booboo wrote:birdlaw117 wrote:booboo wrote:birdlaw, since you seem invested in this conversation, you could try counting the amount of people that went into a firm from the file that lists positions at firms.
I've done it once but cannot remember the numbers.
I could. But that wouldn't really prove or show anything, since it would be moving in the opposite direction of Campos' discrepancy. I just look at it as proof that this is not as simple as everyone is trying to make it. There are multiple moving parts and without knowing exactly how all of the data is collected, trying to reconcile it futile.
I agree. And those numbers are SA positions anyway. My only contribution is that I don't think NYU is attempting to deceive anyone.
Agreed. I'm curious about what the reason is, but I don't actually care. It's not like NYU, CLS and HLS got together and decided to deceive people in the same way.