Page 1 of 2

#1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:09 pm
by davidcasaletto
The person who ranks #1 at Cornell, would they be competitive for the best Federal clerkships; Top COA, SCOTUS, etc. Top 50 law firms as well.

Or is Cornell too low ranked/ regional to really allow competition with HYS etc? Any insight on this would be helpful.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:11 pm
by Hand
Somebody get this guy some candy and a pat on the head

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:13 pm
by abl
Yes. #1 at most first tier schools is going to be competitive for just about any position in the country.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:13 pm
by FSK
Here's some insight: you sound insane asking a question like this.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:15 pm
by Winter is Coming
For realz?

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:17 pm
by KMart
Winter is Coming wrote:For realz?

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:17 pm
by davidcasaletto
Just trying to make sure I understand, thanks guys, keep the thoughts coming.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:23 pm
by Winter is Coming
Dude c'mon of course the number one student at any T14 will have basically the same options as the top of the class at HYS and better options then the students at median there. If anything it'll help because of the small class size at Cornell it may be easier to find professors/deans who are really willing to go to bat for you.

Also the selectivity between the things you mentioned is wildly different. SCOTUS clerk is not something anyone should think about until they are at the top of their class.

V50 is obviously an attainable goal from any of the T14.

What are you looking for here?

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:27 pm
by davidcasaletto
Winter is Coming wrote:Dude c'mon of course the number one student at any T14 will have basically the same options as the top of the class at HYS and better options then the students at median there. If anything it'll help because of the small class size at Cornell it may be easier to find professors/deans who are really willing to go to bat for you.

Also the selectivity between the things you mentioned is wildly different. SCOTUS clerk is not something anyone should think about until they are at the top of their class.

V50 is obviously an attainable goal from any of the T14.

What are you looking for here?
An understanding of the ceiling of opportunity at Cornell.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:32 pm
by RunnerRunner
davidcasaletto wrote:
Winter is Coming wrote:Dude c'mon of course the number one student at any T14 will have basically the same options as the top of the class at HYS and better options then the students at median there. If anything it'll help because of the small class size at Cornell it may be easier to find professors/deans who are really willing to go to bat for you.

Also the selectivity between the things you mentioned is wildly different. SCOTUS clerk is not something anyone should think about until they are at the top of their class.

V50 is obviously an attainable goal from any of the T14.

What are you looking for here?
An understanding of the ceiling of opportunity at Cornell.
My impression is that ceilings aren't really an issue for the top student at any T14. Differences in employment outcomes become more significant the further down you are in your class (e.g. median at Cornell has nowhere near the same opportunities as median at YHS). But if you are literally number 1 at Cornell you can pretty much write your own ticket.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:33 pm
by ballcaps
davidcasaletto wrote:
Winter is Coming wrote:Dude c'mon of course the number one student at any T14 will have basically the same options as the top of the class at HYS and better options then the students at median there. If anything it'll help because of the small class size at Cornell it may be easier to find professors/deans who are really willing to go to bat for you.

Also the selectivity between the things you mentioned is wildly different. SCOTUS clerk is not something anyone should think about until they are at the top of their class.

V50 is obviously an attainable goal from any of the T14.

What are you looking for here?
An understanding of the ceiling of opportunity at Cornell.
what you're actually asking is: are there any opportunities available exclusively to HYS kids?

the answer is "not really." the possibilities exist everywhere (in the t14); the issue is probability.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:35 pm
by envisciguy
The #1 person at Cornell will have pretty much any opportunities they want, provided there's not something terribly wrong with them.

OP, I REALLY hope you're not asking this because you're planning on being #1 in your class, though I'm fairly certain you are.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:36 pm
by davidcasaletto
envisciguy wrote:The #1 person at Cornell will have pretty much any opportunities they want, provided there's not something terribly wrong with them.

OP, I REALLY hope you're not asking this because you're planning on being #1 in your class, though I'm fairly certain you are.
;]

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:36 pm
by King Cayuga
davidcasaletto wrote:
Winter is Coming wrote:Dude c'mon of course the number one student at any T14 will have basically the same options as the top of the class at HYS and better options then the students at median there. If anything it'll help because of the small class size at Cornell it may be easier to find professors/deans who are really willing to go to bat for you.

Also the selectivity between the things you mentioned is wildly different. SCOTUS clerk is not something anyone should think about until they are at the top of their class.

V50 is obviously an attainable goal from any of the T14.

What are you looking for here?
An understanding of the ceiling of opportunity at Cornell.
You should start preparing your SCOTUS clerkship applications now. I heard Justice Kagan favors applicants with ESP.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:37 pm
by starry eyed
the butthurt is running deep in this thread

eta: nvmd just saw his other thread

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:37 pm
by abl
davidcasaletto wrote:
Winter is Coming wrote:Dude c'mon of course the number one student at any T14 will have basically the same options as the top of the class at HYS and better options then the students at median there. If anything it'll help because of the small class size at Cornell it may be easier to find professors/deans who are really willing to go to bat for you.

Also the selectivity between the things you mentioned is wildly different. SCOTUS clerk is not something anyone should think about until they are at the top of their class.

V50 is obviously an attainable goal from any of the T14.

What are you looking for here?
An understanding of the ceiling of opportunity at Cornell.
There is little-to-no ceiling. The #1 student at Cornell will be competitive for the vast majority of clerkships (including for most feeders), as well as just about all other highly competitive positions. There are a very select few judges/employers who hire just from HYS and occasionally one or two other schools (like Alshuler Berzon -- HYS + Berkeley, I believe) that you probably won't have a shot at. But we're talking really just exceptions to the general rule.

I suspect the biggest ceiling is SCOTUS. Practically speaking, you're probably not going to get a Supreme Court clerkship out of Cornell (even as #1 in the class).

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:38 pm
by kaiser
Your insecurity is the only thing that would hold you back.

First in the class at Cornell can do literally anything in the legal field. Even a Supreme Court clerkship isn't entirely out of the realm of possibility.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:42 pm
by bearsfan23
Harvard is more prestigious

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:52 pm
by starry eyed
#1 Harvard is better

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:52 pm
by Winter is Coming
V32 is the ceiling for Cornell.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:53 pm
by CanadianWolf
No, because they all transfer to Harvard or Yale ?

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:55 pm
by Winter is Coming
All joking aside our transfer out situation is kind of weird. There are a few H kids and sometimes Y, but a surprising amount of medianish kids transfer to NYU. I guess some people really do hate Ithaca and if you're not giving up money here, might as well live your life.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:57 pm
by davidcasaletto
Winter is Coming wrote:All joking aside our transfer out situation is kind of weird. There are a few H kids and sometimes Y, but a surprising amount of medianish kids transfer to NYU. I guess some people really do hate Ithaca and if you're not giving up money here, might as well live your life.
I wouldn't want to transfer because I got a very good scholarship (to me) for Cornell, and from my understanding transfer scholarships are rare and not as substantial..If I can reach competitive levels with the t6 by being top of the class at Cornell then I'd prefer to stay here for 13k a year instead of 50k at NYU...why do people transfer?

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 4:59 pm
by Desert Fox
davidcasaletto wrote:
Winter is Coming wrote:All joking aside our transfer out situation is kind of weird. There are a few H kids and sometimes Y, but a surprising amount of medianish kids transfer to NYU. I guess some people really do hate Ithaca and if you're not giving up money here, might as well live your life.
I wouldn't want to transfer because I got a very good scholarship (to me) for Cornell, and from my understanding transfer scholarships are rare and not as substantial..If I can reach competitive levels with the t6 by being top of the class at Cornell then I'd prefer to stay here for 13k a year instead of 50k at NYU...why do people transfer?
You are falsely assuming that they are making a logic choice.

Re: #1 student at Cornell competitive against HYS etc?

Posted: Mon Apr 20, 2015 5:01 pm
by Mack.Hambleton
davidcasaletto wrote:
Winter is Coming wrote:All joking aside our transfer out situation is kind of weird. There are a few H kids and sometimes Y, but a surprising amount of medianish kids transfer to NYU. I guess some people really do hate Ithaca and if you're not giving up money here, might as well live your life.
I wouldn't want to transfer because I got a very good scholarship (to me) for Cornell, and from my understanding transfer scholarships are rare and not as substantial..If I can reach competitive levels with the t6 by being top of the class at Cornell then I'd prefer to stay here for 13k a year instead of 50k at NYU...why do people transfer?
if they're paying sticker at both