Detroit Market Forum
- enteringthemaze
- Posts: 73
- Joined: Fri Oct 31, 2014 3:38 pm
Detroit Market
Hey, looking for some advice regarding school choice. I ultimately want to end up in the Detroit area. I have very strong ties to the Southeastern Michigan, including an undergrad degree from UofM. I'd be fine with going out of state for law school, but ultimately would like to come back home. I've gotten full tuition offers from Wayne and MSU. About half tuition at places like IU and Minnesota. Plus, I've been accepted to GULC. I'm still waiting on a few schools, but I am trying to begin my decision making process. While keeping my debt in check is obviously an important factor, I ultimately want to attend the school that would give me the best shot at top Detroit firms and a good quality of life post law school. Thanks!
- superpatton
- Posts: 88
- Joined: Thu Sep 04, 2014 6:41 pm
Re: Detroit Market
I assume you've got an application out to Michigan, because that might be your best option.
http://www.lstscorereports.com/state/MI/
That link should give you some information about the employment stats of schools in Michigan. What was your LSAT score and would you be able to retake for options? Just remember that sitting out a cycle might not be a horrible idea depending on your exact situation.
http://www.lstscorereports.com/state/MI/
That link should give you some information about the employment stats of schools in Michigan. What was your LSAT score and would you be able to retake for options? Just remember that sitting out a cycle might not be a horrible idea depending on your exact situation.
- bugsy33
- Posts: 271
- Joined: Thu Feb 13, 2014 9:04 pm
Re: Detroit Market
Michigan has a really difficult market right now. It's really insular, in that most firms hire Wayne/MSU/UofD, but none of those schools give you a good chance of actually getting a legal job. It's kind of a quandary. The only way to effectively guarantee Michigan employment is to go to UofM, but that's off limits for ~95% of law applicants. Most of the great, but not elite, applicants are pushed out of state to other B1G schools + ND. I've heard of some people making it back, but it's not easy. So your options are basically
1.) Get into UMich Law somehow
2.) Get into some other T-14 and hope you can get back
3.) Get into a T1 B1G/ND and hope you can get back
4.) Take a full ride to Wayne/MSU and flip a coin on legal employment and hope you didn't waste 3 years of hard work.
5.) Give up on the Michigan market and go to just follow the traditional TLS wisdom of LST+$$$+Ties.
1.) Get into UMich Law somehow
2.) Get into some other T-14 and hope you can get back
3.) Get into a T1 B1G/ND and hope you can get back
4.) Take a full ride to Wayne/MSU and flip a coin on legal employment and hope you didn't waste 3 years of hard work.
5.) Give up on the Michigan market and go to just follow the traditional TLS wisdom of LST+$$$+Ties.
-
- Posts: 2777
- Joined: Sat Apr 02, 2011 12:19 pm
Re: Detroit Market
You're in the same boat as many other students, which is that you want to work in a regional market that has been savaged by the recession, you'd prefer high-paying work, but you have a good scholly to local schools that place mainly in jobs paying 40-55K. You probably won't get the top Michigan jobs without going to Michigan. Those schools both have about a 50% chance of getting you a job at a small firm or with the local government (maybe more like 60% with the lowered class sizes in three years). I think you're going to have to determine whether you really want a shot at a 100K+ job (in which case a T14 is really your only option) or you'd be happy with minimal debt and a lower salary.enteringthemaze wrote:Hey, looking for some advice regarding school choice. I ultimately want to end up in the Detroit area. I have very strong ties to the Southeastern Michigan, including an undergrad degree from UofM. I'd be fine with going out of state for law school, but ultimately would like to come back home. I've gotten full tuition offers from Wayne and MSU. About half tuition at places like IU and Minnesota. Plus, I've been accepted to GULC. I'm still waiting on a few schools, but I am trying to begin my decision making process. While keeping my debt in check is obviously an important factor, I ultimately want to attend the school that would give me the best shot at top Detroit firms and a good quality of life post law school. Thanks!
- cron1834
- Posts: 2299
- Joined: Thu Jan 02, 2014 1:36 am
Re: Detroit Market
Retake until you get into Michigan.
Want to continue reading?
Register now to search topics and post comments!
Absolutely FREE!
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 1474
- Joined: Fri Mar 14, 2014 9:00 pm
Re: Detroit Market
Yes. With the mindset that you may have to get a job elsewhere in the midwest or NYC.cron1834 wrote:Retake until you get into Michigan.
- enteringthemaze
- Posts: 73
- Joined: Fri Oct 31, 2014 3:38 pm
Re: Detroit Market
Yes, I have an app in at Michigan. But it really doesn't seem like Michigan places well in state either. While I'd love to go there, I'd rather make less money than end up in NYC. I'm one of those rather be unemployed than go the NYC route people. Ultimately, I'd be fine with a smaller firm since my Michigan COL during law school will be essentially nothing as I have a SO who works in MI. So, really I suppose would Wayne State or Michigan State ultimately serve me better? Or is going to a T1 Big Ten school better than staying in state?
-
- Posts: 363
- Joined: Sun Nov 03, 2013 11:56 am
Re: Detroit Market
the best assumption when picking schools is that you will be at median, so look where those people go. And honestly, median at michigan from what I see is not a guaranteed spot at a top Detroit firm. If you know you only want to work in detroit and you can get into michigan then it might be worth it to take a full ride at Wayne. But Wayne over MSU for sure.
- Dog
- Posts: 371
- Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 1:00 am
Re: Detroit Market
I have never agreed with this TLS idea. OP has a full ride to Wayne/MSU, I highly doubt the median result for full ride students at schools is to finish median. As it stands, I think your best option is Wayne State on a full ride. That said, I have heard of some pretty terrible stipulation results for scholarships there. Check out this page:umichman wrote:the best assumption when picking schools is that you will be at median, so look where those people go. And honestly, median at michigan from what I see is not a guaranteed spot at a top Detroit firm. If you know you only want to work in detroit and you can get into michigan then it might be worth it to take a full ride at Wayne. But Wayne over MSU for sure.
http://law.wayne.edu/about/retention.php
The numbers were particularly bleak for scholarship retention in 2012-2013 although they rebounded a bit. In addition, you will need to perform pretty well at Wayne to grab one of the jobs you want. I definitely agree Wayne > MSU for Detroit, and I'm an MSU undergrad.
If you get into Michigan that could be great, but if you have to pay sticker there's actually a decent chance your outcome from Wayne might be better if you stay in Detroit imo. Full repayment at UM is $3k+ per month for ten years, and you might end up working a similar job. Of course, Michigan gives you better chances at those jobs. I do NOT think going to Big Ten schools like Indiana/Iowa/Illinois/Ohio State/etc. would be worth it if you're dead set on Michigan, especially if they gave you more debt. Notre Dame and Northwestern might beat out Wayne, but the debt loads would be far greater. If GULC is sticker, I would probably stick with Wayne. That's me though.
- Tiago Splitter
- Posts: 17148
- Joined: Tue Jun 28, 2011 1:20 am
Re: Detroit Market
115/488 students at Wayne get full tuition or more, according to the 509. Even if those students uniformly finish at the top of the class OP is only guaranteed top quarter or so, which does absolutely nothing at places where grades matter.Dog wrote:OP has a full ride to Wayne/MSU, I highly doubt the median result for full ride students at schools is to finish median.
- Ron Don Volante
- Posts: 899
- Joined: Wed Nov 05, 2014 2:26 pm
Re: Detroit Market
Dog wrote:umichman wrote:the best assumption when picking schools is that you will be at median, so look where those people go. And honestly, median at michigan from what I see is not a guaranteed spot at a top Detroit firm. If you know you only want to work in detroit and you can get into michigan then it might be worth it to take a full ride at Wayne. But Wayne over MSU for sure.I have never agreed with this TLS idea. OP has a full ride to Wayne/MSU, I highly doubt the median result for full ride students at schools is to finish median. As it stands, I think your best option is Wayne State on a full ride.
- Dog
- Posts: 371
- Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 1:00 am
Re: Detroit Market
I wasn't trying to say OP is going to for sure finish at the top of the class. I was simply saying I disagree with the median assumption. Whether that does anything for outcomes in this case is another argument entirely.Tiago Splitter wrote:115/488 students at Wayne get full tuition or more, according to the 509. Even if those students uniformly finish at the top of the class OP is only guaranteed top quarter or so, which does absolutely nothing at places where grades matter.Dog wrote:OP has a full ride to Wayne/MSU, I highly doubt the median result for full ride students at schools is to finish median.
Speaking of that argument, I would also disagree that top quarter at Wayne does nothing for you over median. If OP was hypothetically guaranteed top quarter like you mentioned, OP's median result would be top 12.5%. 9.8% of Wayne students got biglaw in the most recent statistics. If this was totally dependent on grades and no one outside the top 25% gets biglaw, OP would have close to a 40% chance at it. Of course, this hypothetical is not the case. Top quarter sure as hell beats the middle 25-50% though, on average.
I don't think the OP can optimistically predict a great outcome, but the assume median assumption is flawed.
Last edited by Dog on Fri Jan 23, 2015 1:46 pm, edited 7 times in total.
-
- Posts: 25
- Joined: Wed Aug 06, 2014 12:08 am
Re: Detroit Market
I think the numbers could be misleading you a bit since most Michigan Law students probably aren't looking to stay in Michigan in the first place.enteringthemaze wrote:...But it really doesn't seem like Michigan places well in state either...
Register now!
Resources to assist law school applicants, students & graduates.
It's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
- CaptainJapan
- Posts: 375
- Joined: Mon Jun 09, 2014 9:53 pm
Re: Detroit Market
KingsleyZissou wrote:I think the numbers could be misleading you a bit since most Michigan Law students probably aren't looking to stay in Michigan in the first place.enteringthemaze wrote:...But it really doesn't seem like Michigan places well in state either...
This is what I've heard to be true. I have ties in the Detroit area and most of the lawyers I've spoken with have said that applicants from t14 are a hot commodity lately. Most U of M kids leave the state...most other t14 grads aren't flocking to Detroit.
- star fox
- Posts: 20790
- Joined: Fri Feb 01, 2013 4:13 pm
Re: Detroit Market
Well, and http://www.crainsdetroit.com/assets/PDF/CD97174117.PDFKingsleyZissou wrote:I think the numbers could be misleading you a bit since most Michigan Law students probably aren't looking to stay in Michigan in the first place.enteringthemaze wrote:...But it really doesn't seem like Michigan places well in state either...
- enteringthemaze
- Posts: 73
- Joined: Fri Oct 31, 2014 3:38 pm
Re: Detroit Market
So, going to a T-14 to work in Detroit big law seems financially questionable since Detroit pays about 50K less than other areas of the country and T-14 debt at sticker (or close to sticker) is very high. Is Wayne State really a lost cause for somebody from Michigan who wants to stay in Michigan?
- Tiago Splitter
- Posts: 17148
- Joined: Tue Jun 28, 2011 1:20 am
Re: Detroit Market
Going to T-14 for Detroit big law is a bad move because there aren't a lot of Detroit big law jobs. But if you don't get one you can just get one in NYC for a few years. If you go to Wayne State you can't expect big law, but it's okay if you just plan to work in small law in the area and take on very little debt.enteringthemaze wrote:So, going to a T-14 to work in Detroit big law seems financially questionable since Detroit pays about 50K less than other areas of the country and T-14 debt at sticker (or close to sticker) is very high. Is Wayne State really a lost cause for somebody from Michigan who wants to stay in Michigan?
Get unlimited access to all forums and topics
Register now!
I'm pretty sure I told you it's FREE...
Already a member? Login
-
- Posts: 363
- Joined: Sun Nov 03, 2013 11:56 am
Re: Detroit Market
Do any of you have any experience of going to Mich and then trying to go midsize law in detroit?
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2015 8:24 pm
Re: Detroit Market
- Midsize/Detroit BigLaw is very doable from umich. Do not let lower placement numbers relative to other Michigan law schools fool you. Many umich students self select out of Detroit market or are not desirable to firms because of their lack of ties. Umich students with strong Michigan ties at median, and even a little below, are favored over the vast majority of MSU/WSU/UofD students. Students at these schools must have outstanding credentials and be at the very top of their classes to have a chance at Detroit Big Law. And when I say top of their class, I literally mean top 5 or 6 people at each school.
- The top firms in Detroit seem to be doing well financially. However, this has not translated into larger summer associate classes. The top 5 or 6 firms have classes between 6-12 per year. So far, firms have favored lateral hiring over increasing summer class sizes.
- If you are from Michigan, and went to U of M for undergrad, you will remain an attractive candidate for Detroit. The problem is that it will require a lot of legwork on your end because your school will not be a natural pipeline for Detroit firms. You will need to contact hiring partners, remain in contact, etc. Every year students summer from out of state schools, but they all have strong ties. Firms seem to apply similar criteria to Michigan to other T-14 students. Around median, will make you competitive. For the higher ranked Big Ten + ND and other midwest T-30 schools you will need to be better, I'd guess top 1/4.
- If you want Detroit, Michigan is the clear choice. With your strong ties other T-14 schools would be a solid choice as well. At WSU/UofD/MSU you will have to do outstanding to have a shot at Detroit Big Law. Of course, at full ride this will be at little financial cost, but you will be giving up better placement. A degree from those schools would also virtually lock you into Michigan/Detroit where the dropoff in pay/prestige/exit options from Big Law to other legal jobs is massive. If you want Detroit Big Law, WSU/UofD/MSU is a tough route to get there. A T-14 school would allow you the ability to work in another city and lateral back, and a much better shot at Detroit directly.
- The top firms in Detroit seem to be doing well financially. However, this has not translated into larger summer associate classes. The top 5 or 6 firms have classes between 6-12 per year. So far, firms have favored lateral hiring over increasing summer class sizes.
- If you are from Michigan, and went to U of M for undergrad, you will remain an attractive candidate for Detroit. The problem is that it will require a lot of legwork on your end because your school will not be a natural pipeline for Detroit firms. You will need to contact hiring partners, remain in contact, etc. Every year students summer from out of state schools, but they all have strong ties. Firms seem to apply similar criteria to Michigan to other T-14 students. Around median, will make you competitive. For the higher ranked Big Ten + ND and other midwest T-30 schools you will need to be better, I'd guess top 1/4.
- If you want Detroit, Michigan is the clear choice. With your strong ties other T-14 schools would be a solid choice as well. At WSU/UofD/MSU you will have to do outstanding to have a shot at Detroit Big Law. Of course, at full ride this will be at little financial cost, but you will be giving up better placement. A degree from those schools would also virtually lock you into Michigan/Detroit where the dropoff in pay/prestige/exit options from Big Law to other legal jobs is massive. If you want Detroit Big Law, WSU/UofD/MSU is a tough route to get there. A T-14 school would allow you the ability to work in another city and lateral back, and a much better shot at Detroit directly.
-
- Posts: 89
- Joined: Fri Jan 11, 2008 11:41 pm
Re: Detroit Market
1) UMich if you're admitted; 1a) Wayne State full ride; 2) GULC if you desperately want to live in DC and don't mind risking your long-term plan of living in Detroit (which might be jeopardized if you don't score really well at GULC).
-
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2015 12:32 am
Re: Detroit Market
I lived in Michigan for awhile.
Your best bet, would be go to U Michigan.
Michigan State is not going to do you any good in the Detroit area because of Wayne State is the preferred school and is local and tied with MSU in rankings. Wayne will always win.
Other than U Michigan, a t14 is not worth it if your coming back to Detroit and I recommend staying in the state.
Short answer: go to Wayne State.
Your best bet, would be go to U Michigan.
Michigan State is not going to do you any good in the Detroit area because of Wayne State is the preferred school and is local and tied with MSU in rankings. Wayne will always win.
Other than U Michigan, a t14 is not worth it if your coming back to Detroit and I recommend staying in the state.
Short answer: go to Wayne State.
Communicate now with those who not only know what a legal education is, but can offer you worthy advice and commentary as you complete the three most educational, yet challenging years of your law related post graduate life.
Register now, it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login
- dsn32
- Posts: 436
- Joined: Sun May 01, 2011 3:40 pm
Re: Detroit Market
Feel free to PM me OP. Current Penn student who will be SA'ing in MI this summer (though not in Detroit). I've interviewed with pretty much all the firms and can tell you my experience coming from a non-Umich t-14.
- dsn32
- Posts: 436
- Joined: Sun May 01, 2011 3:40 pm
Re: Detroit Market
I should add too......if you want to be a lawyer above being geographically picky in the short term...do GULC. If you want to be in MI over all...go to Michigan or another t14....or don't go. I know a lot of struggles from people out of the other schools in MI. It's a dangerous gamble.
-
- Posts: 700
- Joined: Thu Feb 27, 2014 2:06 am
Re: Detroit Market
Going to Michigan at full tuition is crazy. Median at Michigan hardly guarantees a job at a top firm in Detroit ... there just aren't that many spots to go around. In fact, I'm of the mind that one of the biggest thing bringing Michigan's employment numbers down is the number of students who bid on places like Detroit when they should be bidding where the jobs are, New York. And even if you get a biglaw job in Detroit you're paying $3,000+ per month.
At the same time, you're chances of getting a biglaw job in Detroit out of Michigan State or Wayne State is pretty bad. Your chance of not finding legal employment is real.
I think you have to either decide that (a)getting a 50k/yr job in a small firm is fine and go to Wayne State, (b) retake the LSAT, or (c) give up on law school.
At the same time, you're chances of getting a biglaw job in Detroit out of Michigan State or Wayne State is pretty bad. Your chance of not finding legal employment is real.
I think you have to either decide that (a)getting a 50k/yr job in a small firm is fine and go to Wayne State, (b) retake the LSAT, or (c) give up on law school.
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Sat Feb 07, 2015 8:24 pm
Re: Detroit Market
I think all the advice given here is pretty on point. Just want to underscore that median at Michigan/T-14 will make you competitive- not guarantee you a job. Detroit firms turn down competitive people all the time. There are so few spots relative to interest in the current Summer Associate classes in Detroit.
I do want to underscore the ability to lateral back to Detroit. If you are willing to work in Chicago/NYC/DC first, then you will be an attractive candidate later. This is why I would favor other T-14's as well, even if you can't get a Detroit gig out of the gate. Lateral hiring is the current trend with the big firms in Detroit, T-14 schools would help you get back to Detroit later. The "I wanted to come home and help the city come back" narrative and Big Law lateral hiring is very common in the big Detroit firms. However, there is virtually no hiring from the pool of local non biglaw or small shop attorneys. Like other posters have said, this is what makes Wayne/MSU/etc so dangerous. If you miss Detroit you're virtually done. But if you miss at a T-14, you will still have a great shot at BigLaw NYC/Chicago/etc and lateral back.
I do want to underscore the ability to lateral back to Detroit. If you are willing to work in Chicago/NYC/DC first, then you will be an attractive candidate later. This is why I would favor other T-14's as well, even if you can't get a Detroit gig out of the gate. Lateral hiring is the current trend with the big firms in Detroit, T-14 schools would help you get back to Detroit later. The "I wanted to come home and help the city come back" narrative and Big Law lateral hiring is very common in the big Detroit firms. However, there is virtually no hiring from the pool of local non biglaw or small shop attorneys. Like other posters have said, this is what makes Wayne/MSU/etc so dangerous. If you miss Detroit you're virtually done. But if you miss at a T-14, you will still have a great shot at BigLaw NYC/Chicago/etc and lateral back.
Seriously? What are you waiting for?
Now there's a charge.
Just kidding ... it's still FREE!
Already a member? Login