick you over someone else. Not only that, but lots and lots of people with "strong softs" are applying to the top law schools. So while this might be strong I don't think it's stronger than a lot of the other applicants they're probably getting. Your PS might help it stand out more, though; a lot will just depend on how well-written your PS is.

The good news is you have a strong LSAT score, so that works in your favor. If I'm reading this right your LSAT should be just above median for Columbia, so I don't see an ED there being unreasonable. It's a longer shot than NYU, but I think you might get into NYU RD. If you're willing to gamble at all, I'd ED Columbia. If you really, really want to make sure you're attending one of these schools next fall and want the safe choice, I'd ED to NYU.

[Curry]

.